Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi

'Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi
'Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi
عبد الرحمن الكواكبي
Born	1849, 1854 or 1855; Aleppo, Ottoman Empire
Died	1902 or 1903; Cairo, Egypt, British Africa
Era	19th-century philosophy
Region	Islamic Philosophy
School	Arab nationalism
Main interests	Islamic philosophy, anti-colonialism, Arab unity
Notable ideas	Separation of state and religion, Islamic constitutionalism, Arab independence

'Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi (Arabic: عبد الرحمن الكواكبي, romanized: ʿAbd al-Raḥmān al-Kawākibī‎, c. 1854-c.1902) was a Syrian author, a liberal thinker, and Pan-Arab solidarity supporter. He was one of the most prominent intellectuals of his time; however, his thoughts and writings continue to be relevant to the issues of Islamic identity and Pan-Arabism. His criticisms of the Ottoman Empire eventually led to Arabs calling for the sovereignty of the Arab Nations, setting the basis for Pan-Arab nationalism. Al-Kawakibi articulated his ideas in two influential books, The nature of tyranny and the struggle against slavery ( طبائع الإستبداد ومصارع الإستعباد) and Mother of All Villages (أم القرى). He died in 1902 of “mysterious” causes. His family alleged that he was poisoned by Turkish agents.

Early life

Al-Kawakibi was born in Aleppo to an influential Syrian family. He received a thorough education in the Islamic sciences and the languages of the region including Arabic, Turkish and Persian.^[1] As a young man, Al-Kawakibi was very interested in literature and politics, having edited Furat, the official paper of Aleppo from 1875 to 1880. at the age of twenty-two al-Kawakibi had been appointed as editor of Aleppo's official newspaper.^[2] He also edited the highly influential reformist journal, al-Manar, which was started by Rashid Rida, another influential Islamic scholar.

Career

After working at Furat and al-Manar, Al-Kawakibi started his own literary journal called the al-Sahba.^[3] The journal vehemently criticized the despots and dictators of his time, and alluded to the tyranny of the Ottoman Empire. He especially focused his criticism on the new Vali of Aleppo, Jamil Pasha. Due to Al-Kawakibi's political outspokenness, the journal was shut down by the local Ottoman Government after only 15 issues. After his work as editor, Al-Kawakibi entered politics more directly, and worked for various positions in the Ottoman civil service in Aleppo. Despite his opposition to the Ottoman Empire, Al-Kawakibi wanted to serve Arabs. During this point in his career, he became an honorary member of the board of lawyer examinations. Al-Kawakibi, along with other Aleppans, complained about the Vali to the central government in Istanbul. These criticisms fell on deaf ears until Istanbul sent a representative to Aleppo to investigate, and immediately threw Kawakibi and his followers into prison for false complaints. Once released from prison, Al-Kawakibi's popularity rose and he became the mayor of Aleppo in 1892. Later on Al-Kawakibi went to Istanbul to study the Ottoman Empire's despotism and problematic leadership more extensively. With his newfound knowledge, he returned to Aleppo and began working for the Ottoman government again. Because of his opinions, he was subject to harassment and intimidated on a regular basis. He decided to publish his book Umm al-Qura (The Mother of Cities:Mecca) in Egypt, rather than in Syria, and finally left his home country in 1899, moving to Egypt where he was welcomed by other Islamic intellectuals residing there.

Al-Kawakibi was influenced by the teachings of Jamal al-Din al-Afghani as well his disciple Muhammad Abduh.^[1] Al-Afghani preached Pan-Islamic identity – with this as his basis, Al-Kawakibi went one step further, incorporating Al-Afghani's theories into Pan-Islamic Arabic solidarity. Another contemporary of Al-Kawakibi was the Islamic scholar and advocate for Arab independence,^[1] Sayyid Rashid Rida who was based in Egypt at the same time. Rida and Al-Kawakibi discussed ideas of Pan-Arabism as well as Quranic interpretations. Al-Kawakibi believed that Arabs should be representatives of Islam, not the Ottomans. Rida believed that blind-following(taqlid) was the reason for downfall of Muslims. They both advocated the revival of independent Islamic thinking(ijtihad).

Ideas

Al-Kawakibi, in his earlier writings, was careful not to specifically criticize the Ottoman rulers, but rather critiqued despots and imperialists in general, though his implied target was clear. In one of his most influential books Tabai al-Istibdad wa-Masari al-Isti’bad (The Nature of Despotism), he said that tyranny violated Islamic teachings and that tyrants were responsible for Muslim nations' weakness and struggle. Al-Kawakibi believed that the demise of the Muslims in the Arab world was due to the oppressive rule of the Ottoman Empire. He was a vocal opponent of the Sultan of the Ottoman Empire and believed that the Sultan had no right to control the Arab people. Al-Kawakibi said "If I had an army at my command I would overthrow Abdulhamid’s (Sultan of the Ottoman Empire) government in 24 hours". He also invoked Muhammad's sayings in order to rally people behind his cause. He believed that the Arabs were united unlike other Muslims and that there was no racial or sectarian segregation among Arabs. He stated that Arabs were, "of all nations the most suitable to be an authority in religion and an example to the Muslims; the other nations have followed their guidance at the start and will not refuse to follow them now."

According to Line Khatib, a political scientist and Middle East expert, Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi’s contributions to liberal thought in the Arab world continue to resonate today.^[4] However, in Western academic discourse, Kawakibi is often framed primarily as an Arab nationalist and Islamic reformer.^[5] Yet, as Khatib observes, "his political vision and his work on autocratic governance and democratic rule are equally impressive." This distinction stems from his seminal work, *Taba’i‘ al-Istibdad wa Masari‘ al-Isti‘bad* (1902) [*The Characteristics of Despotism and the Destructions of Enslavement*], which addresses what Kawakibi viewed as the primary challenge facing the Arab region: despotism. The book stands as a liberal manifesto par excellence, delivering a scathing critique of Ottoman autocracy and repression while offering a systematic analysis and denunciation of despotism (*istibdad*). Kawakibi identified tyranny as a profound affliction, describing it as “unaccountable, unlimited, arbitrary, self-serving, and exclusive rule.” In the preface, he boldly asserts that the root cause of the region's backwardness is “political despotism,” and its remedy lies in “constitutional democracy.” Kawakibi viewed despotism as the origin of all societal maladies, or “the malady,” as he termed it.^[6] Political and social backwardness, he argued, are direct consequences of despotism, which fosters slavery (*isti‘bad*) and perpetuates ignorance. He elaborates on the vicious cycle created by this triad: despotism stifles knowledge and encourages ignorance—particularly in the social sciences and philosophy, disciplines that empower individuals to understand their rights and recognize freedom as essential to life. ^[7] Ignorance, in turn, reinforces subjugation and undermines the social fabric. Ultimately, Kawakibi saw despotism as the fountainhead of all corruption: “it corrupts the mind, religion, education, science, and morals. It is the source of injustice, humiliation, ignorance, poverty, unemployment, and ruin.”

According to Elizabeth F. Thompson, a historian of social movements and liberal constitutionalism in the Middle East at American University in Washington D.C., Al-Kawakibi's thoughts on Islamic democracy influenced an entire generation of Arab reformers. Al-Kawakibi published a newspaper in his hometown, Aleppo, that promoted equal rights for Armenians, Christians, and Jews. The truest expression of Islamic politics was democracy, Al-Kawakibi claimed, as long as it was based on the brotherhood and unity of Arabs regardless of religion and ethnicity.^[8]

Al-Kawakibi believed that there were a few reasons beyond the Ottoman's influence for the decline of Muslims at the time period. He believed that imitation (taqlid) caused the Muslims to be stagnant when it came to their religion and other forms of knowledge. Instead, of continuously trying to interpret the Quran and hadiths, Muslims relied on interpretations from centuries ago. Other reasons for the decline of Muslims were he believed, that Muslims abandoned Islamic values and relied on superstitions, and also that they disregarded science and, by extension, were not able to keep up with modern society. However, Al-Kawakibi noted that the tyrannical nature of regimes was the root cause of the struggle of Arabs. The Ottomans prohibiting Arabs from education and imposing foreign rules, established in Istanbul, on Arabs under the control of the Ottoman Empire only elevated the position of the Turks and kept the other Muslims, especially Arabs in the dark. He believed that religion was used as an excuse by the Ottomans to unfairly rule over Arabs and other Muslims without understanding the cultural and local customs.

Al-Kawakibi additionally believed that Mecca should be the capital of the Islamic world, not Istanbul. He was a proponent of historical Arab exceptionalism as the founding location of Islam. He believed that the rightful Caliph should come from the Quraysh tribe as Muhammad did.^[9] His book Umm Al Qura (The Mother of Villages) reflects these ideas. His book contained a fictional story of an Islamic conference taking place in Mecca, thus illustrating the importance of Mecca to the Islamic world.

Criticism

Al-Kawakibi's ideas were controversial to some. His critics alleged that he was a proponent of socialism. According to author Charles Tripp, the idea of “Islamic socialism” was advocated by Al-Kawakibi.^{[citation needed]} Islamic socialism is the belief that the Quran permits redistribution of wealth, although that point is disputed by many Muslim scholars.^[10]

Legacy

Although Al-Kawakibi did not have a tremendous amount of support during his lifetime, his ideas influenced entire future generations of Arab reformers and leaders, such as Faisal I, the king of the Arab Kingdom of Syria or Greater Syria in 1920 and King of Iraq from 23 August 1921 until his death. Additionally, Al-Kawakibi's message and legacy passed onto Pan-Arab nationalists such as Gamal Abdel Nasser, even though Al-Kawakibi was not a Pan-Arab nationalist but instead believed in Arab unity and solidarity.

According to the contemporary Lebanese historian, social commentator, and writer, Jean Dayeh, Al-Kawakibi was a Muslim political pioneer due to his ideas championing the separation of state and religion.^[11]

The Kawaakibi Foundation is named after him.^[12] Kawakibi's great-grandson, Salam Kawakibi, is a Paris-based intellectual and the director of the Arab Centre for Research and Policy Studies, who has co-published a collection of Kawakibi's essays "On Despotism" in French.^[13]^[14] For their virulent attacks on 'Abdul Hamid II and the autocratic rule of the Ottomans, ‘Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi, alongside the Syrian Islamic reformer Sayyid Rashid Rida (d. 1935), remain influential cultural icons in pan-Arab circles.^[15]

Death

Al-Kawakibi died in 1902 and many of his family and supporters alleged that he had been poisoned by Turkish agents. This has never been proven.^[3] Following Al-Kawakibi's death, the Ottomans were able to confiscate and destroy all but two books, The Nature of Tyranny and Umm Al-Qura, written by Al-Kawakibi.^[16]

References

^ ^a ^b ^c Kurzman, Charles (1 January 2002). Modernist Islam, 1840-1940: A Sourcebook. Oxford University Press. p. 152. ISBN 9780195154689.
^ Mohammed A. Bamyeh, Intellectuals and Civil Society in the Middle east. Bloomsbury Publishing, 2012. “Born in Aleppo in 1855 to a noble family of Kurdish origin, the historic 'Abd al-Rahman al- Kawakibi graduated from a traditional school and by the age of twenty-two had been appointed editor of Aleppo's official newspaper.”[1]
^ ^a ^b "Profile: Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi". www.aljazeera.com. Retrieved 4 June 2016.
^ Khatib, Line (1 January 2023). Quest for Democracy: Liberalism in the Modern Arab World. Cambridge University Press.
^ Khatib, Line (1 January 2023). Quest for Democracy: Liberalism in the Modern Arab World. Cambridge University Press.
^ Khatib, Line (1 January 2023). Quest for Democracy: Liberalism in the Modern Arab World. Cambridge University Press.
^ Khatib, Line (1 January 2023). Quest for Democracy: Liberalism in the Modern Arab World. Cambridge University Press.
^ Thompson, Elizabeth (1 January 2021). How the West Stole Democracy from the Arabs: The Syrian Congress of 1920 and the Destruction of Its Liberal-Islamic Alliance, 1840-1940: A Sourcebook. Grove Atlantic.
^ Kay, Shari (2020). Arabia infelix: Britain Sharif Hussein and the lost opportunities of Anglo-Arab relations, 1916-1924 (Thesis). hdl:20.500.11929/sdsu:57703. OCLC 1228848499. ProQuest 2451400709. Al-Afghani's pan-Islamic solidarity was expanded upon by the Aleppo-born Syrian writer Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi (1854/55 – 1902). Like his contemporaries, he was wary of the western influences upon Islam, yet desired a refreshed approach to the solidarity of the 'umma (community). That included a return to a Quraysh/Arab caliphate.
^ Raz, Ronen (1996). "Interpretations of Kawakibi's Thought, 1950-1980s". Middle Eastern Studies. 32 (1): 179–190. doi:10.1080/00263209608701097. JSTOR 4283781. A third topic which was addressed in the literature about Kawakibi was socialism, in particular since the early 1960s when Arab socialism became a state-sponsored ideology in Egypt, Syria and Iraq. The social critique of Kawakibi and his calls for social justice were interpreted by most writers as being socialist in nature with Abd al-Rahman Burj avoiding anachronism and noting that what Kawakibi had in mind was 'what we call today socialism'. Muhammad Sa'd al-'Uryan went further in his analysis to explain the differences between Arab socialism, presumably pioneered by Kawakibi, and Communism. This explanation, a common practice among Arab intellectuals at the time, focused on the attitude to religion as a core differentiating element of the two ideologies.
^ Ryuichi Funatsu (2006). "Al-Kawākibī's Thesis and its Echoes in the Arab World Today" (PDF). Harvard University. Retrieved 14 April 2023.
^ "Kawaakibi Foundation". Kawaakibi Foundation. Retrieved 14 April 2023.
^ de Courtois, Sébastien (31 December 2017). "Mémoire(s) d'Alep, avec Salam Kawakibi". France Culture (in French). Archived from the original on 13 April 2019. Retrieved 17 April 2021.
^ "Du despotisme : et autres textes de Abd al-Rahman Kawakibi : livre à découvrir sur France Culture". France Culture (in French). Archived from the original on 17 April 2021. Retrieved 17 April 2021.
^ Al-Rasheed, Kersten, Shterin, Madawi, Carol, Marat; Skovgaard-Petersen, Jakob (2015). "7: The Caliphate in Contemporary Arab TV Culture". Demystifying the Caliphate: Historical Memory and Contemporary Contexts. New York: Oxford University Press. p. 158. ISBN 978-0-19-932795-9.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
^ "The Nature of Tyranny | Hurst Publishers".

External links

Works by Abd al-Rahman al-Kawakibi at LibriVox (public domain audiobooks)