User:Ijwilliams/Medical racism

Medical racism in the United States encompasses discriminatory and targeted medical practices and misrepresentations in medical teachings driven by biases based on characteristics of patients including race and ethnicity. In American history, it has impacted various racial and ethnic groups and affected their health outcomes. Vulnerable subgroups within these racial and ethnic groups such as women, children and the poor have been especially endangered over the years. An ongoing phenomenon since at least the 18th century in the United States, medical racism has been evident on a widespread basis through various unethical studies, forced procedures, and differential treatments administered by health care providers, researchers, and even sometimes government entities. Whether medical racism is always caused by explicitly prejudiced beliefs about patients based on race or by unconscious bias is not widely agreed upon.

History

A doctor is seen drawing blood from a patient who was unwittingly a test subject in the Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male. This study is controversial for its violation of ethics in the name of science.

In a modern context, medical racism and its history has created a deep distrust of health professionals and their practices in certain racial and ethnic groups. Studies within the last couple decades have elucidated varied treatment from health professionals still occurring that reveal racial biases. These racial biases have impacted the way in which substances such as painkillers are prescribed or the rate at which diagnostic tests are given. Black patients in particular have a long history of contrasting medical treatment based on different perceptions of the pain thresholds of Black people. However, medical racism has not been limited to Black people in the United States. While infamous studies like the Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male may be known, the U.S. Public Health Service Sexually Transmitted Disease (STD) Inoculation Study of 1946-1948 notably impacted Guatemalan prisoners, sex workers, soldiers, and mental health patients in a detrimental fashion by purposely infecting victims with STDs such as syphilis and gonorrhea. The push to forcibly sterilize Indigenous women as young as 15 years old occurred from 1970 to 1976 by the Indian Health Service as revealed in researcher Jane Lawrence's paper "The Indian Health Service and the Sterilization of Native American Women." These are only a few examples of the many that exist in American history of the unethical actions of health care providers, researchers, and government entities pertaining to the health services of minority groups.

Factors

Cultural Incompetency

Physicians not possessing the appropriate level of cultural competence as it pertains to their patient demographic can lead to adverse impacts to those patients due to poor relationship dynamics and contribute to medical racism. Cultural incompetence exists for a number of reasons such as lack of diversity in medical education and lack of diverse members of medical school student and faculty populations. This leads to marginalization of both minority healthcare providers and minority patients.

Medical Education

Studies done on the curriculums of medical schools in the US have found that within the assigned textbook readings, there exists a disparity between the representation of race and skin color in textbook case studies relative to the US population. This is true for both visual and textual lecture materials.

A group of studies done on the representation of race and gender in course slides for the University of Washington School of Medicine, preclinical lecture slides at the Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University and case studies used at the University of Minnesota Medical School simultaneously showed associations of race as a "risk factor" and a lack of racial diversity.

In this image is one of the first symptoms of lyme disease, erythema migrans, depicted on white skin. Without more diverse depictions, this rash may be harder to detect on those with darker skin tones.

The study done on the University of Minnesota Medical School employed the use of the concept of hidden curriculum to describe the ways in which lack of representation and informal teachings can greatly influence the minds of aspiring physicians. The interactions had between students and faculty or the transmission of unintentional messages can be just as, if not more, influential than formal lectures. These can include the associations of diseases such as sickle cell anemia as a "black disease" and cystic fibrosis as a "white disease" which leads to poor health outcomes. In this study, the 1996-1998 year one and year two curriculums of the school were analyzed. It revealed that only 4.5% of the case studies mentioned a racial or ethnic background of the patient and when the patient was black or had "potentially unfavorable characteristics" race or ethnicity was more likely to be identified. There was also a greater prevalence of health-related themes discussed when race or ethnicity was identified. Researchers determined that the inclusion of specific racial or ethnic identities in those cases was intended to indicate something about that disease or health condition. Implications such as these contributes to the racialization of diseases.

A study of specific medical textbooks has also yielded much information on minority representation in medical teachings. Based on the required texts of the top 20 ranked medical schools in North America, US editions of Atlas of Human Anatomy (2014), Bates' Guide to Physical Examination and History Taking (2013), Clinically Oriented Anatomy (2014), and Gray's Anatomy for Students (2015) were chosen for the study. Using the total 4146 images from the four textbooks that depicted visible faces, arms, heads, and skin, researchers discovered two of three books were close in diversity to the US population, one book displayed "diversity on basis of equal representation" and one matched neither definition of diversity. On a topic level there were also issues of diversity. When discussing health issues such as skin cancers three of four books included no imagery at all and the one book that did had only imagery of white and light-skinned patients. According to researchers, symptoms might manifest differently depending on skin tone. Missed indicators may go unreported if there is a lack of education on how to recognize these discrepancies.

Some medical students have also done their own research and added to the discourse on underrepresentation in medical school education. They've noted specific examples such as skin infections like erythema migrans being depicted on almost exclusively white skin. As an indicative first symptom of lyme disease, a lack of knowledge on how to detect this rash on patients with darker skin colors means failed diagnoses of the disease. Studies have shown that there is in fact a delay in lyme disease diagnoses for black patients. The lack of representation in medical school lectures risks creating adverse impacts on the health outcomes of minority populations in the US.

Representation in Medical Field

According to US Census data, black and Hispanic people account for 13% and 18% of the overall population, respectively. However, they only make up 6% and 5% of medical school graduates, respectively. Black physicians make up only about 3% of American doctors. Black physicians in particular have historically faced numerous obstacles to obtaining membership in the larger medical community. During the 20th century in the United States, groups such as the American Medical Association neglected black physicians and their pursuit of success in the field of medicine. This has led to continued marginalization of black physicians in the US due to their small numbers among other factors and this contributes to the marginalization of black patients. Minorities often perceive medical facilities as "white spaces" because of a lack of diversity at the institutional level.

In this postcard, a Jim Crow caricature resembling an ape proclaims "Give My Regards to Broadway." This type of depiction of black people was once quite common in American history.

Racial Depictions

In an early 20th century postcard, black children are described as "Alligator Bait" as they sit in a tree above an alligator. Images such as these, popular with Americans, helped to contribute to dehumanizing black Americans.

The dehumanization of certain racial groups such as black people can also contribute to disparities in healthcare due to varied perceptions, by physicians, of concepts such as pain tolerance and cooperation – one aspect of medical racism. In American history, social Darwinism has been utilized to justify American chattel slavery among other historical practices and the racist ideas about black people it created persisted into the 20th century. The Three-Fifths Compromise worked also to reinforce the notion that black people were less than human.

However, this has not just been relegated to the past. As recently as the 1990s, California state police came under fire for referring to cases involving young black men as "N.H.I" or no humans involved. One police officer involved in the Rodney King beating in 1991 was cited as saying that a domestic quarrel between a black couple was "something right out of Gorillas in the Mist." This comparison has historical prevalence in that it stems from early theorizations about the evolution of primates. Proponents of this social Darwinistic theory believe that white people are the most advanced humans, descended from primates, and that black people must fall somewhere in the middle of the two.

In a study on whether or not the association of black people with apes influences the perceptions and behaviors of whites and non-whites, it was found that even without explicit knowledge of that historical association people implicitly related one with the other. This study was done in the context of criminal justice and aimed to reveal whether these animal associations impacted the likelihood of jurors to give the death sentence. Researchers were able to conclude that, "The present research foregrounds dehumanization as a factor in producing implicit racial bias, and we associate it with deadly outcomes."

Black Americans

Black Americans have faced innumerable obstacles to equal access to healthcare due to medical racism and this has been translated into poor health outcomes. Within this paradigm, American doctors and institutions have historically played a large role in perpetuating scientific racism, denying equal care to black patients, and committing violence against black people.

Ideas about black people's relation to primates and their biological and intellectual inferiority to white people, in the US, were just a few ways that chattel slavery was justified. Following this was the introduction of the idea that black people have much higher pain thresholds or that they don't feel pain at all. Proponents of ideas such as this also proposed that black people have thicker skulls, less sensitive nervous systems, and that they contracted diseases linked to having darker skin. Some even believed that black people could go through surgery with no pain medicine and that when they were punished, during enslavement, they felt no pain. There also existed the assumption that white American physicians operated on, that poor health was the status quo for black people and that they'd naturally die off due to syphilis and tuberculosis and this was detrimental to the quality of healthcare they then provided. High rates of syphilis among black people was used to reinforce this notion. However, racial myths also have negative impacts on the health outcomes of black Americans, starting from infancy. Beliefs in the "supernormal health" of black babies and children creates ignorance and avoidance of the health issues faced early in black children's lives. With a large role in the perpetuation of such widely believed ideas, oral tradition can be highly influential even when not necessarily explicitly within medical curriculum.

When false ideas of pain tolerance based on race are present within people's minds, they lead to detrimental consequences even if those who believe in them have no explicitly prejudiced beliefs, as discovered by researchers. In a study on racial bias in pain assessments, a demonstrated correlation between racial bias in pain assessment and subsequent pain treatment suggestions was found. It was also found that in both a significant number of laypersons and those with medical training, incorrect beliefs about differences between black and white people on a biological level were held. Beliefs such as these can lead to differential treatment of patients on the basis of race. In a research by Staton et al., doctors were shown to have a higher probability of underestimating the pain intensity that black patients were feeling. In the early 2000s multiple studies were able to demonstrate discrepancies in the pain treatment of black patients as compared to white patients. From children to adults, differences were as much as patients only taking half of the amount of pain medications as white patients.

Freedom from slavery did not stop the impacts that slavery had on black people, such as in the field of healthcare; the denial of access or equal access to healthcare was able to recreate experiences of slavery by exposing black people to many infectious diseases. A notable difference in services offered and rendered for black patients and white patients has been observed in the American healthcare system even with the presentation of the same severity of symptoms and the same insurance.

This photo shows "HeLa cells" that originated from black woman and cancer patient, Henrietta Lacks. Lacks was unaware of her stolen cells that have been used for many decades now in medical advancements such as the development of the polio vaccine.

Along with unequal access to medical care, medical racism has contributed to violence perpetrated against black Americans throughout history. Including the use of "resurrectionists" to retrieve newly buried bodies of deceased black people for medical study use, the bodies of black people were abused for forced medical experimentation for many years. As noted in writings on the American medical field's history of medical racism, "American medical education relied on the theft, dissection, and display of bodies, many of whom were black." This is especially true for women, such as was the case for Henrietta Lacks. The nonconsensual experimentation on enslaved black women was used to help further the field of gynecology. Following this, due to the history of eugenics in the United States, this same population once again fell victim to forced procedures, in this case sterilization. This went on in the US for as long as the 1970s and 1980s as is documented in Killing the Black Body. For black Americans, the involuntary sterilization of black women was so well known it began being referred to as the "Mississippi Appendectomy".

This violence perpetrated by American physicians and institutions has a long, documented history. Including the Tuskegee syphilis study, there are many other instances of experimentation on black populations without their knowledge or consent. In 1951, the US Army intentionally exposed large numbers of black citizens to Aspergillus fumigatus to ascertain whether they were more susceptible to this fungus. In the same year, black workers at a Norfolk supply center in Virginia were exposed to crates contaminated with the same fungus. Journalist Richard Sanders reported that from 1956-1958 the US Army intentionally released mosquitoes in poor black communities of Savannah, Georgia and Avon Park, Florida. Many people subsequently developed fevers for unknown reasons and some died, it is theorized that the mosquitoes were infected with a strain of yellow fever. Pulitzer-prize winning author of The Plutonium Files, Eileen Welsome wrote on how the US secretly injected thousands of Americans with plutonium while developing the atomic bomb. A number of these victims were black and completely unaware of the injections.

Indigenous Americans

Depicted is war chief Pontiac holding a war hatchet. It was in Pontiac's War that Jeffery Amherst famously proposed gifting smallpox infected blankets to the indigenous peoples.

Starting in the 18th century, the United States has committed many acts of medical injustice against Indigenous Americans. In the 18th century, smallpox was used as a biological weapon to wipe out indigenous populations. In particular, in 1763 Sir Jeffery Amherst ordered soldiers to take the blankets and handkerchiefs of smallpox patients and gift them to indigenous people of Delaware at a peacemaking parley. There is also the prevalence of involuntary sterilization of young indigenous girls and women. From the data yielded by multiple studies, it's suggested that the Indian Health Service sterilized between 25-50% of indigenous women from 1970 to 1976.

Contemporarily, the health outcomes of indigenous populations in the US are still vastly worse than the greater population. In the state of Montana, the life expectancy for indigenous women is 62, while for men it is 56. These numbers are significantly lower than the national averages by around 20 years. This is due to a number of factors such as the fact that unequal funding plagues the Indian Health Service that is in charge of ensuring the access the federal government must provide and that around 25% of indigenous people in the US report facing discrimination in medical settings. An executive director at South Dakota Urban Indian Health, Donna Keeler, explains that while her clinic receives federal funding for indigenous people living in urban areas, federal prison inmates would have more federal funding allocated to their healthcare.

Latinx Americans

The document shown is the results of a 2010 inquiry into the STD research that took place by the US in Guatemala. President Barack Obama enlisted the Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues to oversee the project.

In the United States, 20% of Latinx Americans report encountering discrimination in healthcare settings and 17% report avoiding seeking medical care due to expected discrimination. Studies of Latinx people living in the U.S. reveal that after experiencing an instance of discrimination in a healthcare setting they, afterward, delayed seeking medical treatment again. The discrimination faced by Latinx Americans can further contribute to the negative health outcomes that stem from the experience of racism and discrimination by minorities. Cultural incompetency can hinder productive relationships between healthcare providers and patients because different cultural norms of communication can give the impression that a physician is not properly attending to the concerns of their patient as was found in studies on Latina experiences with the healthcare system. It was found in one study that in the role that communication plays in the dynamic between Latina patients and healthcare providers, the way women perceived their communication with their provider was greatly impactful to their perception of discrimination.

The aforementioned U.S. Public Health Service Sexually Transmitted Disease (STD) Inoculation Study of 1946-1948 is just one historical example of the way in which Latin American populations have been victim to medical racism and medical injustices. From 2006 to 2012, California prisons performed illegal sterilizations on inmates and more than half of the women were black or Latina. Both black and Latinx patients have been found to be under-treated for pain.

Contemporary Issues

In the year 2020, a nurse whistleblower exposed the practice of forced hysterectomies at a US Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility.

Alleviation

In addressing the issue of medical racism in the United States, there are different ways to mitigate unconscious bias that leads to the perpetuation of health disparities. Practices like better diversity training, introspection of biases, "cultural humility and curiosity", and a full commitment to changing the culture of healthcare and the impact of stereotypes can work to lessen the effects that unconscious bias can have on patients.