Wikipedia

Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare

Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare is a 2014 book authored by Gareth Porter, an American historian, investigative journalist, author and policy analyst specializing in U.S. national security policy. In this 310-page book,[1] he asserts that Iran's nuclear energy program has been peaceful, arguing that the evidence widely cited to demonstrate Iran's nuclear weapons ambitions is fabricated by Israel and the United States.[2][3]

Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare
Front cover of the book showing Israel PM Benjamin Netanyahu speaking before UN general assembly
AuthorGareth Porter
LanguageEnglish
PublisherJust World Books
Publication date
February 1, 2014
Publication placeUnited States
Pages310
ISBN978-1935982333
WebsiteJust World Books Webstore

Contents

edit

The book consists of the following chapters:[4]

  1. The US Denial Policy and Its Consequences
  2. The Politics of Iran’s Nuclear Secrecy
  3. Iran’s Unknown Nuclear Politics
  4. US Political Origins of the Nuclear Scare
  5. Israeli Political Origins of the Nuclear Scare
  6. Choosing Regime Change Over Diplomacy
  7. The IAEA Comes Up Empty
  8. The Mystery of the Laptop Documents
  9. Intelligence Failure
  10. The Phantom Bomb Test Chamber of Parchin
  11. Phony War Crises

Synopsis

edit

Starting with "U.S. support for the Iraqis during the 1980s Iraq–Iran War", the book argues that with the collapse of the Soviet Union and the ending of the Cold War, Americans saved the CIA by giving it a new reason to exist, the new threat posed by the combination of "weapons of mass destruction" and "terror".[5] Taking seriously the declarations of Ali Khamenei, Iran's supreme leader, and of his predecessor, Ruhollah Khomeini, that nuclear weapons are against teachings of Islam and hence Iran is not seeking them, Porter says that the pressure by U.S. to prevent Tehran's development of its civilian nuclear program left them with only the Hobson's choice of working covertly and covering their tracks.

According to John Waterbury, "The risk for Israel and the United States, of course, is that they might have to go to war to confront a threat that, Porter alleges, they know does not exist."[2]

According to the Fars News Agency, in addition to explaining why Tehran covered its nuclear activity, the author deals with the issues such as the alleged smuggled laptop, Parchin test chamber and the role of Israel in creating the crisis.[6][unreliable source?]

Porter argues in his book that the root of the crisis is in fact "Washington's denial of Iran's right to a peaceful nuclear program" and not "Iran's defiance of the nuclear nonproliferation treaty."[7]

Reception

edit

According to Al-Monitor columnist Akiva Eldar, a number of contentions in Porter's book have been independently made by Uzi Eilam, a senior intelligence source who won the Israel Security Prize and served in the Israeli Atomic Energy Commission as a director for nine years. Senior Israeli security officials said Eilam was not aware of recent information and that he is "out of the loop".[8]

Shmuel Meir, a research fellow at the Center for Strategic Studies at Tel Aviv University and former researcher at the IDF's intelligence unit and the IDF’s Planning Department strategic unit, called Porter "the only journalist and investigator in the world who read, with an unbiased eye, all the IAEA reports and the American intelligence reports of the last several decades regarding the Iranian issue"[8][5] and said that the book was "highly detailed and well-documented" and suitable for "all interested in understanding how we arrived at the Iranian nuclear crisis, and the 'attack scenarios', and invented facts and intelligence reports whose purpose was to support the preconceptions".[5]

Josh Ruebner in Foreign Policy in Focus wrote that the book is "meticulously researched and richly detailed". Among Porter's conclusions is one that regards the efforts to include Iran's ballistic missiles within the nuclear negotiations after the interim deal was signed without them as "an Israeli-inspired monkey wrench thrown by its lobby ... to derail the talks".[9] Alex Cacioppo's review in Muftah says that, using information from "open source documentation and revealed through in-depth interviews with key players", Porter draws a different picture from the experts and politicians who portray Iran as a "transgressing power with nefarious nuclear ambitions".[10]

In October 2014, Hans Blix, former director general of the IAEA and former executive chairman of the United Nations Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission (UNMOVIC), participated in a televised HBO History Makers Series conference with the Council on Foreign Relations. When asked if he thought Iran's nuclear program could be successfully monitored, he replied that he was more worried about the handling of intelligence, "because there is as much disinformation as there is information. There was a book published by Gareth Porter in the U.S. some time ago about the whole Iranian affair, and, well, he certainly maintains that much of the evidence that was given to the IAEA was really cooked, was not authentic. And I wouldn't be at all surprised."[11] According to the publisher of Porter's book, shortly after it was published, Blix wrote: "I feel grateful to Gareth Porter for his intrusive and critical examination of intelligence material passed to the IAEA."[12] Alluding to the assassinations of Iranian nuclear scientists, he added: "When security organizations do not shy away from assassinating nuclear scientists we can take it for certain that they do not for a moment hesitate to circulate false evidence."[12][13]

According to William Beeman, professor and chair of the Department of Anthropology, University of Minnesota, Porter's narration of how consensus was built over the threat of Iran's nuclear program is fascinating because he has created a convincing account of the incident which demonstrates how the background for attacking Iran was mixed with "lies and misinformation" over many years.[14] He makes prominent mention of Robert Gates, an increasingly influential member of the US government who eventually became Secretary of Defense, as a possible "prime mover" of this Iran policy.[14] Porter "exposes the many lies and half-truths that have been promulgated over more than two decades to try and convince the American public and the world that Iran is the chief danger to international peace through its nuclear program".[14]

Paul R. Pillar, a 28-year veteran of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) until his retirement in 2005,[15] described the book in a Middle East Policy Council journal review as "an admirably thorough treatment" of the Iranian nuclear program and the perception of it and response to it by Israeli and American policymakers.[16] He wrote that the book's two most significant contributions are "as an overall history of the understanding, or misunderstanding, of the Iranian program" and its debunking of "the conventional wisdom that Iran is set on getting nuclear weapons", and noted Porter's thorough examination and assessment of both.[16] Pillar said that Porter was "much less convincing", however, when he failed to support his repetition of the old cliché that to maintain their funding levels, almost all of the American security establishment was exaggerating the actual threat of weapons proliferation.[16] He also noted that Porter's "effort to spread attributions of bias around very broadly" resulted in a minimization of the actual political differences of the various presidential administrations, especially the "sharp" distinction between the George W. Bush and Barack Obama policies.[16]

Translation

edit

The book is translated into Persian and published in Iran. Both translation and publication is done by Fars News Agency publication.[6]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ Gareth Porter (2014). Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare. ISBN 978-1935982333.
  2. ^ a b Waterbury, John (2014). "Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare". Foreign Affairs. ISBN 978-1935982333. Retrieved January 5, 2016.
  3. ^ Staff (January 31, 2014). "Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare". Just World Books. Retrieved January 5, 2016.
  4. ^ Staff writers. "Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare". www.iranreview.org. Retrieved 12 January 2016.
  5. ^ a b c Meir, Shemuel (31 May 2014). "Was the Iranian threat fabricated by Israel and the U.S.?". Ha'aretz. Retrieved 5 February 2016.
  6. ^ a b Staff. "خبرگزاری فارس – بحران ساختگی:‌ داستان ناگفته هراس از ایران هسته‌ای". خبرگزاری فارس (in Persian). Retrieved 5 January 2016.
  7. ^ Hautaviita, Johannes. "An analysis of the nuclear crisis between the US and its allies and Iran". Helsinki Times. Retrieved 4 February 2016.
  8. ^ a b Eldar, Akiva. "An Israeli scare campaign about Iran's nuclear program?". Al-monitor. Archived from the original on 2014-05-31. Retrieved 5 February 2016.
  9. ^ Ruebner, Josh (2014-03-03). "Overcoming the "Manufactured Crisis" with Iran – FPIF". Foreign Policy In Focus. Retrieved 7 January 2016.
  10. ^ Cacioppo, Alex. "A Review of Gareth Porter's Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare". Muftah. Retrieved 7 January 2016.
  11. ^ Hans Blix on a Legacy of Nuclear Safeguards and InspectionsArchived 2017-03-19 at the Wayback Machine
  12. ^ a b Gareth Porter adds timely facts, realism to Iran/nuclear discussion Archived 2016-08-20 at the Wayback Machine; Just World Books; October 21, 2014
  13. ^ McGovern, Ray. "Trial Begins in Case of Ex-CIA Officer Allegedly Divulging Secrets to Journalist". Alternet. Retrieved 5 February 2016.
  14. ^ a b c Beeman, William O. "Did Robert Gates Manufacture the Iran Crisis?". Huffington Post. Retrieved 5 February 2016.
  15. ^ "Paul R. PIllar". Brookings Institution. Archived from the original on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 12 February 2016.
  16. ^ a b c d Pillar, Paul R. (Fall 2014). "Manufactured Crisis: The Untold Story of the Iran Nuclear Scare – Book Review". Middle East Policy Council Journal. Vol. XXI, no. 3. Retrieved 12 February 2016.
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=Manufactured_Crisis:_The_Untold_Story_of_the_Iran_Nuclear_Scare&oldid=1167755420"