Union of Orthodox Rabbis

The Union of Orthodox Rabbis of the United States and Canada (UOR), often called by its Hebrew name, Agudath Harabonim or (in Ashkenazi Hebrew) Agudas Harabonim ("union of rabbis"), was established in 1901 in the United States and is the oldest organization of Orthodox rabbis in the United States. It had been for many years the principal group for such rabbis, though in recent years it has lost much of its former membership and influence.

History

The Agudath Harabonim was formed in 1902, to espouse a strictly traditionalist agenda. Its founders were concerned with the Americanized, acculturated character of even the relatively traditional wing of local Jewry, exemplified by the Orthodox Union (OU), which had formed five years earlier, and the Jewish Theological Seminary of America. There were two distinct groups within the American Orthodox rabbinate: the Eastern European and the Western European and American-born: "The Americans were English-speakers, often had a secular education, and competed with Reform (and later Conservative) movements for the heart of the modern American Jew. European transplants were often Yiddish-speaking with barely any English skills, trained exclusively in rabbinics, and would be termed Haredi today, and had a stronger affinity to the entire body of religious texts; they were there to maintain standards." Though there were American scholars trained in the European path, and European schools that supported secular scholarship, most rabbis belonged to one camp or the other.^{[citation needed]}

To the Eastern Europeans, the OU and its later affiliated Rabbinical Council of America, were dangerously accommodationist and lacking in both scholarship and piety. Their credentials were rarely recognized, if at all, by the UOR. The Eastern Europeans needed a fellowship to promote their ideas and raise political capital, and the Agudath Harabanim served that need.^[1]

The UOR leadership was willing to tolerate the OU in urgent needs, such as kosher supervision. The Agudath Harabonim initially started raising standards in New York and elsewhere, but had some trouble getting the butchers and shochtim in line. Henry Pereira Mendes and his colleagues in the OU in New York provided assistance in this area.^{[citation needed]}

Among the main founding rabbis of the Agudath Harabonim were Bernard Levinthal, Moshe Zevulun Margolies (known as "Ramaz"),^[2] Moshe Yisrael Shapiro;^[3] and S. A. Joffee.^[4] Margolies was from Europe, and equally at ease in Yiddish and English, had feet in both camps, with a personality well suited for the modern American congregation.^{[citation needed]}

Among the well-known leaders from the Agudath Harabonim's past are Rabbis Eliezer Silver and Moshe Feinstein. In recent years, the organization has been under the direction of Rabbi Tzvi Meir Ginsberg.^{[citation needed]}

Competing Haredi organizations

Knesseth Harabonim / Assembly of Hebrew Orthodox Rabbis

Almost from the start, the Agudath Harabonim had critics among the Yiddish-speaking rabbis, as well. In particular, Rabbi Gavriel Wolf "Velvel" Margolis felt that the Union was too lax in some areas of Kashrus, too exclusive, and too interfering in the kashrus work he had been hired to do by his congregation. He founded a competing organization, the Knesseth Harabonim (Assembly of Hebrew Orthodox Rabbis).^[5] Evidence of the Knesseth exists starting around 1920,^[4] but a Knesseth convention claims that it had existed for some years previously;^[6] in any event, it had not been a successful organization prior to 1920.^[4]

Several public relations wars broke out between Knesseth and Agudath in the 1920s. Many of them were about competing claims of laxity in meat supervision, wine supervision, or legitimacy of import and licensing of sacramental wine during Prohibition.^[4]^[1] However, not all was war, kashrus, or Prohibition. Both organizations worked on social issues of the day that affected Jews, and on the improvement of rabbinical life for their members.^[7]

Degel Harabanim and Iggud HaRabonim

A third, less-active group was the Council of Orthodox Rabbis (Degel Harabanim in Hebrew). It may have merged with Knesseth shortly after its founding. They are known to have shared conventions, especially in opposition to Agudath.

A later group, also small, is the Iggud HaRabonim (Rabbinical Alliance of America), founded in 1942.^{[citation needed]}

Later years

The disputes among the organization seem to have died down in the late 1940s or 1950s; Knesseth and Degel faded away as a separate organization.^{[citation needed]}

Only Agudath and Iggud still function today, though neither is very active.^{[citation needed]}

Today

Controversies

The organization has not shied away from controversy in the past.^{[citation needed]}

In December 1925, Reform Rabbi Stephen S. Wise delivered a sermon about Jesus the Jew, causing an uproar culminating in an edict of condemnation against him by the Agudath Harabonim.^[8]^[9]

In 1945, at Hotel McAlpin in New York City, the Agudath Harabonim "formally assembled to excommunicate from Judaism what it deemed to be the community's most heretical voice: Rabbi Mordecai Kaplan, the man who eventually would become the founder of Reconstructionist Judaism. Kaplan, a critic of both Orthodox and Reform Judaism, believed that Jewish practice should be reconciled with modern thought, a philosophy reflected in his Sabbath Prayer Book."^[10] The prayer book was allegedly burned.^{[citation needed]}

The group has regularly placed advertisements in Jewish newspapers shortly before the High Holy Days, prohibiting worship at non-Orthodox synagogues.^[11] Similarly, the Friday April 4, 1997 edition of The Jewish Press, quoted from "A Historic Declaration", issued by the Union of Orthodox Rabbis on March 31, 1997:

Reform and Conservative are not Judaism at all. Their adherents are Jews, according to the Jewish Law, but their religion is not Judaism...we appeal to our fellow Jew, members of the Reform and Conservative movements: Having been falsely led by heretical leaders that Reform and Conservative are legitimate branches and denominations of Judaism, we urge you to be guided by this declaration, and withdraw from your affiliation with Reform and Conservative temples and their clergy. Do not hesitate to attend an Orthodox synagogue due to your inadequate observance of Judaism. On the contrary, it is because of that inadequacy that you need to attend an Orthodox synagogue where you will be warmly welcomed...^[12]

The organization also condemned the National Jewish Outreach Program's Shabbat Across America/Canada program because it coordinated and helped Reform and Conservative organizations. In an advertisement placed in the Friday March 7, 2003, edition of The Jewish Press it declared:

...Agudas Horabonim cannot approve of a call to attend a Reform or Conservative temple on Friday night, or any time. As important as Kiruv—bringing Jews closer to the synagogue—is, it must be carried out in accordance with the Halacha. Since the "Shabbat Across America/Canada" does not state that the synagogue must be Orthodox, clearly implying that it can also be a Reform and Conservative temple, the Agudas Harabonim strongly disapproves, and warns all Jews not to take part in the "Shabbat Across America/Canada" program.

One of the leading organizers of the above public protests was Rabbi David Hollander, an Orthodox rabbi and writer in New York.^{[citation needed]}

Simone Veil

In 2005, French politician Simone Veil, an Auschwitz survivor, was invited to speak at the commemoration of the 60th anniversary of the camp's liberation. Yehuda Levin, on behalf of the Union, wrote to the President of Poland that it was inappropriate for Veil to speak at the event, since by "having brought about the legalization of abortion in France" she was "responsible for an ongoing destruction of human life far exceeding that of the Nazis". PR Jan.27, 2005

Notable members

Notable current or recent members of the Union of Orthodox Rabbis of the USA and Canada include:

Rabbi Malkiel Kotler, Rosh Yeshiva of Beth Medrash Govoha of Lakewood.
Rabbi Moshe David Tendler, a senior Rosh Yeshiva at Yeshiva University's RIETS.
Rabbi J. David Bleich, Rosh Yeshiva at Yeshiva University's RIETS and a world-renowned authority on Jewish law and ethics.
Rabbi Reuven Feinstein, Rosh Yeshiva of Mesivtha Tifereth Jerusalem – Staten Island campus.
Rabbi Avraham Osdoba, Senior member of the Crown Heights Beis Din, and Rosh Yeshiva of the Central Chabad Yeshiva.
Rabbi Yosef Heller, Senior member of the Crown Heights Beis Din, and Rosh Kollel of the Crown Heights Kollel.
Rabbi Menachem Genack, chief executive officer of the Orthodox Union Kosher Division.
Rabbi Chaim Shlomo Ginsberg, secretary & Menahel.

Beis Din

The organization's primary function is the Beis Din which serves the Americas. The current members of the Beth Din of the Union of Orthodox Rabbis of the USA and Canada are:

Rabbi Arye Ralbag, Av Beis Din.
Rabbi Chaim Kraus, Senior Dayan.
Rabbi Elimelech Lebowitz, Senior Dayan.
Rabbi Sholom Shuchat, Dayan, Menahel Choshen Mishpat Dept..
Rabbi Tzvi Ralbag, Dayan, Menahel Gittin Dept..
Rabbi Gavriel Stern, Dayan.
Rabbi Ovadia Fabbi, Dayan, Menahel West Coast Dept..

Criticisms

Critics of Agudath Harabonim's efforts claim that the group's leadership does not deserve a media bully pulpit to denounce the practices of other American Jewish movements, because its rabbinical membership represents a statistically small portion of the total number of rabbis ordained by all movements in the United States, and even by the Orthodox movement itself.^[13]^[14]

In addition, they maintain that the group's controversial activities are not vocally supported by the American Orthodox Jewish community as whole, because its centrist and Modern Orthodox rabbinical members generally do not appear with the group during such announcements.^[11] In addition, rabbis maintaining membership in both the UOR and Rabbinical Council of America frequently tend to place greater importance in, and watch more carefully, the activities of the RCA, thus making their support of UOR activities marginal at best.^{[citation needed]}

References

^ ^a ^b Gurock, Jeffrey S. American Jewish History, Volume 5: The history of Judaism in America. KTAV. pp. 110–115.
^ "Moses Margolies, Dean of American Rabbis, Dies at Summer Home", Jewish Telegraphic Agency, August 26, 1936. Accessed March 28, 2023. "Rabbi Margolies was the founder and later honorary president of the Union of Orthodox Rabbis of United States and Canada."
^ "Rabbi Moshe Yisroel Shapiro". kevarim.com.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Sprecher, Hannah. "Orthodox Rabbis React to Prohibition" (PDF). American Jewish Archives. pp. 172–173. Retrieved 3 September 2013. 32. Gurock, Resisters and Accommodators, pp. 147–148, describes this ongoing conflict as follows:
'This senior scholar, the reputed [sic] author of several European-published rabbinic tracts, quickly elected chief rabbi of several New England area congregations, saw little personal value in affiliating with the relatively new rabbinic organization. If anything, he recognized the Agudat ha-Rabbanim as an organizational establishment which stood in the way of his economic and rabbinic-political advancement through the kashruth industry. . . . he undertook a decade-long campaign to undermine the reliability of Agudat ha-Rabbanim within New York Orthodox circles.'
This harsh assessment of Rabbi Margolis's motives differs from the position taken by another respected historian.
Arthur A. Goren, [Transitional] Institutions Transplanted, in The Jews of North America, ed. Moses Rischin (Detroit, 1987), p. 73, describes the conflict as follows: 'In 1911 Adath Israel appointed the eminent rabbi, scholar and preacher, Gabriel Ze'ev Margolis, as its spiritual leader. The Adath Israel leadership, with Margolis at its head and with the support of the Morgen Zhurnal, the Orthodox Yiddish daily, entered the thicket of communal politics. For the next decade it attempted to federate all Orthodox institutions with the goal of communalizing the supervision of kosher meat and religious education. Although the effort proved abortive, it illustrates the communal thrust latent in the traditional hevra kadisha society.'
^ Sprecher. "In January 1920 Gabriel Wolf Margolis finally received the recognition that had eluded him when, together with 135 other he formed the Assembly of Hebrew Orthodox Rabbis of America."
^ "11th Annual Convention of K'nesseth Ha'rabonim". Jewish Daily Bulletin. Jewish Telegraphic Agency. May 12, 1926. Retrieved 28 August 2013.
^ Sprecher. Even the Assembly of Orthodox Rabbis entered the fray, sending telegrams to Wilson, President-elect Harding, and various congressmen. As reprinted in the organization's Sefer Knesset haRabbanim, they contained the following message: "Ministering as we do largely among erstwhile strangers in our land, we can testify that they are ready to embrace American ideals at the first opportunity. To create legislation which would leave undying pain in hearts of all American immigrants would certainly leave a poor background for us to do Americanization work."
^ Adam Soclof (February 5, 2012). "Kosher Jesus - Again". Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
^ "Dr. Wise Resigns From Jewish Fund – Says He Does Not Wish Sermon on Jesus to Hurt United Palestine Appeal – He Explains His Position – Louis Lipsky Defends Him as a Champion of Zionist Cause and Religion of Jews". The New York Times. December 25, 1925.
^ Zachary Silver, "A look back at a different book burning," The Forward, June 3, 2005
^ ^a ^b Debra Nussbaum Cohen, How a small Orthodox group wrote a national story, Jewish Telegraphic Agency [j. the Jewish News Weekly of Northern California], April 4, 1997
^ "Article Details". www.acjna.org.
^ E.g., "The Agudas Horabbonim still exists, but is little more than a paper organization." Jerome Chanes, A Primer on the American Jewish Community, American Jewish Committee
^ E.g., "The Union of Orthodox Rabbis of the U.S. and Canada comprises a fraction of the Orthodox rabbinate in North America, and in Israel, the ultra-Orthodox, despite massive support from the government, still reach only a fraction of the population." Remarks of Eric H. Yoffie, President of the Union for Reform Judaism (then the Union of American Hebrew Congregations), April 12, 1997 Archived February 23, 2008, at the Wayback Machine.

[vol5-1] Gurock, Jeffrey S. American Jewish History, Volume 5: The history of Judaism in America. KTAV. pp. 110–115.

[2] "Moses Margolies, Dean of American Rabbis, Dies at Summer Home", Jewish Telegraphic Agency, August 26, 1936. Accessed March 28, 2023. "Rabbi Margolies was the founder and later honorary president of the Union of Orthodox Rabbis of United States and Canada."

[3] "Rabbi Moshe Yisroel Shapiro". kevarim.com.

[Sprecher-4] Sprecher, Hannah. "Orthodox Rabbis React to Prohibition" (PDF). American Jewish Archives. pp. 172–173. Retrieved 3 September 2013. 32. Gurock, Resisters and Accommodators, pp. 147–148, describes this ongoing conflict as follows:
'This senior scholar, the reputed [sic] author of several European-published rabbinic tracts, quickly elected chief rabbi of several New England area congregations, saw little personal value in affiliating with the relatively new rabbinic organization. If anything, he recognized the Agudat ha-Rabbanim as an organizational establishment which stood in the way of his economic and rabbinic-political advancement through the kashruth industry. . . . he undertook a decade-long campaign to undermine the reliability of Agudat ha-Rabbanim within New York Orthodox circles.'
This harsh assessment of Rabbi Margolis's motives differs from the position taken by another respected historian.
Arthur A. Goren, [Transitional] Institutions Transplanted, in The Jews of North America, ed. Moses Rischin (Detroit, 1987), p. 73, describes the conflict as follows: 'In 1911 Adath Israel appointed the eminent rabbi, scholar and preacher, Gabriel Ze'ev Margolis, as its spiritual leader. The Adath Israel leadership, with Margolis at its head and with the support of the Morgen Zhurnal, the Orthodox Yiddish daily, entered the thicket of communal politics. For the next decade it attempted to federate all Orthodox institutions with the goal of communalizing the supervision of kosher meat and religious education. Although the effort proved abortive, it illustrates the communal thrust latent in the traditional hevra kadisha society.'

[5] Sprecher. "In January 1920 Gabriel Wolf Margolis finally received the recognition that had eluded him when, together with 135 other he formed the Assembly of Hebrew Orthodox Rabbis of America."

[JTA-NewarkConvention-6] "11th Annual Convention of K'nesseth Ha'rabonim". Jewish Daily Bulletin. Jewish Telegraphic Agency. May 12, 1926. Retrieved 28 August 2013.

[7] Sprecher. Even the Assembly of Orthodox Rabbis entered the fray, sending telegrams to Wilson, President-elect Harding, and various congressmen. As reprinted in the organization's Sefer Knesset haRabbanim, they contained the following message: "Ministering as we do largely among erstwhile strangers in our land, we can testify that they are ready to embrace American ideals at the first opportunity. To create legislation which would leave undying pain in hearts of all American immigrants would certainly leave a poor background for us to do Americanization work."

[8] Adam Soclof (February 5, 2012). "Kosher Jesus - Again". Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

[9] "Dr. Wise Resigns From Jewish Fund – Says He Does Not Wish Sermon on Jesus to Hurt United Palestine Appeal – He Explains His Position – Louis Lipsky Defends Him as a Champion of Zionist Cause and Religion of Jews". The New York Times. December 25, 1925.

[10] Zachary Silver, "A look back at a different book burning," The Forward, June 3, 2005

[SmallOrthodoxGroup-11] Debra Nussbaum Cohen, How a small Orthodox group wrote a national story, Jewish Telegraphic Agency [j. the Jewish News Weekly of Northern California], April 4, 1997

[12] "Article Details". www.acjna.org.

[13] E.g., "The Agudas Horabbonim still exists, but is little more than a paper organization." Jerome Chanes, A Primer on the American Jewish Community, American Jewish Committee

[14] E.g., "The Union of Orthodox Rabbis of the U.S. and Canada comprises a fraction of the Orthodox rabbinate in North America, and in Israel, the ultra-Orthodox, despite massive support from the government, still reach only a fraction of the population." Remarks of Eric H. Yoffie, President of the Union for Reform Judaism (then the Union of American Hebrew Congregations), April 12, 1997 Archived February 23, 2008, at the Wayback Machine.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]