Talk:DragonDictate

Dragon Dictate for Mac 2.0 -- has no manual

No manual released of Sept 20, 2010.

Can one correct misrecognized words by re-typing them, as with the Windows NaturallySpeaking

Does "personal vocabulary" mean that it is now easy to correct misrecognized words by re-typing them, so that the program recognizes them in the future, as with current NaturallySpeaking?

Cache problems solved?

The "golden cache" problem of MacSpeech -- has it been solved?

New Dragon Dictate for Mac fix the word training bug in MacSpeech?

7. mwra Member

Although you can train one word in the manner you describe, I've found it has no effect. Even after you have trained a word correctly, Dictate then doesn't pick up the 'correction' in it's Recognition window. It looks like a back-of-house bug where the recognition selections overlook new/retrained vocabulary items in favour of the default vocabulary. At least, that's the only logical way I can explain the errors I'm seeing. Posted 1 year ago #

1.SeanW Member

Often, I find that MacSpeech Dictate dictation errors are small. For example, one word out of an entire sentence is in the incorrect tense. Rather than using the train commands, I've done it more effective and efficient to simply say "select the word and then repeating the word, usually dictate gets the correct version on the first try -- and seems to learn from this. Only use the training commands when correcting a whole sentence or phrase, or when adding a word to vocabulary. Posted 1 year ago #

2. Charlie Member

This technique is certainly efficient, however, Dictate will not learn from changes made in this way. In order for it to learn, the correction has to be done in the Training window. Charlie Posted 1 year ago #

3. DoctorK Member

It's not working for me in the "Training" window. Hours of training on one word - my name!

Posted below in another thread:

I've now spent hours eagerly hoping that the "train the word ____" command would easily and reliably work. Sadly, and even more frustratingly, it doesn't! All I'm trying to do is get it to recognize my name! I say "Kernan" (it's pronounced Kerr Nan) and up comes Conan; Kern and; and multiple others. No matter what technique I've used, nothing works. I keep "training" the word "Kernan" and when the window brings up "Conan", I type in "Kernan" and select it.

I then say my name again, and up comes "Conan". This is going to make me barbaric towards my otherwise grand and brand new iMac.

I have used every suggestion and technique offered in the help manual (very slim guidance) and this forum.

I keep thinking I must be doing something wrong or missing something.

MacSpeech seems to have such promise and gets most of what I say pretty decently. Given that I'm preparing to dictate hundreds of pages of book draft material, I sure would like to get this command down.

Suggestions?Posted 1 year ago #

4. Charlie Member

Hey, DoctorK, see my post responding to your duplicate posting on this subject in the Troubleshooting section. Charlie Posted 1 year ago #

5. fairgo4all Member As a longtime Dragon Dictate User I have just come to the Mac world and delighted with the Mac...got excited when I read and thus bought the MacSpeech. Initial recognition terrific and then discovered simple misrecognition or non-recognition errors couldn't be corrected on the fly

I mean it has all been done for ages in the Dragon parent - simply say - "correct that" (meaning the last utterance)and you can immediately correct it by either choosing the correct alternative or training the correct word on the spot.

To have to go through the WORD Recognition process is to seriously interrupt the thought process-- hate to say it but this knocks MacSpeech out of the ring for me - and I will have to use Dragon 10 or even 9 on the notebook pc for creative dictation.

I will experiment some more but notice another user who has spent more time on it (and has experienced the flow and faster/more practical method long developed and available in Dragon) has reached the same conclusion.

If someone who reads this has any influence with the people who build and offer this program please just tell them that this (inability to easily correct errors as you go) is a serious defect in their offering and should be remedied forthwith. I think it gets close to being a dud for this critical reason. I certainly could not recommend it to anyone until this defect has been fixed. Posted 1 year ago #

6. fairgo4all Member Training one word - like your name is easily done in the panel where you add words and then train them - although I found I had to re-type the word for training...even though it had been added??

My complaint is the error correction function should be in the flow of dictation - as it is in Dragon Dictate - where all of this came from anyway - or so the literature says. Posted 1 year ago #

7. mwra Member Although you can train one word in the manner you describe, I've found it has no effect. Even after you have trained a word correctly, Dictate then doesn't pick up the 'correction' in it's Recognition window. It looks like a back-of-house bug where the recognition selections overlook new/retrained vocabulary items in favour of the default vocabulary. At least, that's the only logical way I can explain the errors I'm seeing. Posted 1 year ago # —Preceding unsigned comment added by 66.167.61.70 (talk) 15:23, 20 September 2010 (UTC)

This entry should state whether MacSpeech Dictate bugs are fixed in "Dragon Dictate for Mac"

MacSpeech Dictate has a bug, encompassed in the "golden rule" workaround requiring users to use no "hands and voice" in the same session (can't just type in a correction for the words it misrecognized and have the program recognize your correction and update its voice model). The result has been train-of-thought shattering hoops to jump through every time. Errors could also not be ignored, because the program would either learn nothing or learn wrong. This and other user interface bugs have been fixed in the Windows version of the Dragon product, but not the Mac version.

MacSpeech also has a cache handling workaround, a cache issue "solved" by a most inconvenient user workaround called the "Golden Cache", so that it requires a steep learning curve to learn how to manage/program the workaround, and attention after learning.

Finally, corrected words don't remain corrected, and laboriously "trained" words won't stay trained.

For these reasons, many buyers have been bitterly disappointed by the failure of MacSpeech Dictate to match the ease promised in the hype. Most put the programs back on the shelf and wrote off their losses.

This section should answer the question of whether the September 20 "Dragon Dictate for Mac" or "Dragon Dictate 2.0" has fixed the serious user interface problems of MacSpeech Dictate.

Hopefully, a "Dragon Dictate for Mac" manual or other detailed description will be made available soon. The failure to release one, and pointing in promotional materials to MacSpeech Dictate's manual, which sets out the unsatisfactory workarounds, is troubling. Hopefully, the lack of a manual does not indicate that the MacSpeech bugs are not fixed. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 68.165.11.115 (talk) 13:25, 21 September 2010 (UTC)