Wikipedia

What Made You Say That

"What Made You Say That" is the debut single by Canadian country music artist Shania Twain.[3] It was released as the lead single to her eponymous debut album (1993) on March 6, 1993. The song was written by Tony Haselden and Stan Munsey Jr. and produced by Harold Shedd and Norro Wilson, who also produced her album. The song was initially recorded by American country singer and actor Wayne Massey for his third album Wayne Massey and Black Hawk (1989).

"What Made You Say That"
This is the cover to Shania Twain's 1993 debut single "What Made You Say That".
Single by Shania Twain
from the album Shania Twain
B-side"Crime of the Century"
ReleasedMarch 6, 1993 (1993-03-06)[1]
Recorded1992
GenreCountry pop[2]
Length2:59
Label
Songwriter(s)
Producer(s)
Shania Twain singles chronology
"What Made You Say That"
(1993) 		"Dance with the One That Brought You"
(1993)
Music video
"What Made You Say That" on YouTube
Alternative cover
US cassette single cover

Despite a heavily played video, the track only charted at number 55 on the Billboard Hot Country Songs chart and number 70 on the Canadian RPM Country Tracks chart. The track was not included on her 2004 Greatest Hits collection but was included in her 2022 compilation Not Just a Girl (The Highlights), the only song off her debut album to be included. Twain would perform the track on a few occasions, most notably at the 1993 CCMA Awards and her debut tour Come On Over Tour. On the latter, she would bring a child who had won a local radio contest to perform the song while Twain provided backing vocals. One of these children was a then-unknown Avril Lavigne.[3][4]

Critical reception

edit

Billboard magazine reviewed the song as "sassy, buoyant, catchy, and supported by an alluring video."[5] Brad Hogue of Cashbox put the track under his "Feature Picks", saying "Twain's vocals are strong, and alternate between seductive trite and sincerity."[6] Kevin John Coyne of Country Universe, in a retrospective interview, rated the song a C, criticizing the "dated on arrival" production and saying that Twain's playful vocals and a "catchy" hook was what saved it from being a "total dud."[7]

Music video

edit
 
Twain in the video for "What Made You Say That".

Shania Twain's first music video was directed by Steven Goldmann.[8] Mercury Records invested in an expensive music video shot at Miami Beach, Florida on January 12, 1993.[9][10] It was released on February 20, 1993, to Country Music Television (CMT), where it was labeled as a "Hot Shot".[11] The video is simple, featuring Twain dancing around on the beach with a male model portrayed as her love interest. It was included in Twain's video album The Platinum Collection (2001). It received a nomination at the 1993 CCMA Awards for CMT Video of the Year.[12]

The video attracted controversy at the time of its release due to the showing of Twain's midriff, which she said in her autobiography that she was inspired by Cindy Crawford and Madonna.[13] At the time of release for the video for "What Made You Say That," women in country music were expected to cover up.[9] According to music critic Roy Shuker, the video was a celebration of her sex appeal.[14] Robin Eggar of the book Shania Twain: The Biography described the video as proof to Twain that "being young, sassy, and sexy worked, that she did not have to conform to Nashville's ideas of the correct feminine image."[15] Despite that, CMT banned the video claiming it was too suggestive, although they would later retract the ban and let the video play again on the network.[13]

The video's screening on CMT Europe, where it was so popular that for multiple weeks it was the most played video on the network,[15] caught the attention of rock producer Robert John "Mutt" Lange.[14] He noticed her beauty and singing ability and had wanted to meet her.[16] According to Twain, she did not know who Mutt Lange.[17] The two began talking on the phone and would later meet at the Nashville Fun Fair in June 1993 before they would marry later that December.[17] This would be the start of a over-decade long collaboration between the two that would make the most commercially successful material of Twain's career.

Chart performance

edit

"What Made You Say That" entered the US Billboard Hot Country Songs chart (then known as "Hot Country Singles & Tracks") the week of March 27, 1993,[18] at number 74. The track proved to be a disappointment commercially, hitting only number 55 on the chart for the week of May 15, 1993, and spent 18 weeks in total on the chart.

Track listings

edit

US jukebox single[19]

  1. "What Made You Say That" – 2:59
  2. "Crime of the Century" – 3:29

US cassette single[20]

  1. "What Made You Say That" – 2:59
  2. "You Lay a Whole Lot of Love on Me" – 2:48

Charts

edit
Weekly chart performance for "What Made You Say That"
Chart (1993) Peak
position
Canada Country Tracks (RPM)[21] 70
US Hot Country Songs (Billboard)[22] 55
US Country Top 50 (Radio & Records)[23] 43
US Country (Gavin Report)[24] 40
US Top 100 Country Singles (Cashbox)[25] 40

References

edit
  1. ^ "Grass Roots Campaign Raises Mercury". Radio & Records. No. 981. February 26, 1993. p. 38. Canada native Twain, who blends pop and blues influences with country, is scheduled to hit the airwaves after CRS with "What Made You Say That."
  2. ^ "Mercury's Triple Play Tour: The First Pitch". Radio & Records. No. 982. March 5, 1993. p. 64. ...and the country pop of "God Ain't Gonna Get You for That" and "What Made You Say That."
  3. ^ a b Mulligan, Stephen (March 25, 2022). Were You There?: Over 200 Wonderful, Weird, and Wacky Moments from the Canadian Tire Centre in Ottawa (1996-2020). Dorrance Publishing Company. p. 37. ISBN 9781638674542.
  4. ^ Snapp, Lauryn (March 12, 2022). "Did Shania Twain Inspire Avril Lavigne's Career?". 97.3 The Dawg. Retrieved November 26, 2024.
  5. ^ Flick, Larry, ed. (March 27, 1993). "Single Reviews: Country". Billboard. Vol. 105, no. 13. Nielsen Business Media. p. 82. ISSN 0006-2510.
  6. ^ Hogue, Brad (March 13, 1993). "Cash Box Country Reviews: Singles". Cashbox. Vol. LVI, no. 27. p. 20.
  7. ^ Coyne, Kevin John (June 25, 2011). "Retro Single Review: Shania Twain, "What Made You Say That"". Country Universe. Retrieved November 26, 2024.
  8. ^ "CMT : Videos : Shania Twain : What Made You Say That". Country Music Television. Archived from the original on October 12, 2007. Retrieved November 26, 2024.
  9. ^ a b McCall, Michael (September 15, 2015). Shania Twain: An Intimate Portrait of a Country Music Diva. St. Martin's Publishing Group. ISBN 9781250098252.
  10. ^ The Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum (January 4, 2012). Rumble, John; McCall, Michael; Kingsbury, Paul; Gill, Vince (eds.). The Encyclopedia of Country Music. Oxford University Press. p. 553. ISBN 9780199920839.
  11. ^ "The Clip List". Billboard. Vol. 105, no. 9. Nielsen Business Media. February 20, 1993. p. 46. ISSN 0006-2510.
  12. ^ "Search Past CCMA Award Winners And Nominees - Canadian Country Music Association". Canadian Country Music Association. Retrieved November 26, 2024.
  13. ^ a b Twain, Shania (May 3, 2011). From This Moment On. Atria Books. p. 237. ISBN 9781451620757.
  14. ^ a b Shuker, Roy (March 15, 2012). Popular Music Culture: The Key Concepts. Taylor & Francis. ISBN 9781136577710.
  15. ^ a b Eggar, Robin (June 15, 2010). Shania Twain: The Biography. Gallery Books. pp. 164–165. ISBN 9781451604542.
  16. ^ Hager, Barbara (1998). On Her Way: The Life and Music of Shania Twain. Berkley Boulevard. ISBN 9780425164518.
  17. ^ a b Pickels, Dwayne E. (2000). Shania Twain. Chelsea House Publishers. ISBN 9781438141305.
  18. ^ Warner, Jay (2008). Notable Moments of Women in Music. Hal Leonard Books. p. 326. ISBN 9781423429517.
  19. ^ What Made You Say That (US jukebox 7-inch single sleeve). Shania Twain. Mercury Nashville Records, PolyGram. 1993. 422-864 992-7.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
  20. ^ What Made You Say That (US cassette single sleeve). Shania Twain. Mercury Nashville Records, PolyGram. 1993. 864 922-4.{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link)
  21. ^ "Top RPM Country Tracks: Issue 0971." RPM. Library and Archives Canada. June 5, 1993. Retrieved August 5, 2013.
  22. ^ "Shania Twain Chart History (Hot Country Songs)". Billboard.
  23. ^ "R&R Country National Airplay". Radio & Records. No. 990. April 30, 1993. p. 45.
  24. ^ "the Gavin Report: Country". Gavin Report. No. 1950. April 23, 1993. p. 17.
  25. ^ "Cash Box Charts: Top 100 Country Singles". Cashbox. Vol. LVI, no. 37. May 22, 1993. p. 22.
Retrieved from "https://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=What_Made_You_Say_That&oldid=1260496281"