Wikipedia neutral point of view disputes
Subtotals
January 20122
February 20122
April 20121
June 20123
July 20125
August 20128
September 20127
October 20128
December 201240
January 201333
February 201335
March 201331
April 201331
May 201325
June 201333
July 201325
August 201320
September 201329
October 201333
November 201323
December 201344
January 201447
February 201431
March 201429
April 201432
May 201439
June 201428
July 201426
August 201420
September 201439
October 201436
November 201435
December 201424
January 201539
February 201536
March 201535
April 201539
May 201535
June 201549
July 201530
August 201548
September 201535
October 201537
November 201548
December 201545
January 201639
February 201639
March 201634
April 201641
May 201638
June 201639
July 201633
August 201629
September 201637
October 201631
November 201640
December 201639
January 201742
February 201751
March 201744
April 201750
May 201736
June 201738
July 201742
August 201737
September 201727
October 201730
November 201723
December 201735
January 201853
February 201830
March 201839
April 201837
May 201847
June 201840
July 201842
August 201845
September 201857
October 201865
November 201833
December 201846
January 201957
February 201934
March 201943
April 201933
May 201933
June 201938
July 2019109
August 201951
September 201933
October 201938
November 201940
December 201950
January 202046
February 202050
March 202037
April 202062
May 202045
June 202055
July 202048
August 202054
September 202058
October 202066
November 202061
December 202064
January 202161
February 202141
March 202167
April 202160
May 202172
June 202167
July 202184
August 202169
September 202178
October 202160
November 202163
December 202172
January 202271
February 202260
March 202249
April 202259
May 202261
June 202267
July 202258
August 202248
September 202263
October 202259
November 202253
December 202263
January 202364
February 202341
March 202375
April 202377
May 202362
June 202399
July 202395
August 202385
September 202369
October 202381
November 202387
December 202375
January 202497
February 202477
March 202497
April 202487
May 2024126
June 202499
July 2024114
August 2024103
September 2024115
October 2024135
November 202494
Undated articles0

My areas of interest and expertise range from theoretical mathematics to linguistics to emergency medicine. I am an American. Many of my edits are made when I come here to review a subject and notice mistakes. I also watch articles on a variety of subjects that happen to interest me or that I have edited in the past. Professional obligations have limited my time for Wikipedia in recent years, but I still pop in from time to time.

On your right you can find some userboxes with basic information relevant to my wikipedia activities. If you want to know more about me, I invite you to look at my edit history and form your opinions from that

Inclusionism in the age of AI Over my many years of involvement on Wikipedia, I've generally taken the view that retaining content is better than removing it, even if it is poorly sourced, because Wikipedia is a long term project, and content that can be improved should be given the chance to improve. However, this philosophy needs to be tempered somewhat now that the internet is full of AI-generated content. Wikipedia is a primary source of training data and input for AI tools, and as a result false information on Wikipedia will rapidly be incorporated into AI's knowledge base, mingled with more reliable information, and then repeated as true. This accelerates and exacerbates the process of Citogenesis, where unsourced and incorrect information originating on Wikipedia is repeated in other venues and eventually makes its way into the sources wiki editors use, thus locking false information in place in a circular citation loop that can be very hard to get rid of. In light of this, I encourage wiki editors to be more aggressive in removing dubious and unsourced content. As an alternative to total loss of content in cases where improvement may be possible, I recommend moving content to talk or user space while it is being worked on.

POV Processing One of my major contributions to the wiki has been going through backlogged POV dispute tags. The vast majority of these tags were either inappropriately added or the dispute in question ended a long time ago. Unfortunately, new tags are currently being added at a higher rate than old tags are removed. If you want to help, there's a box at the top right of this user page with the backlog sorted by date. Some general guidelines:

  • If talk contains no POV discussions, remove the tag.
  • If talk page contains POV discussions, but they seem to have been resolved by consensus, remove the tag.
  • If talk page contains unresolved POV discussions, but the discussions have not been updated for several years, remove the tag. If the article still has glaringly obvious problems, consider adding some other suitable tag.
  • When in doubt, cut the tag! In the event that someone actually still disputes the article, they will simply replace it.

See this page for more guidance on tag removal.

If you feel that one of my tag removals was inappropriate, feel free to replace the tag. If you do, please also contribute to the article talk page explaining what still needs to be done before the tag may be removed. Otherwise expect a talk page message from me requesting clarification.

This task is not glamorous, but if the trend is not reversed the backlog will continue to grow indefinitely.

Update: every article that was tagged as a POV dispute when I began this endeavor 13 years ago has been addressed! Unfortunately, backlog has grown since then from 4 years to 12 years. The trend is not entirely bad, however - the amount of new unresolved disputes per month has fallen from 200-300 to 120 on average. If the backlog can be completely cleared, addressing new disputes will be a manageable task for a team of 2-3 moderately active editors.

Please help!

Happy editing!