Wikipedia

Wikipedia:AMA Requests for Assistance/Requests/October 2006/Excellentone

< Wikipedia:AMA Requests for Assistance | Requests

Wikipedian filing request:

Other Wikipedians this pertains to:

Wikipedia pages this pertains to:

Questions:

edit

Have you read the AMA FAQ?

  • Answer:Yes

How would you describe the nature of this dispute? (policy violation, content dispute, personal attack, other)

  • Answer: policy violation

What methods of Dispute Resolution have you tried so far? If you can, please provide wikilinks so that the Advocate looking over this case can see what you have done.

  • Answer: Introduced NPOV on article (see nkt talk page)

What do you expect to get from Advocacy?

  • Answer: Advice about how to procede

Summary:

edit

The NKT article seems to me to give undue weight to the views of one author, David Kay, who is cited to such an extent that the article could perhaps be more properley described as 'what David Kay thinks about the NKT'. There are two sections which have been nominated for merging with other articles (but no discussion of this on the talk page), and the piece as a whole seems utterly lacking in coherence and full of missing citations and opinion presented as fact. The article has been heavily edited by kt66 who appears to have an agenda that runs contrary to the aims of WP. The discussion of this article is interminable...would it be better to delete it altogether?

Discussion:

edit

Followup:

edit

When the case is finished, please take a minute to fill out the following survey:

Did you find the Advocacy process useful?

  • Answer:

Did your Advocate handle your case in an appropriate manner?

  • Answer:

On a scale of 1 (worst) to 5 (best), how polite was your Advocate?

  • Answer:

On a scale of 1 to 5, how effective do you feel your Advocate was in solving the problem?

  • Answer:

On a scale of 1 to 5, how effective do you feel the Advocacy process is altogether?

  • Answer:

If there were one thing that you would like to see different in the Advocacy process, what would it be?

  • Answer:

If you were to deal with this dispute again, what would you do differently, if anything?

  • Answer:


AMA Information

edit

Case Status: open


Advocate Status:

Retrieved from "https://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:AMA_Requests_for_Assistance/Requests/October_2006/Excellentone&oldid=1137460388"