Please first read User:Shock Brigade Harvester Boris/A pocket guide to Arbitration. Then pay a minute of silence to its author whom to have known was one of the pleasures on the site. He would have been an arb for whom I'd have voted without a question.

If you want analysis and recommendations, look what others offer. To know what I go for, or just compare what the candidates answered, stay here and read their answers, abbreviated by "agree" and others shortcuts for sometimes verbuous comments.

Questions

edit

I wanted to ask one simple question:

I commented in the Fram case, decision talk, like this:
Comment by Gerda
Trying to keep it simple: I believe that Fram's admin rights were removed out of process, and should be restored without questions. In case of future problems, the community can get back to arbcom. A new RfA right now seems to offer no fair chances. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 21:14, 10 September 2019 (UTC).
Imagine you had been an arb, what would you have written in reply? --Gerda Arendt (talk) 16:16, 31 October 2019 (UTC)

For clarification, I added a second question:

Second question, same thread: LouisAlain?

Finally, if I still couldn't figure out what the answer to the first questions would have been, I asked which remedy the candidate would have supported. I would have supported 2a, as Worm That Turned and Opabinia regalis, or 2e, which was not yet there when I commented, but was prepared with great effort by GorillaWarfare.

As some seemed to have trouble understanding what I wanted to know, I summarized later:

I commented in the Fram case, decision talk, like this. If you had been an arb then, what might you have replied, and/or which of the remedies under 2 would you have supported?

Looking at the answers

edit

I looked at the answers, and marked what I liked, which doesn't necessarily mean I will vote for them, - other factors may play a role.

My question: I wanted to see a clear statement of in dubio pro reo. None of us could look at the secret evidence, but we could see some open evidence which raised doubts - at least with me - about the quality of the allegations. I also looked at how concise a candidate could deliver a message, at my former experiences with a candidate, and at recent contributions. Candidates marked green will most likely get my vote, as of the first day of voting. I'll give the others another chance. I am sad about Hevrin Khalaf - protest pictured, which matters much more than arbcom. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 12:40, 19 November 2019 (UTC)

Cassianto asked some candidates questions about a case in which he was involved, sometimes a short version (s), sometimes a long version (l). I looked at what candidates replied, and marked what I like. With Barkeep49, we had as interesting discussion. 12 candidates today and we found an image. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 08:45, 20 November 2019 (UTC)

 

Kurdish civil engineer and politician
Hevrin Khalaf,
who worked for tolerance
among Christians, Arabs, and Kurds,
was killed
in the 2019 Turkish offensive into Syria?

I voted. As 12 candidates passed my minimum request I voted neutral for the one most likely to be elected without my vote. --Gerda Arendt (talk) 17:09, 23 November 2019 (UTC)

Answers

edit
Candidate nom day answer day answers remedy Precious no. Precious reason Experience G C sup Elected %
gadfium 3 Nov 3–9 Nov "would agree" open 2028 Māori task force admin  Y s  Y Yes
Richwales 3 Nov 4–11 Nov "partly agree" open 278 law and massacre admin s  Y
Worm That Turned 4 Nov 5 Nov support per vote in the case 2a,e 203 support arb  Y n Yes 75,94
Fish and karate (withdrawn 12 Nov) 6 Nov 7–11 Nov "partly agree" 1, 2b 1802 courage and images admin
Hawkeye7 6 Nov 7 Nov "follow GorillaWarfare" 171 people in sports and battles former admin l
Cas Liber 8 Nov 8 Nov "agree" 2e 75 wildflowers and birds former arb  Y s  Y Yes 78,43
Lord Roem (withdrawn 13 Nov) 8 Nov 8 Nov "agree" 2e 1736 supreme justice admin, arb clerk  Y
Thryduulf 9 Nov 9–10 Nov "disagree" 2c,d, or e 576 thinking of options arb n
Bradv 9 Nov 9–10 Nov "disagree", explained 2a or 2b, 2a 13 Nov 2263 "help improve the encyclopedia and achieve its vision" admin, arb clerk s  Y 62,55
Isarra 10 Nov 14 ask further n
Barkeep49 10 Nov 10–11 Nov "disagree" 2109 radiant child admin s  Y
Laser brain (withdrawn 16 Nov) 10 Nov 10 Nov "agree" 700 featured pet projects admin, FA coordinator  Y
KrakatoaKatie 11 Nov 11 Nov "disagree", as in the case 2b 1777 "one of the best Wikipedians of all time" arb n 70,07
Xeno 11 Nov 11 Nov "agree" 2181 clear thoughts and language bureaucrat  Y s  Y Yes 69,28
Newyorkbrad 11 Nov 11 Nov "agree" + respect other views 2a 99 standing strong arb with long standing  Y n Yes 79,69
The Rambling Man 11 Nov 11 Nov "agree" explained 2a 602 playing nice former admin  Y s  Y Yes
David Fuchs 11 Nov 11 Nov "agree" 153 star treks former arb  Y n Yes 66,10
Beeblebrox 11 Nov 11 Nov "agree" 553 "move along" former arb  Y 66,63
Llywrch 11 Nov 12 Nov "agree with sentiment" 2a 2308 places in Ethiopia, Roman senators, and butting in admin  Y n Yes
Maxim 12 Nov 12 Nov "agree" 2a sort of 1196 ice hockey players bureaucrat  Y n Yes 65,94
SoWhy 12 Nov 12 Nov "agree" 202 questions and help admin  Y n Yes 67,36
Kudpung 12 Nov 12 Nov "might follow WTT OR GW" admin n
Calidum 12 Nov 12 Nov "agree" but evidence 2a 1038 common sense  Y n Yes
DGG 12 Nov 13 Nov "agree" 453 keep articles admin  Y n Yes 63,25
Enterprisey 12 Nov 17 Nov ask further n


Results

Notes

edit
  1. ^ Template adapted from User:Worm That Turned/ACE2015