Year
|
Author(s)/Editor(s)
|
Title
|
Publisher
|
Result
|
Ref.
|
1990s
|
1992
|
Randy Stradley (ed.)
|
Dark Horse Presents
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Winner
|
[1]
|
Stephen R. Bissette and others (eds.)
|
Taboo #5
|
Spiderbaby Grafix/Tundra Publishing
|
Nominee
|
[1]
|
Dave Elliott and Gary Leach (eds.)
|
A1 #5
|
Atomeka Press
|
Nominee
|
[1]
|
Diane Noomin (ed.)
|
Twisted Sisters
|
Penguin Books
|
Nominee
|
[1]
|
Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly (eds.)
|
Raw vol. 2, #3
|
Raw Books/Penguin Books
|
Nominee
|
[1]
|
1993
|
Stephen R. Bissette (ed.)
|
Taboo
|
Spiderbaby Grafix/Tundra Publishing
|
Winner
|
[2]
|
Dennis Eichhorn (ed.)
|
Real Stuff
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[2]
|
David Mazzucchelli and Richmond Lewis (eds.)
|
Rubber Blanket
|
Rubber Blanket Press
|
Nominee
|
[2]
|
Chris Oliveros (ed.)
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Nominee
|
[2]
|
Byron Preiss (ed.)
|
The Ray Bradbury Chronicles
|
Bantam Books
|
Nominee
|
[2]
|
Jerry Prosser and Rich Shupe (eds.)
|
The Residents: Freak Show
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Nominee
|
[2]
|
1994
|
Randy Stradley (ed.)
|
Dark Horse Presents
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Winner
|
[3]
|
Karen Berger (ed.)
|
Vertigo Comics Jam
|
DC Comics/Vertigo Comics
|
Nominee
|
[3]
|
Dennis Eichhorn (ed.)
|
Real Stuff
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[3]
|
Jerry Prosser (ed.)
|
Andrew Vachss' Hard Looks
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Nominee
|
[3]
|
Howard Zimmerman (ed.)
|
Ray Bradury Comics
|
Topps Comics
|
Nominee
|
[3]
|
1995
|
Andy Helfer (ed.)
|
Big Book of Urban Legends
|
Paradox Press
|
Winner
|
[4]
|
Diane Noomin (ed.)
|
Twisted Sisters
|
Kitchen Sink Press
|
Nominee
|
[4]
|
Chris Oliveros (ed.)
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Nominee
|
[4]
|
Randy Stradley and Bob Schreck (eds.)
|
Dark Horse Presents
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Nominee
|
[4]
|
1996
|
Bronwyn Taggart (ed.)
|
Big Book of Conspiracies
|
Paradox Press
|
Winner
|
[5]
|
Monte Beauchamp (ed.)
|
BLAB! #8
|
Kitchen Sink Press
|
Nominee
|
[5]
|
Joe R. Lansdale and Richard Klaw (eds.)
|
Weird Business
|
Mojo Press
|
Nominee
|
[5]
|
Chris Oliveros (ed.)
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Nominee
|
[5]
|
Kim Thompson (ed.)
|
Zero Zero
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[5]
|
1997
|
Mark Chiarello and Scott Peterson (eds.)
|
Batman Black and White
|
DC Comics
|
Winner
|
[6]
|
Tony Bedard (ed.), by Peter Gutierrez and various artists
|
Shi: Kaidan
|
Crusade Comics
|
Nominee
|
[6]
|
Jim Higgins (ed.), by Carl Sifakis and various artists
|
Big Book of Hoaxes
|
Paradox Press
|
Nominee
|
[6]
|
Joe Pruett (ed.)
|
Negative Burn
|
Caliber Comics
|
Nominee
|
[6]
|
Randy Stradley (ed.)
|
A Decade of Dark Horse Comics
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Nominee
|
[6]
|
1998
|
Scott Allie (ed.)
|
Hellboy Christmas Special
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Winner
|
[7]
|
Monte Beauchamp (ed.)
|
BLAB! #9
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[7]
|
Karen Hirsch (ed.)
|
Mind Riot
|
Simon & Schuster/Aladdin Paperbacks
|
Nominee
|
[7]
|
Jim Ottaviani (ed.)
|
Two-Fisted Science
|
G.T. Labs
|
Nominee
|
[7]
|
Shelly Roeberg (ed.)
|
Vertigo Comics: Winters Edge
|
DC Comics/Vertigo Comics
|
Nominee
|
[7]
|
Kim Thompson (ed.)
|
Zero Zero
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[7]
|
1999
|
Diana Schutz (ed.), by Matt Wagner
|
Grendel: Black, White and Red & Red, White and Black
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Winner
|
[8]
|
Andy Helfe Kirchner, Steve Vance, and Anina Bennett
|
Big Book of Bad
|
Paradox Press/DC Comics
|
Nominee
|
[8]
|
Joe Pruett (ed.)
|
Negative Burn #50
|
Caliber Comics
|
Nominee
|
[8]
|
Bob Schreck (ed.)
|
Oni Double Feature
|
Oni Press
|
Nominee
|
[8]
|
Jeff Smith, Mark Crilley, Linda Medley, Stan Sakai, Jill Thompson, and Charles Vess
|
Trilogy Tour II Book
|
Cartoon Books
|
Nominee
|
[8]
|
2000s
|
2000
|
Scott Dunbier (ed.), by Alan Moore, Rick Veitch, Kevin Nowlan, Melinda Gebbie, and Jim Baikie
|
Tomorrow Stories
|
America's Best Comics
|
Winner
|
[9]
|
Monte Beauchamp (ed.)
|
BLAB!
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[9]
|
Brian Clopper (ed.)
|
Brainbomb
|
Behemoth Books
|
Nominee
|
[9]
|
Etgar Keret, Mira Friedmann, Batia Kolton, Rutu Modan, Yirmi Pinkus, and Itzik Rennert
|
Jet Lag
|
Actus Tragicus
|
Nominee
|
[9]
|
Jean-Christophe Menu (ed.)
|
Comix 2000
|
L'Association
|
Nominee
|
[9]
|
Jim Ottaviani (ed.)
|
Dignifying Science
|
G.T. Labs
|
Nominee
|
[9]
|
2001
|
Chris Oliveros (ed.)
|
Drawn & Quarterly, vol. 3
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Winner
|
[10]
|
Jon B. Cooke and John Morrow (eds.)
|
Streetwise
|
TwoMorrows Publishing
|
Nominee
|
[10]
|
Patrizia Crivelli and others (eds.)
|
Strapazin: Bubbles 'n' Boxes and Beyond
|
Swiss Institute of New York/Swiss Federal Office of Culture
|
Nominee
|
[10]
|
Tom Devlin and others (eds.)
|
Expo 2000
|
Small Press Expo
|
Nominee
|
[10]
|
Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly (eds.)
|
Little Lit
|
HarperCollins
|
Nominee
|
[10]
|
2002
|
Joey Cavalieri (ed.)
|
Bizarro Comics
|
DC Comics
|
Winner
|
[11]
|
Gary Groth and Anne Elizabeth Moore (eds.)
|
Comics Journal Winter Special 2002
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[11]
|
Chris Oliveros (ed.)
|
Drawn & Quarterly, vol. 4
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Nominee
|
[11]
|
Jamie S. Rich (ed.)
|
Oni Press Summer Color Special 2001
|
Oni Comics
|
Nominee
|
[11]
|
Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly (eds.)
|
Little Lit: Strange Stories for Strange Kids
|
HarperCollins
|
Nominee
|
[11]
|
2003
|
|
SPX 2002
|
CBLDF
|
Winner
|
[12]
|
Ben Catmull and Dylan Williams (eds.)
|
Orchid
|
Sparkplug Comics
|
Nominee
|
[12]
|
Tim Ervin-Gore (ed.)
|
Super Manga Blast
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Nominee
|
[12]
|
Ng Suat Tong (ed.)
|
Rosetta: A Comics Anthology
|
Alternative Comics
|
Nominee
|
[12]
|
2004
|
Karen Berger and Shelly Bond (eds.), by Neil Gaiman, Dave McKean, P. Craig Russell, Miguelanxo Prado, Barron Storey, Frank Quitely, Glenn Fabry, Milo Manara, and Bill Sienkiewicz
|
The Sandman: Endless Nights
|
Vertigo Comics/DC Comics
|
Winner
|
[13]
|
Scott Allie (ed.)
|
The Dark Horse Book of Hauntings
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Nominee
|
[13]
|
Chris Oliveros (ed.)
|
Drawn & Quarterly, vol. 5
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Nominee
|
[13]
|
Chris Pitzer (ed.)
|
Project: Telstar
|
AdHouse Books
|
Nominee
|
[13]
|
Diana Schutz (ed.)
|
AutobioGraphix
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Nominee
|
[13]
|
Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly (eds.)
|
Little Lit: It Was a Dark and Silly Night
|
HarperCollins
|
Nominee
|
[13]
|
2005
|
Diana Schutz and David Land (eds.)
|
Michael Chabon Presents The Amazing Adventures of the Escapist
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Winner
|
[14]
|
Scott Allie (ed.)
|
The Dark Horse Book of Witchcraft
|
Dark Horse Books
|
Nominee
|
[14]
|
Spencer Lamm (ed.)
|
The Matrix Comics, vol. 2
|
Burlyman Entertainment
|
Nominee
|
[14]
|
Jim McLauchlin (ed.), by Troy Hickman and others
|
Common Grounds
|
Top Cow Productions/Image Comics
|
Nominee
|
[14]
|
Chris Ware (ed.)
|
McSweeney's Quarterly #13
|
McSweeney's
|
Nominee
|
[14]
|
2006
|
Mark Chiarello (ed.)
|
Solo
|
DC Comics
|
Winner
|
[15]
|
Scott Allie (ed.)
|
The Dark Horse Book of the Dead
|
Dark Horse Books
|
Nominee
|
[15]
|
Nat Gertler (ed.)
|
24 Hour Comics Day Highlights 2005
|
About Comics
|
Nominee
|
[15]
|
Gary Groth and Eric Reynolds (eds.)
|
Mome
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[15]
|
Kazu Kibuishi (ed.)
|
Flight, vol. 2
|
Image Comics
|
Nominee
|
[15]
|
2007
|
Shelly Bond (ed.), by Troy Hickman and others
|
Fables: 1001 Nights of Snowfall
|
Vertigo Comics/DC Comics
|
Winner
|
[16]
|
Frédéric Boilet (ed.)
|
Japan as Viewed by 17 Creators
|
Fanfare/Ponent Mon
|
Nominee
|
[16]
|
Sammy Harkham (ed.)
|
Kramers Ergot #6
|
Buenaventura Press
|
Nominee
|
[16]
|
Glenn Head (ed.)
|
Hotwire Comix and Capers
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[16]
|
Chris Pitzer (ed.)
|
Project: Romantic
|
AdHouse Books
|
Nominee
|
[16]
|
2008
|
Gabriel Bá, Becky Cloonan, Fábio Moon, Vasilis Lolos, and Rafael Grampá
|
5
|
self-published
|
Winner
|
[17]
|
Ivan Brandon (ed.)
|
24Seven, vol. 2
|
Image Comics
|
Nominee
|
[17]
|
Gary Groth and Eric Reynolds (eds.)
|
Mome
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[17]
|
Anne Elizabeth Moore and Chris Ware (eds.)
|
The Best American Comics 2007
|
Houghton Mifflin
|
Nominee
|
[17]
|
Jason Rodriguez (ed.)
|
Postcards: True Stories That Never Happened
|
Villard
|
Nominee
|
[17]
|
2009
|
Rantz Hoseley (ed.)
|
Comic Book Tattoo: Narrative Art Inspired by the Lyrics and Music of Tori Amos
|
Image Comics
|
Winner
|
[18]
|
Scott Allie and Sierra Hahn (eds.)
|
MySpace Dark Horse Presents
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Nominee
|
[19]
|
Lynda Barry (ed.)
|
The Best American Comics 2008
|
Houghton Mifflin
|
Nominee
|
[19]
|
Ivan Brunetti (ed.)
|
An Anthology of Graphic Fiction, Cartoons, and True Stories, vol. 2
|
Yale University Press
|
Nominee
|
[19]
|
Sammy Harkham (ed.)
|
Kramers Ergot #7
|
Buenaventura Press
|
Nominee
|
[19]
|
2010s
|
2010
|
Mark Andrew Smith, D. J. Kirkbride, and Joe Keatinge (eds.)
|
Popgun, vol. 3
|
Image Comics
|
Winner
|
[20]
|
Paul Briggs (ed.)
|
What Is Torch Tiger?
|
Torch Tiger
|
Nominee
|
[21]
|
Brendan Burford (ed.)
|
Syncopated: An Anthology of Nonfiction Picto-Essays
|
Villard
|
Nominee
|
[21]
|
Kazu Kibuishi (ed.)
|
Flight, vol. 6
|
Villard
|
Nominee
|
[21]
|
Andrei Molotiu (ed.)
|
Abstract Comics
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[21]
|
Bob Weill (ed.)
|
Bob Dylan Revisited
|
W. W. Norton & Company
|
Nominee
|
[21]
|
2011
|
Paul Morrissey and David Petersen (eds.)
|
Mouse Guard: Legends of the Guard
|
Archaia Entertainment
|
Winner
|
[22]
|
Joy Ang and Nick Thornborrow (eds.)
|
The Anthology Project
|
Lucidity Press
|
Nominee
|
[23]
|
Matt Dembicki (ed.)
|
Trickster: Native American Tales
|
Fulcrum Books
|
Nominee
|
[23]
|
Nicolas Finet (ed.)
|
Korea as Viewed by 12 Creators
|
Fanfare/Ponent Mon
|
Nominee
|
[23]
|
Sonny Liew and Lim Cheng Tju (eds.)
|
Liquid City, vol. 2
|
Image Comics
|
Nominee
|
[23]
|
2012
|
Mike Richardson (ed.)
|
Dark Horse Presents
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Winner
|
[22]
|
Michel Choquette (ed.)
|
The Someday Funnies
|
Abrams ComicArts
|
Nominee
|
[24]
|
Rob Davis and Woodrow Phoenix (eds.)
|
Nelson
|
Blank Slate Books
|
Nominee
|
[24]
|
Chris Duffy (ed.)
|
Nursery Rhyme Comics
|
First Second Books
|
Nominee
|
[24]
|
Harvey Pekar and Paul Buhle (eds.)
|
Yiddishkeit: Jewish Vernacular and the New Land
|
Abrams ComicArts
|
Nominee
|
[24]
|
2013
|
Mike Richardson (ed.)
|
Dark Horse Presents
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Winner
|
[22]
|
Justin Hall (ed.)
|
No Straight Lines: Four Decades of Queer Comics
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[25]
|
Jeff Ranjo, Jed Diffenderfer, (eds.)
|
Where Is Dead Zero?
|
Dead Zero Publishing
|
Nominee
|
[25]
|
Matt Smith (ed.)
|
2000 AD
|
Rebellion Developments
|
Nominee
|
[25]
|
Alex Spiro and Sam Arthur (eds.)
|
Nobrow #7: Brave New World
|
Nobrow Press
|
Nominee
|
[25]
|
2014
|
Mike Richardson (ed.)
|
Dark Horse Presents
|
Dark Horse Comics
|
Winner
|
[22][26]
|
Sam Arthur and Alex Spiro (eds.)
|
Nobrow #8: Hysteria
|
Nobrow Press
|
Nominee
|
[26]
|
Gabe Fowler (ed.)
|
Smoke Signal
|
Desert Island
|
Nominee
|
[26]
|
Matthew Levine and Cameron Chittock (eds.), by Ben Acker, Ben Blacker, et al.
|
Thrilling Adventure Hour
|
Archaia Entertainment/Boom! Studios
|
Nominee
|
[26]
|
Michael Woods (ed.)
|
Outlaw Territory
|
Image Comics
|
Nominee
|
[26]
|
2015
|
Josh O'Neill, Andrew Carl, and Chris Stevens (eds.)
|
Little Nemo: Dream Another Dream
|
Locust Moon
|
Winner
|
[22][27]
|
Monte Beauchamp (ed.)
|
Masterful Marks: Cartoonists Who Changed the World
|
Simon & Schuster
|
Nominee
|
[27]
|
Jonathan Clode and John Stuart Clark (eds.)
|
To End All Wars: The Graphic Anthology of The First World War
|
Soaring Penguin
|
Nominee
|
[27]
|
Rachel Deering (ed.)
|
In the Dark: A Horror Anthology
|
Tiny Behemoth Press/IDW Publishing
|
Nominee
|
[27]
|
Anne Ishii, Chip Kidd, and Graham Kolbeins (eds.)
|
Massive: Gay Erotic Manga and the Men Who Make It
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[27]
|
2016
|
Tom Devlin (ed.)
|
Drawn & Quarterly, Twenty-Five Years of Contemporary, Cartooning Comics, and Graphic Novels
|
Drawn & Quarterly
|
Winner
|
[22][28]
|
Dan Berry (ed.)
|
24 x 7
|
Fanfare
|
Nominee
|
[28][29]
|
Matt Bors (ed.)
|
Eat More Comics: The Best of the Nib
|
The Nib
|
Nominee
|
[28][29]
|
David Petersen (ed.)
|
Mouse Guard: Legends of the Guard, vol. 3
|
Boom! Studios/Archaia Entertainment
|
Nominee
|
[28][29]
|
Shannon Watters (ed.)
|
Peanuts: A Tribute to Charles M. Schulz
|
Boom! Studios/KaBOOM!
|
Nominee
|
[28][29]
|
2017
|
Sarah Gaydos and Jamie S. Rich (eds.)
|
Love Is Love
|
IDW Publishing/DC Comics
|
Winner
|
[22][30]
|
Santiago Garcia (ed.)
|
Spanish Fever: Stories by the New Spanish Cartoonists
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
|
Brandon Graham and Emma Ríos (eds.)
|
Island Magazine
|
Image Comics
|
Nominee
|
|
Sammy Harkham (ed.)
|
Kramers Ergot #9
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
|
David Schilter and Sanita Muižniece (eds.)
|
Baltic Comics Anthology š! #26: dADa
|
kuš!
|
Nominee
|
|
2018
|
Taneka Stotts (ed.)
|
Elements: Fire, A Comic Anthology by Creators of Color
|
Beyond Press
|
Winner
|
[22]
|
Max B. Perlson, Trina Robbins, et al.
|
A Bunch of Jews (and Other Stuff): A Minyen Yidn
|
Bedside Press
|
Nominee
|
[31][32]
|
Sean Phillips (ed.)
|
The Spirit Anthology
|
Lakes International Comic Art Festival
|
Nominee
|
[31][32]
|
Eric Reynolds (ed.)
|
Now #1
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[31][32]
|
Jamie Rhodes, et al.
|
A Castle in England
|
Nobrow Press
|
Nominee
|
[31][32]
|
2019
|
Marco Lopez, Desiree Rodriguez, Hazel Newlevant, Derek Ruiz, and Neil Schwartz (eds.)
|
Puerto Rico Strong
|
Lion Forge Comics
|
Winner
|
[33]
|
Shelly Bond (ed.)
|
Femme Magnifique: 50 Magnificent Women Who Changed the World
|
Black Crown/IDW Publishing
|
Nominee
|
[34]
|
Alex de Campi (ed.)
|
Twisted Romance
|
Image Comics
|
Nominee
|
[34]
|
Will Dennis (ed.), curated by J. H. Williams III and Wendy Wright-Williams
|
Where We Live: A Benefit for the Survivors in Las Vegas
|
Image Comics
|
Nominee
|
[34]
|
2020s
|
2020
|
Diane Noomin (ed.)
|
Drawing Power: Women’s Stories of Sexual Violence, Harassment and Survival
|
Abrams ComicArts
|
Winner
|
[35][36][37]
|
Matt Bors (ed.)
|
The Nib #2–4
|
The Nib
|
Nominee
|
[35][38]
|
Sammy Harkham (ed.)
|
Kramers Ergot #10
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[35][38]
|
David Rault
|
ABC of Typography
|
SelfMadeHero
|
Nominee
|
[35][38]
|
David Schilter, Sanita Muižniece, et al. (eds.)
|
Baltic Comics Anthology š! #34-37
|
kuš!
|
Nominee
|
[35][38]
|
2021
|
MK Czerwiec (ed.)
|
Menopause: A Comic Treatment
|
Graphic Medicine/Pennsylvania State University Press
|
Winner
|
[39]
|
Shelly Bond (ed.)
|
Hey, Amateur! Go From Novice to Nailing It in 9 Panels
|
IDW Publishing/Black Crown
|
Nominee
|
[40]
|
Sammy Harkham (ed.)
|
Los Angeles Times
|
NTWRK
|
Nominee
|
[40]
|
Wren McDonald (ed.)
|
Ex Mag, vols. 1-2
|
Peow Studio
|
Nominee
|
[40]
|
Sarah Mirk (ed.)
|
Guantanamo Voices: True Accounts from the World’s Most Infamous Prison
|
Abrams ComicArts
|
Nominee
|
[40]
|
Eric Reynolds (ed.)
|
Now
|
Fantagraphics
|
Nominee
|
[40]
|
2023
|
Matt Bors (ed)
|
The Nib Magazine
|
Nib
|
Winner
|
[41]
|
Alex Antone and Jon Moisan (eds)
|
Creepshow
|
Image Skybound
|
Nominee
|
Josh Bernstein (ed)
|
The Illustrated Al: The Songs of “Weird Al” Yankovic
|
Z2
|
Bex Ollerton (ed)
|
Sensory: Life on the Spectrum
|
Andrews McMeel
|
Rantz Hoseley (ed)
|
Tori Amos: Little Earthquakes, The Graphic Album
|
Z2
|