Wikipedia

Recognition of same-sex unions in Ukraine

Ukraine does not recognize same-sex marriage or civil unions. The Constitution of Ukraine defines marriage as between "a woman and a man". The issue of legal recognition for same-sex couples has become particularly acute after the start of Ukraine's accession to the European Union in 2022 and the Russian large-scale invasion of Ukraine during the Russo-Ukrainian War.[1][2]

In August 2022, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said his government was working on passing a civil partnership law that would provide same-sex couples with some of the rights and benefits of marriage.[3] A petition in support of civil partnerships was submitted to the Verkhovna Rada in April 2023.[4][5] In May 2023, Zelenskyy said that the Ministry of Justice was working on introducing partnership legislation.[6][7] Polling suggests that a majority of Ukrainians support the legal recognition of same-sex registered partnerships.[8][9][10][11] Ukraine is also obliged to introduce a same-sex union law under a June 2023 ruling by the European Court of Human Rights.[12]

edit

Background

edit

Article 51 of the Constitution of Ukraine, adopted by the Verkhovna Rada (the Parliament of Ukraine) in 1996, states: "Marriage is based on the free consent of a woman and a man. Each of the spouses has equal rights and duties in the marriage and family."[13] In June 2018, the Ministry of Justice said that "there is no legal grounds" for same-sex marriage in Ukraine.[14] The wording of Article 51 is interpreted as banning same-sex marriage; however, Olha Sovgirya, a justice of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine, believes that the Constitution does not prohibit same-sex marriage, arguing that the "emphasis in Article 51 is on the freedom of marrying a member of the opposite sex, and not on the fact that the parties should be of different sexes."[15]

Civil partnerships

edit

2015 action plan

edit

On 23 November 2015, the Government of Ukraine approved an action plan to implement a "National Strategy on Human Rights" in the period up to 2020, which included the promise of drafting a bill creating civil partnerships for opposite-sex and same-sex couples by 2017.[16][17][18] However, in early 2018, the Ministry of Justice, led by Pavlo Petrenko, stated that "the development and submission to the government of a draft law on the legalization of a registered civil partnership in Ukraine cannot be implemented" due to "numerous appeals from the regional councils, the Council of Churches and other religious organizations".[19]

2022 petition

edit
 
Laws regarding same-sex partnerships in Europe¹
  Marriage
  Civil union
  Limited domestic recognition (cohabitation)
  Limited foreign recognition (residency rights)
  Unrecognized
  Constitution limits marriage to opposite-sex couples
¹ May include recent laws or court decisions that have not yet entered into effect.

On 3 June 2022, an online petition was launched on the official website of the President of Ukraine calling for the legalization of same-sex marriage. Citing the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the text of the petition stated: "At this time, every day may be the last. Let people of the same sex have the opportunity to start a family and have an official document confirming this. They need the same rights as traditional couples." Oksana Solonska, the media communications manager of Kyiv Pride, said, "It is important that LGBTQ people have the right to see their partner and take their body from the morgue, and seek compensation if needed. All married couples have these rights. We really hope that same-sex marriage will be legalised, so people will be able to take care of each other." The petition quickly gained signatures, and by 13 July, the petition had gathered more than 28,000 signatures. Any petitions that gather more than 25,000 signatures automatically trigger the president's consideration.[20]

On 2 August 2022, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy issued an official response to the petition. Zelenskyy said it would be impossible to legalize same-sex marriage without an amendment to the Constitution of Ukraine, and that "[t]he Constitution of Ukraine cannot be changed during martial law or a state of emergency". "The Family Code of Ukraine defines that the family is the primary and main unit of society. A family consists of persons who live together, are connected by common life, have mutual rights and obligations. According to the Constitution of Ukraine, marriage is based on the free consent of a woman and a man (Article 51)",[3] Zelenskyy wrote. However, Zelenskyy said that his government would work on a bill to legalize civil partnerships in Ukraine. "In the modern world, the level of democratic society is measured, among other things, through state policy aimed at ensuring equal rights for all citizens. Every citizen is an inseparable part of civil society, he is entitled to all the rights and freedoms enshrined in the Constitution of Ukraine. All people are free and equal in their dignity and rights."[21] He called on Prime Minister Denys Shmyhal to address the issue.[22] Shmyhal instructed the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of Social Policy to consider the issues raised in the petition. Ukraine is obliged under the European Court of Human Rights' ruling in Fedotova and Others v. Russia to provide legal recognition to same-sex unions. In January 2023, the Grand Chamber ruled that Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which guarantees a right to private and family life, places a positive obligation on all member states of the Council of Europe to recognize same-sex partnerships.[23]

The Russo-Ukrainian War has spurred efforts within the military to legalize same-sex unions, because the partners of gay soldiers are not afforded the same rights and privileges as opposite-sex partners, "although they are fighting just as bravely as their fellow straight combat troops". A soldier in the Donbas said, "When we defend the country, we dismantle Russian propaganda about all gay people being communists, Marxists, and anti-Ukraine. We have destroyed these homophobic myths by fighting the Russians and risking our lives for Ukraine."[24] In August 2023, two women, Stanislava Petlysia and Alina Shevchenko, held a symbolic same-sex wedding ceremony in Kharkiv to protest the lack of legal recognition of same-sex relationships.[25][26]

Introduction of legislation in 2023

edit

Same-sex couples do not have a right to inheritance, hospital visitations or to make medical decisions for an ill partner. "If [my] (partner) dies ... [I] won't be allowed even to bury [him] ... they might not let [me] into the hospital", said a cadet specialising in aerial reconnaissance who had joined the Armed Forces of Ukraine in the wake of the Russian invasion. LGBT groups described Zelenskyy's statement as "historic", and called on a bill to be passed as soon as possible: "People need this now", said Olena Shevchenko.[27] The introduction of civil partnerships (Ukrainian: цивільне партнерство, cyvílʹne partnérstvo, pronounced [tseˈʋ⁽ʲ⁾ilʲne pɐrtˈnɛrstwɔ])[a] would allow same-sex couples to enjoy some of the rights and benefits of marriage, including property rights, maintenance, inheritance, and spousal privilege, among others. MP Inna Sovsun said she was considering introducing her own civil union bill to Parliament should the government fail to do so.[15] Sovsun introduced a civil partnership bill with 18 cosponsors in March 2023.[29] The bill passed two parliamentary committees with unanimous support in May.[30] A petition in support of registered partnerships was submitted to Parliament in April 2023 with 25,000 signatures.[4]

In May 2023, Zelenskyy said that the Ministry of Justice was working on introducing its own partnership bill.[6][7] The Ministry gave final approval to a draft civil union bill on 22 October 2023,[31] and the government vowed to approve it by the end of 2023.[32][33] Conservative politician Andriy Kozhemiakin of the Batkivshchyna party told Parliament in June 2023 he supported the measure because "If it will never exist in Russia, it should exist and be supported here."[34] However, the bill has stalled due to opposition from members of the Legal Affairs Committee.[35] In August 2024, the Committee on National Health, Medical Care and Medical Insurance recommended the Parliament to pass the legislation.[36][37] Zelenskyy reiterated his support in November 2024.[38]

Maymulakhin and Markiv v. Ukraine

edit

On 1 June 2023, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled in Maymulakhin and Markiv v. Ukraine that the Ukrainian Government had violated the human rights of a same-sex couple, Andriy Maymulakhin and Andriy Markiv, by denying them a marriage license. The couple had been denied a license at seven registry offices in Kyiv in October 2014, and challenged the refusal at the ECHR in November 2014.[39] The ECHR has also issued similar rulings with respect to Russia in Fedotova and Others, and Romania in Buhuceanu and Others.[40] The court ruled that Article 8 (right to respect for private and family life) and Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) of the European Convention on Human Rights require the government to recognise same-sex unions:[12]

As a result, same-sex couples were denied any opportunity to regulate fundamental aspects of life as a couple except certain property-related aspects, and then only as private individuals entering into contracts under the ordinary law. The Court has already held that such private contractual agreements cannot be considered to give recognition and the required protection to a couple, as they are limited in scope and fail to provide for basic rights. In general, there was no possibility for a same-sex couple to rely on the existence of their relationship in dealings with the judicial or administrative authorities, as regards, for example, the right to joint matrimonial property, the right to inheritance by law, the right to receive visits from the partner in the event of hospitalisation, the right to refuse to testify against one another, the right to adoption, and the right to social assistance and benefits for low-income families. It followed that Mr Maymulakhin and Mr Markiv had been treated differently from opposite-sex couples on account of the lack of any legal recognition and protection for them. Their sexual orientation had been the sole basis for the difference in treatment.

Religious performance

edit

The Catholic Church opposes same-sex marriage and does not allow its priests to officiate at such marriages. In December 2023, the Holy See published Fiducia supplicans, a declaration allowing Catholic priests to bless couples who are not considered to be married according to church teaching, including the blessing of same-sex couples.[41] The Conference of Roman Catholic Bishops in Ukraine issued a statement that it saw a "danger in ambiguous wording that causes divergent interpretations among the faithful". "What we missed in the document is that the Gospel calls sinners to conversion, and without a call to leave the sinful life of homosexual couples, the blessing may look like an endorsement." The Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church, in full communion with the Holy See, announced it would not bless same-sex couples. Major Archbishop Sviatoslav Shevchuk said the declaration "has no legal force for the faithful of the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church".[42][43]

Public opinion

edit

Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022 has bolstered support for the recognition of same-sex unions in Ukraine. Surveys by Nash Svit for the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology showed that opposition to same-sex civil unions had decreased from 69% in 2016 to 42% in 2022. Jul Sirous, a coordinator for volunteers and teamwork at Kyiv Pride, said, "[People are] now looking at some things in a completely different light because compared to the fact that a person might be gone tomorrow, the fact that they are gay or a lesbian – we're not paying attention to that."[27][44]

A 2022 poll conducted by the Center for Social Expertise of the Institute of Sociology at the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine showed that 27% of Ukrainians supported same-sex marriage and 26% supported it with "some exceptions", meaning that 53% supported the recognition of same-sex unions in some form. This represented a large increase from 2016 when 33% of the population supported recognising same-sex unions.[45]

According to a poll conducted in January 2023 by the National Democratic Institute with the help of the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology, 56% of Ukrainians agreed that same-sex partners should have the right to register their relationship in the form of a civil partnership, while 24% disagreed. In addition, 44% of Ukrainians supported same-sex marriage, while 36% were opposed, and 30% supported adoption by same-sex couples, while 48% were against.[46] According to a June 2024 survey by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology, 29% of respondents said they supported civil partnerships for same-sex couples without the possibility to adopt, while 36% were opposed and 26% were "indifferent".[47]

See also

edit

Notes

edit
  1. ^ Russian: гражданское партнёрство, graždánskoje partnjórstvo, pronounced [ɡrɐʐˈdanskəjə pɐrt⁽ʲ⁾ˈnʲɵrstvə];[28] Crimean Tatar: vatandaş ortaqlıq, pronounced [vɑtɑnˈdɑʃ ortɑqˈlɯq]

References

edit
  1. ^ Війна загострила питання легалізації одностатевих шлюбів, - Злобіна (in Ukrainian), retrieved 2023-05-29
  2. ^ Донбас.Реалії (2022-12-15). ""Ми захищаємо країну нарівні з іншими" – ЛГБТ-військові про важливість легалізації одностатевих стосунків". Радіо Свобода (in Ukrainian). Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  3. ^ a b Pietsch, Bryan (2022-08-04). "Zelensky floats civil unions amid gay marriage push in Ukraine". Washington Post. ISSN 0190-8286. Retrieved 2022-08-28.
  4. ^ a b Суспільне Новини (29 March 2023). "На сайті президента з'явилась петиція на підтримку закону про реєстровані партнерства". Retrieved 6 May 2023.
  5. ^ "Цивільне партнерство в Україні: чому це актуально під час війни". Гречка - інформаційний портал кіровоградщини (in Ukrainian). Retrieved 2023-05-03.
  6. ^ a b "Рухаємось назустріч європейським стандартам. Зеленський відповів на петицію про реєстрацію партнерства для одностатевих пар — Delo.ua". delo.ua (in Ukrainian). 2023-05-26. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  7. ^ a b "Зеленський відповів на петицію про цивільні партнерства". Українська правда _Життя. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  8. ^ "Більше половини українців ставиться до ЛГБТ-людей позитивно або байдуже – опитування". The Village Україна. 2022-06-03. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  9. ^ "За майже десять років побільшало українців, які підтримують права гомосексуальних пар на реєстрацію сімейних стосунків – дослідження | ZMINA". zmina.info (in Ukrainian). 2022-07-15. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  10. ^ "Одностатевим союзам – так? Що таке цивільне партнерство й коли його чекати в Україні". The Village Україна. 2022-08-15. Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  11. ^ Oprishchenko, Anastasiya (2023-03-08). "Що таке цивільне партнерство та чи дозволить воно зареєструвати шлюб одностатевим парам в Україні". Заборона (in Ukrainian). Retrieved 2023-05-29.
  12. ^ a b "Maymulakhin and Markiv v. Ukraine" (PDF). European Court of Human Rights. 1 June 2023.
  13. ^ "Constitution of Ukraine" (PDF). www.refword.org. Retrieved August 27, 2022.
  14. ^ "Justice ministry: No legal grounds in Ukraine currently for same-sex marriage | KyivPost - Ukraine's Global Voice". KyivPost. 18 June 2018.
  15. ^ a b "Одностатевим союзам – так? Що таке цивільне партнерство й коли його чекати в Україні". The Village (in Ukrainian). 15 August 2022.
  16. ^ "Ukrainian government plans to submit a bill on same-sex 'civil partnership' legalization". uatoday.tv. 11 March 2016. Retrieved 12 March 2016.
  17. ^ "The Cabinet plans to legalize same-sex unions and HIV-positive can be allowed to adopt children". reporter-ua.ru. 11 March 2016. Retrieved 12 March 2016.
  18. ^ "Текст документа: "Про затвердження плану дій з реалізації Національної стратегії у сфері прав людини на період до 2020 року" № 1393-р — редакція від 23.11.2015". Ukrainian Government Portal (in Ukrainian). 23 November 2015. Retrieved 12 March 2016.
  19. ^ Same-sex marriage in Ukraine: accept or deny?, UNIAN (14 February 2018)
  20. ^ "Ukraine to consider legalising same-sex marriage amid war". BBC News. 12 July 2022.
  21. ^ "Zelensky opens door to same-sex civil partnerships in Ukraine". CNN. 3 August 2022.
  22. ^ "Ukraine president asks gov't to study legalising same-sex marriages". Reuters. 2 August 2022.
  23. ^ "ECtHR: refusal of any form of legal recognition and protection for same-sex couples breaches Convention". EU Law Live. 17 January 2023.
  24. ^ Javaid, Maham; Bilefsky, Dan (August 4, 2022). "War Spurs Ukrainian Efforts to Legalize Same-Sex Marriage: The role of gay soldiers, the lack of legal rights for their partners, and the threat of Russia imposing anti-L.G.B.T. policies have turned the war into a catalyst for change in Ukraine". New York Times. p. A4. Archived from the original on 2 August 2022. Retrieved November 5, 2022.
  25. ^ Court, Elsa (26 August 2023). "Women hold symbolic wedding to show lack of rights for same-sex couples". The Kyiv Independent.
  26. ^ Abdul, Geneva (31 December 2023). "Same-sex couples fight for civil unions to be legalised in Ukraine". The Guardian.
  27. ^ a b Vikhrov, Natalie (25 August 2022). "Ukraine war fuels public support for same-sex marriage". Thomas Reuters Foundation News.
  28. ^ "Что на самом деле ответил Зеленский про однополые браки? Читаем между строк". Life.nv.ua (in Russian). 4 August 2022.
  29. ^ "Ukrainian MP introduces bill to legally recognize same-sex couples". Washington Blade. 7 March 2023.
  30. ^ Shmigel, Pete (19 May 2023). "New Developments in Same-Sex Partnership Registration for LGBTQ Soldiers in Ukraine". Kyiv Post.
  31. ^ "Ukraine takes first steps to codify gay marriage". bne IntelliNews. 24 October 2023.
  32. ^ "Zelenskyy responds to civil partnerships petition". Yahoo!. 27 May 2023.
  33. ^ Abdul, Geneva (31 December 2023). "Same-sex couples fight for civil unions to be legalised in Ukraine". The Guardian.
  34. ^ "War brings urgency to fight for LGBT rights in Ukraine". The Guardian. 5 June 2023. Retrieved 5 June 2023.
  35. ^ Mackenzie, Jean (25 June 2024). "LGBT troops on Ukraine's front line fight homophobia at home". BBC. Retrieved 25 June 2024.
  36. ^ Herasimova, Tetiana (12 August 2024). "Rada's Health Care Committee recommends adopting bill on same-sex partnerships". Ukrainian News.
  37. ^ "Комітет Ради підтримав законопроєкт про цивільні партнерства". Укрінформ (in Ukrainian). 9 August 2024.
  38. ^ Alekseev, Victor (17 November 2024). "Zelenskiy Promises to Sign Bill on Registered Partnerships". Glavnoe.ua.
  39. ^ Quell, Molly (1 June 2023). "Ukraine must allow same-sex unions, European rights court rules". Courthouse News Services.
  40. ^ Knight, Kyle (8 September 2023). "Court Rules Bulgaria Must Recognize Same-Sex Relationships". Human Rights Watch.
  41. ^ Flynn, JD (2023-12-22). "Is the 'false narrative' narrative a false narrative?". The Pillar. Archived from the original on 23 December 2023. Retrieved 2023-12-23.
  42. ^ Coppen, Luke (19 December 2023). "'Fiducia supplicans': Who's saying what?". The Pillar.
  43. ^ "Ukrainian Catholic church says document on blessing same-sex couples does not apply". Reuters. 23 December 2023.
  44. ^ "Більше половини українців ставиться до ЛГБТ-людей позитивно або байдуже – опитування". The Village (in Ukrainian). 3 June 2022.
  45. ^ "Право гомосексуальних пар на реєстрацію шлюбу підтримує удвічі більше українців, ніж 10 років тому". The Village (in Ukrainian). 16 July 2022.
  46. ^ "Нове соціологічне дослідження підтвердило радикальне поліпшення ставлення українського суспільства до ЛГБТК". gay.org.ua (in Ukrainian). 24 February 2023.
  47. ^ "PERCEPTION OF LGBT PEOPLE AND THEIR RIGHTS IN UKRAINE: RESULTS OF A TELEPHONE SURVEY CONDUCTED ON MAY 26 - JUNE 1, 2024". Kyiv International Institute of Sociology. 17 June 2024. Retrieved 17 July 2024.
    Nate Ostiller (18 June 2024). "Poll: More than 70% of Ukrainians say LGBTQ people should have same rights as any other citizen". The Kyiv Independent. Retrieved 8 July 2024.
Retrieved from "https://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=Recognition_of_same-sex_unions_in_Ukraine&oldid=1260531387"