Section 119 of the Constitution of Australia requires the federal government to protect the states against invasion and, on the application of state governments, against domestic civil unrest.
Text
editThe Commonwealth shall protect every State against invasion and, on the application of the Executive Government of the State, against domestic violence.[1]
Drafting
editSection 119 was derived from the Guarantee Clause of Article Four of the United States Constitution, which similarly provides for the federal government to protect the states against invasion and "domestic violence".[2] The need for section 119 has been linked with the existence of section 114, which prohibits the states from raising a military force themselves.[3]
Interpretation
editThe first limb of section 119 has been described as conferring a positive duty on the federal government to protect the states from invasion. The second limb provides for military aid to the civil power and has been interpreted as "a federal constraint on the power of the Commonwealth to call out the military domestically".[4] The term "domestic violence" in the second limb is not defined but has been taken to refer to "local uprisings, insurrections or internal unrest within a state".[5]
Section 119 appears not to allow for unilateral intervention by the federal government, but in reality the military has been called out on a number of occasions using other heads of power in the constitution, notably the "defence power" in section 51(vi) and the "nationhood power" in section 61.[3] Quick and Garran's annotated constitution notes that if "domestic violence within a State is of such a character as to interfere with the operations of the Federal Government, or with the rights and privileges of federal citizenship, the Federal Government may clearly, without a summons from the State, interfere to restore order".[6] A 1998 paper on the subject concluded that "the mechanism provided for in Section 119 of the Constitution has been of little practical importance".[3]
Usage
editSection 119 is referenced in the provisions of the Defence Act 1903 relating to the circumstances in which the federal government may call out the Australian Defence Force. The act states that references to "domestic violence" in the act shall have the same meaning as in section 119.[5]
The second limb of section 119 has only been invoked by state governments on a handful of occasions, which occurred during the 1910s and 1920s. The first formal request made by a state government under section 119 was in 1912, when Queensland premier Digby Denham requested federal assistance to deal with the 1912 Brisbane general strike. Andrew Fisher's government refused the request on the grounds that it was "under circumstances which are proper to be dealt with by the Police Forces of the States".[3] In 1919, New South Wales premier William Holman cabled acting prime minister William Watt to request assistance against "the danger of quarantined soldiers escaping their confinement and then being liable to arrest by local police". The situation was resolved by the military internally.[7] A 1971 review of the Commonwealth Archives Office found five further instances in which state governments had requested that the military be deployed to quell civil unrest, although no formal reference was made to section 119. In each instance the request was refused by the federal government.[3]
| Requests for federal intervention under section 119[3] | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year | State | Premier | Prime Minister | Rationale | Status |
| 1912 | Queensland | Digby Denham | Andrew Fisher | 1912 Brisbane general strike | Refused |
| 1916 | Tasmania | Walter Lee | Billy Hughes | 1916 conscription referendum | Refused |
| 1919 | New South Wales | William Holman | William Watt (acting) | Unrest among quarantined soldiers | Accepted |
| 1919 | Western Australia | Hal Colebatch | William Watt (acting) | 1919 Fremantle Wharf riot | Refused |
| 1921 | Western Australia | James Mitchell | Joseph Cook (acting) | Industrial conflict | Refused |
| 1923 | Victoria | Harry Lawson | S. M. Bruce | 1923 Victorian police strike | Refused |
| 1928 | South Australia | Richard Butler | S. M. Bruce | Industrial conflict | Refused |
References
edit- ^ "Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act (The Constitution) - Sect 119". AustLII. Retrieved 13 July 2022.
- ^ Gray, Anthony (2021). "The Australian Government's use of the military in an emergency and the Constitution" (PDF). University of New South Wales Law Journal. 44 (1): 357–393. doi:10.53637/JJZV8883. S2CID 239750508.
- ^ a b c d e f Ward 1998.
- ^ Stephenson 2019, p. 289.
- ^ a b Gray 2021, p. 362.
- ^ Gray 2021, p. 371.
- ^ "States of emergency". Inside Story. 10 September 2020. Retrieved 16 July 2022.
Further reading
edit- Finnane, Mark (2021). "Phillips' Brief: The Curious Case of a Lost Emergency: Section 119 in 1919". Criminal Law Journal. 45 (2): 134–136.
- Stephenson, Peta (18 March 2019). "Fertile ground for federalism? Internal security, the states and Section 119 of the Constitution". Federal Law Review. 43 (2): 289–312. doi:10.22145/flr.43.2.5.
- Ward, Elizabeth (1998). "Call Out the Troops: an examination of the legal basis for Australian Defence Force involvement in 'non-defence' matters". Research Papers 1997-98. Australian Parliamentary Library.