Wikipedia

User:Significa liberdade/EFA

< User:Significa liberdade

Under construction

If you see mistakes, feel free to correct them. If you want to help fill the table out, chime in.

Candidate Nom Q1 Q2 Q3 Thoughts
Ahecht Self nom:

wbm1058:

  • Technical move requests
  • Clean block log
  • No noticeboard drama
  • Move requests for fully protected pages
  • G6 deletion
  • Templates
  • User scripts
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Good AfD record[a]
  • High trust perms: AP, NPP, PM, TE[b]
AntiDionysius Self nom:
  • Rollback
  • Pending changes reviewer
  • Recent changes patrol
  • Welcoming new editors
  • Block vandals (Europe time zone)
  • Protect articles
  • Speedy delete (removed G11)
  • Anti-vandalism
 CTOP issue Oct. 2023 (no link)
  • Good AfD record
  • Low content creation
  • Doesn't always archive critical talk page comments
Bastun
  • Long-term editor (2005)
  • Improve articles
  • Revert vandalism
  • NPP (January)
  • PROD
  • CSD
  • AIV (anti-vandalism)
  • ANI re:Troubles (Ireland)
  • Good AfD record
  • Low content creation
  • Doesn't always archive critical talk page comments
  • Sometimes snappy edit summaries when deleting hate speech
DoubleGrazing
  • NPP --> AfD, SPI, vandalism
  • WIRED
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Excellent AfD record
  • High trust perms: AP, NPP, PM
  • Nom offer from Ingenuity
Dr vulpes

Femke co-nom

  • CSD
  • Page protection
  • PERM
  • Described specific
  • High trust perms: NPP, PM
EggRoll97
  • View deleted revisions
  • AIV
  • No specifics, short
  • Bad AfD record, but AfD isn't everything
  • Edit count < 8,000
  • Low content creation
  • High-trust perms: Edit filter manager, global edit filter helper, NPP, PM
FOARP
  • Collaborative work
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Excellent AfD record
  • theleekycauldron offered to nom for RFA
  • Ritchie encouraged running
  • High-trust perms: PM
Frost
  • Recept change patrol
  • Revert and report vandalism
  • Identify and tag spam
  • Report socks
  • Username violation
  • Change patrol
  • Block
  • Delete
  • Protect
  • Revdel
  • Histmerge
  • Linkspam
  • Almost all edits from this year, many automated
  • ~8k edits
  • Good AfD record
  • High-trust perms: PM
Hawkeye7
  • Former admin
  • Desysoped (no link): privileges removed 12 years ago via "knee-jerk admin actions" in Arbcom
  • Skirted around answering question about why they didn't mention two failed RFAs (2016, 2019)
  • Iffy AfD record
Iwaqarhashmi
  • Anti-vandalism (AIV, UAA)
  • Recent change patrol
  • Sept. NPP drive
  • No specifics
  • Got offended by someone saying he might be a hatcollector based on evidence
Knightoftheswords281
  • Have engaged in conflict, no discussion of resolve
  • Good AfD record
  • Edit count under 8,000
  • <1k edits past year
  • Low content creation
Leonidlednev
  • Anti-vandalism
  • Bad AfD record, but AfD isn't everything
  • No articles created
LindsayH
  • Alt accounts: Kahtar, Rhydypennau, and Rhubarb Bikini
  • "I do not have a 'need for the tools'"
  • Unclear what they would do as an admin
  • Gnoming (citation template errors, c/e)
  • Good AfD record
  • Low content creation
  • Innisfree987 encouraged to run
  • High-trust perms: NPP
MarcGarver
  • Undisclosed paid editing
  • Promotional content and spam
  • Addressing CV at AfC and NPP
  • According to self, no recent conflict
  • Excellent AfD record
  • Low content creation
  • High-trust perms: Steward, Wikibooks sysop & checkuser, AP, NPP
Mdewman6
  • Redirects
  • Naming convention
  • DAB
  • Specifics with (broken) link
  • Excellent AfD record
  • Some content creation
  • High-trust perms: NPP, PM
NoobThreePointOh
Pbritti
  • Content creator
  • Anti-vandalism
  • Page protection
  • Unblock requests
  • AfD/PROD
  • Excellent AfD record
  • High-trust perms: AP, NPP
Peaceray
  • Welcome new editors
  • Anti-vandalism
  • Anti-vandalism
  • Page protection
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Good with conflict per Femke
  • Good AfD record
  • Approval from Rosiestep and others
  • High-trust perms: AP, MMS, PM, TE
Pharaoh of the Wizards
  • Editing since 2006
 Shares history:
  • UAA
  • AIV
  • AFD
  • CSD
  • Contect creation
  • UAA
  • AIV
  • AFD
  • According to self, no significant conflict
  • Bad AfD record, vote stacking
  • Short responses to questions
  • Doesn't always archive critical talk page messages
  • High-trust perms: AP
Queen of Hearts
  • "Lesser" XfDs: CfD, RfD, MfD
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Link in follow-up conversation
  • Iffy AfD record, but no interest in AfD
  • High trust perms:
  • Formerly had pending changes but returned for lack of use
  • Good at closing RM per Maddy from Celeste
  • Nom offers from Josh and Femke
  • Excellent closer at CfD per HouseBlaster
Robert McClenon
  • Former failed RFAs (2006, 2017)
  • NPP
  • "Maintenance and improvement of the encyclopedia"
  • Dispute resolution
  • XfD: MfD, deletion review, CSD (G6, G11)
  • Dispute resolution noticeboard
  • Very bad AfD record (explicitly stating it's not up to participants to look for sources)
  • Low content creation
  • High-trust perms: AP, NPP, PM
  • Logical communication style
  • Lots of back and forth in the discussion
Rsjaffe
  • Uses AWB for mass work
  • Check for undeclared paid editing, vandalism, SP
  • SPI
  • Vandalism
  • Undeclared paid editors
  • Specifics
  • Excellent AfD record
  • High-trust perms: NPP
  • All SPI reports led to blocks
Sable232
  • Vandalism
  • Content creation and formatting
  • Sockpuppets
  • LTA
  • SPI
  • RFPP
  • AIV
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Excellent AfD record
  • Low content creation
  • Potential issues with dispute resolution/being petty (1, 2, 3)
SD0001 Novem Linguae:

Josh:

  • Edit protected page templates and modules
  • Update gadgets
  • Respond to edit requests
  • Operate admin bots
  • Histmerge
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Good AfD record
  • <1,000 edits in last year
  • High-trust perms: BAG, NPP, PM, TE
SheriffIsInTown
SilverLocust Extraordinary Writ:
  • Requested moves
  • Content creation
  • "Good judgment, a calm and friendly disposition, and above all a real diligence in how he goes about making a difference on this site".

HouseBlaster:

  • Arbitration Committee clerk
  • Requested moves
  • Technical move requests
  • Page protection
  • History merge
  • Clerking arbitration
  • No specific conflicts, good attitude
  • Good AfD record
  • High-trust perms: MMS, NPP, PM, TE
Sohom Datta Novem Linguae:
  • MediaWiki extensions
  • 10 GAs
  • NPP coordinator
  • "Personable and pleasant to interact with"
  • 7,583 edit count

Clover:

  • "Kind, knowledgable, and I trust him"
  • Maintain gadgets and userscripts
  • RFPP
  • Admin bots
  • DYK
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Good AfD record
  • Edit count under 8,000
Spy-cicle
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Discussion shared in questions from community
  • Good AfD record
  • <1,000 edits in last year
  • Concerning edits regarding LGBT issues and reliable sources (1, 2, 3, 4, 5)
Starship.paint
  • Content creation
  • INVOLVED in GSEX, APOL, Abortion, AI
  • AN
  • ANI
  • AE
  • ITN dabbling
  • Bad AfD record, but AfD isn't everything
  • High-trust perms: AP
SWinxy
  • Content creation
  • Press photography for Wikimedia Commons
  • (Un)protect pages (CTOP editor)
  • View and restore deleted pages (deletion discussions)
  • Edit fully-protected articles
  • No specifics, good attitude
  • Good AfD record[c]
  • High-trust perms: TE
  • Rhododentrites encouraged to run
ThadeusOfNazereth Vanamonde93:
  • 3 GAs
  • 2 FLs
  • Some DYKs
  • NPP
  • AfD participation
  • RCP
  • Non-admin discussion closure
  • Volunteer advisor with the Wikimedia Foundations Elections Committee
  • AIV
  • RPP
  • DYK
  • RSN
  • Specifics
  • Excellent AfD record
  • High-trust perms: AP, NPP
The Squirrel Conspiracy
  • Formerly Sven Manguard and Nezzadar
  • Withdrawn RFA in 2012 (OUTING)
  • FFD
  • Likely won't be active
  • Admin on Commons
  • Cross-wiki spam and vandalism
  • Spam (del/revdel)
  • Vandalism (del/revdel)
  • View revdel for cross-wiki spam and vandalism
  • No specifics, decent atttitude
  • Good AfD record
  • <1,000 edits in last year
  • Doesn't always archive critical messages
  • High-trust perms: Wikidata sysop, Commons sysop, AP, NPP
Valenciano
  • NPP
  • AIV
  • RFPP
  • UAA
  • CSD log
  • 400 articles created
  • 26 DYK
  • 3 GAs
  • AIV
  • UAA
  • RFPP
  • No specifics, decent attitude
  • Specifics added here and here
  • Good AfD record but stale
  • Doesn't always archive critical messages
  • High-trust perms: AP, NPP
Velella
  • Active 19 years
  • Blocked early on
  • Support the overall admin effort
  • Anti-vandalism
  • SPI
  • Undisclosed paid editing
  • AfD
  • ANI
  • CSD
  • "Avoids drama"
  • Good AfD record
  • Some incorrect draftications despite Page Curator warnings
  • "This process for me has been very stressful."
  • Many creations, but not all good (some uncited)
  • High-trust perms: AP, NPP
Zippybonzo
  • NPP
  • Anti-vandalism
  • Copyright
  • Lack of content work
  • CSD
  • PROD
  • AIV
  • UAA
  • According to self, does not handle criticism well (lashing out, leaving wiki)
  • Bad AfD record
  • Edit count under 8,000
  • <1,000 edits in last year
2024 administrator election candidates
Candidate Candidacy subpage
Queen of Hearts (talk · contribs · count · logs)
EggRoll97 (talk · contribs · count · logs)
SheriffIsInTown (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Rsjaffe (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Leonidlednev (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Zippybonzo (talk · contribs · count · logs)
MarcGarver (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Iwaqarhashmi (talk · contribs · count · logs)
NoobThreePointOh (talk · contribs · count · logs)
ThadeusOfNazereth (talk · contribs · count · logs)
SilverLocust (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Ahecht (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Hawkeye7 (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Sable232 (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Mdewman6 (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Starship.paint (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Frost (talk · contribs · count · logs)
The Squirrel Conspiracy (talk · contribs · count · logs)
AntiDionysius (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Dr vulpes (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Valenciano (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Sohom Datta (talk · contribs · count · logs)
SWinxy (talk · contribs · count · logs)
FOARP (talk · contribs · count · logs)
LindsayH (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Velella (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Robert McClenon (talk · contribs · count · logs)
SD0001 (talk · contribs · count · logs)
DoubleGrazing (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Pbritti (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Knightoftheswords281 (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Pharaoh of the Wizards (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Bastun (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Peaceray (talk · contribs · count · logs)
Spy-cicle (talk · contribs · count · logs)

See all candidate subpages

Notes

edit
  1. ^ AfD records are based on asilvering's analysis
  2. ^ Per Femke
  3. ^ This is my analysis since asilvering didn't add one.
Retrieved from "https://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=User:Significa_liberdade/EFA&oldid=1253929707"