Wikipedia:Boxification
 | This is an essay. It contains the advice or opinions of one or more Wikipedia contributors. This page is not an encyclopedia article, nor is it one of Wikipedia's policies or guidelines, as it has not been thoroughly vetted by the community. Some essays represent widespread norms; others only represent minority viewpoints. |
Boxification is the repeated use of box-style tables in Wikipedia. In many cases, there have been few restrictions on the use of added boxes into various sections of articles. As a result, many boxes repeat the information found in the article's text, or repeated from other articles, but as the "boxified" form of the same data. As the box-style tables have expanded, to aggregate even more data, they have become "boxoboxes" whose primary feature is to present an immense mass of data in a boxified format.
Within their rigid structures, typically formatted within separate templates, the boxes tend to demand their own attention and resist attempts to simplify, or limit, the rambling extent of the details, as long as data is protected within the box walls. Because of that power, to resist limits on additional detail, the box structures often lead to "creeping boxism" such as gigantic boxes, with many boxes inside other boxes of boxes. Also, there have been numerous stacks of boxes, such as maintenance-tag boxes, or trains of bottom navboxes in articles.
Standards to limit boxification
editVarious studies have shown that boxes of information should be limited, in length or scope, to avoid overwhelming the viewers with an excessive volume of information. For instance, in preparing histograms, the total number of bars is recommended to remain within 20 bars.
Considerations of boxspeak
editWhen the structure of an article becomes cluttered with numerous boxes, then the reader is steered into an environment of "boxspeak" where communication of information is primarily structured into a boxified presentation, of rigid box formats, rather than as free-form text which wraps down the page, with different text-sizes depending on each reader's browser settings. Due to the rigid box format, further explanation of the data is hindered, or thwarted, especially in cases of unusual data items which would typically have extra details explained when in a textual format.