This article needs additional citations for verification. (June 2018) |
Chinese water torture, or use of a dripping machine,[1] is a mentally painful process in which cold water is slowly dripped onto the scalp, forehead or face for a prolonged period of time.[1] The process causes fear and mental deterioration of the subject. The pattern of the drops is often irregular, and the cold sensation is jarring, which causes anxiety as a person tries to anticipate the next drip.[2]
Despite the name, it is not a Chinese invention and it is not traditional anywhere in Asia. Its earliest known version was first documented by Hippolytus de Marsiliis in Bologna (now in Italy) in the late 15th or early 16th century, and it was widely used in Western countries before being popularized by Harry Houdini in the early 20th century.[1][3][4]
Origin
edit"Chinese water torture" is mentioned in the 1884 short story "The Compromiser"[5] suggesting some public familiarity with the term by that date. It might have been popularised by the predicament escape Chinese Water Torture Cell (a feat of escapology introduced in Berlin at Circus Busch on September 13, 1910).[1] The escape entailed Harry Houdini being bound and suspended upside-down in a locked glass and steel cabinet full to overflowing with water, from which he escaped. There were also the Fu Manchu stories by Sax Rohmer that were popular in the 1930s (in which Fu Manchu subjected his victims to various ingenious tortures, such as the wired jacket).
Hippolytus de Marsiliis is credited with the invention of a form of water torture. Having observed how drops of water falling one by one on a stone gradually created a hollow, he applied the method to the human body. Other suggestions say that the term "Chinese water torture" was invented merely to grant the method a sense of ominous mystery. The victim would be stripped of their clothes, shown to the public, and then tortured. They would be driven insane while bystanders watched, mocked, and laughed at them.[1][3]
The victims could see each drop coming and, after a long duration of time, were gradually driven frantic to the point of insanity, usually because they were led to believe that a hollow or severe ulcer would develop there, or as a (sometimes combined) result of prolonged restraint under irritating conditions, isolation, or the humiliation of being tortured publicly. [citation needed]
Effectiveness
editThere is very little evidence pertaining to the effectiveness of torture for interrogation purposes. The method itself causes lasting mental damage in victims proportional to the intensity of exposure. The television series MythBusters investigated the effectiveness of Chinese water torture, and while it was found quite effective in producing distress, they noted that the restraining equipment was providing most of the effect by itself. When testing the dripping water alone on a relaxed, unrestrained subject, it was found almost negligible.[6] Nevertheless, in the Episode 3, Season 2 of the web television series Mind Field the MythBusters host Adam Savage said the following: "The creepiest thing that happened after we did this episode was that I got an e-mail from someone from a throwaway account. He said 'We found that randomizing when the drops occurred was incredibly effective.' That anything that happens on a regular periodicity can become a type of meditation and you can then tune it out. If you couldn’t predict it, [...] he said, 'we found we were able to induce a psychotic break within twenty hours.'."[7]
In addition to the victims experiencing mental deterioration, psychosis is a common side effect when undergoing the Chinese water torture. During the psychosis episode, victims experience delusions, hallucinations, and losing touch with reality. In 2012, Australian artist Lottie Consalvo performed the Chinese water torture for an art project, Steer a Steady Ship,[8] to represent her emotions after her sister's passing. Whilst lying under the drips of water, she felt the presence of her deceased sister lying beside her. In the article that explains Consalvo's experience during the performance,"Australian Artist Recreates Chinese Water Torture", the author states, "She came to the idea of Chinese water torture, which can cause psychosis, through its association with the head, which for her represents the physicality of the mind – something she believes is 'more physical than anything in life'."[9]
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ a b c d e Dripping Machine de Young, Mary (2015). Encyclopedia of Asylum Therapeutics, 1750-1950s. ISBN 9780786468973.
- ^ Samuel, Eugenie. "Water torture". New Scientist. Archived from the original on 2021-07-23. Retrieved 2021-04-08.
- ^ a b Paraskovich, Jack (2016). The Wrong View of History. ISBN 978-1-4771-2395-9.
- ^ Margaritoff, Marco; Anglis, Jaclyn (November 14, 2022). "The Disturbing History Of Chinese Water Torture — And How It Drove Victims Insane". All That's Interesting. Retrieved October 14, 2024.
- ^ The Overland Monthly, p. 82, at Google Books
- ^ Mythbusters, "Water Torture". Episode 25, Season 2. (2005)
- ^ Mind Field, "Interrogation - Mind Field S2 (Ep 3)" Archived 2023-01-02 at the Wayback Machine. Episode 3, Season 2. (2017)
- ^ "Lottie Consalvo 'steer a Steady Ship' video Piece Internet Size 1". YouTube. Archived from the original on 2023-02-23. Retrieved 2022-02-18.
- ^ "Australian artist recreates Chinese water torture". Archived from the original on 2022-02-18. Retrieved 2022-02-18.