Traditional Spelling Revised

Traditional Spelling Revised (TSR) is an English-language spelling reform created by Stephen Linstead which aims to apply the underlying rules of conventional English orthography more consistently, thereby reducing the number of irregularities which make English spelling defective. Stephen Linstead describes it as "conservative but progressive", based on the principle that minimal changes are more likely to be adopted by the general public.[1]

In March 2021, it was approved by the International English Spelling Congress (IESC) as the preferred alternative to English orthography.[2][3] The English Spelling Society, sponsor of the Congress, is affording TSR a degree of support and publicity. During the current review period of five years, no major changes will likely happen. However, on the basis of comments received, it is possible there may be some modest modifications during that period.[4]

TSR has been mentioned in the media.[5][6]

Changes

edit

TSR is broadly spelt the same as traditional English orthography, but some rules and spellings are applied more consistently.[7]

'Magic e' rule

edit

Where a single consonant separates a vowel and a silent word final e, the first vowel is 'lengthened'. Unlike the doubling rule, the consonant is not doubled when 'lengthening' is undesired. Instead, the 'magic e' is dropped (unless it indicates soft or hard ⟨c⟩ or ⟨g⟩, then the consonant is doubled).

  • e.g. ⟨win⟩ / ⟨wine⟩, ⟨sad⟩ / ⟨sadist⟩, ⟨bit⟩ / ⟨biter⟩, ⟨fun⟩ / ⟨fuming⟩

The graphemes ⟨ar⟩ and ⟨or⟩ do not straightforwardly take on the "lengthened" forms. Instead ⟨-are⟩ represents /ɛər/ and ⟨-ore⟩ is unchanged.

Doubling rule

edit

The doubling rule dictates that when a stressed vowel is followed by a single consonant and another vowel (which isn't 'magic e'), the stressed vowel is 'lengthened'. This can be negated by doubling the consonant between the two vowels, thus keeping the vowel short. Therefore letters are dropped or doubled from traditional spelling.

  • e.g. ⟨swim⟩ → ⟨swimming⟩ but ⟨fail⟩ → ⟨failed⟩
  • e.g. ⟨accommodate⟩ → ⟨acommodate⟩, ⟨committee⟩ → ⟨comittee⟩
  • e.g. ⟨deddicate⟩, ⟨edducate⟩, ⟨perrish⟩

Doubled ⟨g⟩ before ⟨e⟩ may be spelt ⟨dg⟩ or ⟨gg⟩ to indicate whether it is soft or not.

  • e.g. ⟨flange⟩ → ⟨flandge⟩, ⟨hanger⟩ → ⟨hangger⟩

There is an exception for the letter ⟨i⟩, which does not lengthen itself unless it is part of the ⟨-ing⟩ suffix.

  • e.g. ⟨lipid⟩, ⟨limit⟩ but ⟨wining⟩, ⟨winning⟩

Disambiguation of graphemes

edit

Where graphemes ambiguously represent more than one sound, they are rewritten to be less ambiguous.

  • e.g. ⟨ow⟩ represents completely different sounds in the words ⟨low⟩ and ⟨town⟩, so TSR uses ⟨ow⟩ for // and rewrites the other spellings thus: ⟨low⟩ → ⟨lo⟩, ⟨own⟩ → ⟨oan⟩.

Silent letters

edit

Where letters are rendundant to pronunciation, they are removed. This includes uses of word-final e that suggest "lengthening" when there is none (unless it suggests soft c as in ⟨office⟩). The homographs that this creates are distinguished using apostrophes, hyphens or dierisis.

  • e.g. ⟨wrong⟩ → ⟨rong⟩, ⟨gnash⟩ → ⟨nash⟩
  • e.g. ⟨love⟩ → ⟨luv⟩, ⟨dove⟩ → ⟨duv⟩, ⟨live⟩ → ⟨liv⟩
  • e.g. ⟨hour⟩ → ⟨'our⟩, ⟨write⟩ → ⟨'rite⟩, ⟨know⟩ → ⟨'no⟩, ⟨create⟩ → ⟨cre-ate⟩ / ⟨creäte⟩
  • e.g. ⟨though⟩ → ⟨tho⟩, ⟨through⟩ → ⟨throo⟩

Importantly, the following spellings are not redundant to pronunciation.

  • ⟨easy⟩ not ⟨esy⟩, ⟨high⟩ not ⟨hi⟩, ⟨letter⟩ not ⟨letr⟩, ⟨lie⟩ not ⟨li⟩, ⟨pack⟩ not ⟨pak⟩, ⟨switch⟩ not ⟨swich⟩
  • Silent ⟨g⟩ is retained to preserve the long vowel: ⟨benign⟩, ⟨design⟩, ⟨sign⟩
  • Silent ⟨gh⟩: ⟨high⟩, ⟨bough⟩, ⟨bought⟩, ⟨eight⟩
  • Change ⟨gh⟩ /f/ to ⟨ff⟩: ⟨coff⟩, ⟨enuff⟩, ⟨laff⟩
  • Retain ⟨ph⟩ /f/: ⟨phone⟩

Homophones

edit

There are cases in which spellings of homophones will not merge (and therefore not be disambiguated using an apostrophe). Some phonemes have several different permitted spellings, which helps to distinguish homophones visually.

  • e.g. ⟨main⟩ / ⟨mane⟩, ⟨buy⟩ / ⟨by⟩ / ⟨bye⟩, ⟨stare⟩ / ⟨stair⟩, ⟨sight⟩ / ⟨site⟩ / ⟨cite⟩, ⟨none⟩ / ⟨nun⟩, ⟨scene⟩ / ⟨seen⟩, ⟨tail⟩ / ⟨tale⟩

Some words are respelt where an alternate spelling can be used instead of an apostrophe. However, neither ⟨or⟩ / ⟨ore⟩ / ⟨oar⟩ nor ⟨pore⟩ / ⟨pour⟩ are differentiated.

  • e.g. ⟨bear⟩ → ⟨bair⟩ (to distinguish from ⟨bare⟩), ⟨great⟩ → ⟨grait⟩ (to distinguish from ⟨grate⟩).

New graphemes

edit

Two new letter combinations have been introduced to unambiguously represent /ɑː/ ⟨aa⟩ and /ʊ/ ⟨uu⟩. Though not made explicit, ⟨faather⟩ is likely spelt with a double ⟨a⟩ as both RP and GenAm pronounce it with /ɑ(ː)/, in comparison to ⟨rather⟩, which is pronounced differently by those dialets.

Exceptions

edit

The spellings of some common words that do not otherwise comply with the rules of TSR are preserved so as not to drastically change the look of text.[7] These excpetions, called "sign words" in the documentation, are given in groups, though not all the words in these groups are changed.

  • personal pronouns and adjectives: I, you, he, she, we, me, us, they, your, their(s), them
  • variations of verbs to be and to have: are, was, were, have, having
  • names of numbers: none, once, one, two, four, seven, eleven, twelve, fourteen, seventeen
  • days of the week: Monday, Wednesday, Saturday
  • months and seasons of the year: January, February, April, July, Autumn
  • demonstrative adjectives, pronouns and adverbs including ⟨th⟩: than, that, then, thence, there, these, this, those, thus
  • interrogative pronouns beginning ⟨w⟩: what, where, who, whose
  • other common words with unusual spellings: the, of, to(day), any(one), (e)very, eye, nothing, some, super, very, with, woman, women, yes, either

Some common suffixes are retained.

  • involving /ʃ/: -cean (ocean), -cial (special), -cian (musician), -cient (prescient), -cience (conscience), -cion (suspicion), -cious (spacious), -ssion (passion), -tial (partial), -tient (patient), -tion (nation), -sure, -ed
  • involving /ʒ/: -sion (invasion), -sure (pleasure), -sual (casual)

Some common letter sequences, called "sub-groups" are retained even when irregular.

  • ⟨-ald⟩ (bald), ⟨-alk⟩ (talk, walk), ⟨-alt⟩ (falter, halt), ⟨ange⟩ (danger, angel), ⟨-aste⟩ (taste, waste), ⟨-ign⟩ (benign, sign), ⟨-ind⟩ (find, mind), ⟨old⟩ (old, gold), ⟨-olk⟩ (folk, yolk), ⟨-ore⟩ (therefore, shore), ⟨-other⟩ (brother, mother), ⟨-ould⟩ (could, would), ⟨war-⟩ (warm, warn), ⟨wor-⟩ (worm, worst).

Proper nouns are kept the same, unless alternative spellings become accepted. Loan words are indicated in italics.

Sound-to-spelling correspondences

edit

Each phoneme has its own spelling patterns.[7]

Vowels

edit
Phoneme Lexical set Grapheme Examples[8] Notes
/æ/ TRAP a pan, laff[a]
(au) aunt c.f. ⟨ant⟩
/ɛ/ DRESS e pen, frend[b]
(a) many By assocaition with ⟨any⟩
(ai) again No note in word list
/ɪ/ KIT i pin, bisness[c], pritty[d], sistem[e]
(o, e) women
/ɒ/ LOT o pot, wosh[f]
/ʌ/ STRUT u pun, cum[g]
-other another, brother
(o-e) none, nothing, some
/eɪ/ FACE a-e face
ai laid, braik[h], gaige[i], baiss[j]
ei vein
eigh neigh
-ay stay
-ey they, survey
/iː/ FLEECE e-e scene
ee feed
ea lead "ea" /iː/ doesn't indicate /eɪ/ or /ɛ/: steak → staik, weapon → weppon.
(e) me, he, she, we Usually /∅/, though /iː/ in monosyllables
(ei) either Can also be pronounced with /aɪ/
/aɪ/ PRICE i-e side
ie die, iedeäl[k]
-y why
-ye dye
-uy buy
-igh sigh
(aye) aye Would be /eɪ/ otherwise. Official respelling unknown.
(eye) eye Would be /iː/ otherwise. ⟨y⟩ and ⟨ie⟩ were suggested then rejected
(ei) either Can also be pronounced with /iː/
/oʊ/ GOAT o-e bone
oa moan
-o banjo Many ⟨-ow⟩ forms are changed to ⟨-o⟩: ⟨low⟩ → ⟨lo⟩, ⟨show⟩ → ⟨sho⟩
-oe floe
/juː/ DUE u-e tune
ue due, buetiful[l]
u- unit
ew few
eu Europe For words of Greek origin only
/ʊ/ FOOT uu stuud[m], puuding[n]
(oul) could, should, would Usually /aʊ/
(o) woman Usually /ɒ/
/ɔɪ/ CHOICE oi boil
oy boy, deploying
/uː/ GOOSE oo food, throo[o]
(u-e) super Usually /juː/
/aʊ/ MOUTH ou proud
ow now, gown
ough bough
/ɛər/ SQUARE air stair, bair[p]
-are bare
eir their
(ere) there, where Usually /ɪər/
/ɑːr/ START ar star Double the ⟨r⟩ to change the vowel: ⟨harry⟩. "Harry" and "starry" don't rime.
/ɑː/ PALM a bath Undisambiguated from /æ/
al palm
aa faather[q], tomaato[r], vaaz[s], draama[t] Used for British-American differences in pronunciation and ⟨faather⟩
/ɔːr/ NORTH or or, for, bord[u] Double the ⟨r⟩ to change the vowel: ⟨horrid⟩
(ore) ore Kept for contrast in a few words, but mostly respelled ⟨or⟩
(oar) oar
(our) four Usually /aʊ.ə/
/ɔː/ THOUGHT au fraud
aw law, lawyer
all call
al- and implying totality always cf. algebra
augh daughter
ough(t) bought
/ɜːr/ NURSE er her Double the ⟨r⟩ to change the vowel: ⟨herring⟩, ⟨stirrup⟩, ⟨hurry⟩.
ir fir
ur fur
(or) word, work, worship Usually /ɔː/
/ɪər/ NEAR -eer beer
-ear hear
-ere here
/i/ happY -y fairy
-ie(s) faries ⟨-y⟩ becomes ⟨-ies⟩ for plurals.
/ə/, /ɪ/ commA a, e, i, o, u afraid, defence, invisible, wonnton[v], opus Schwa. The indeterminate sound in many unaccented syllables. TSR usually retains the graphemes used in TS for these phonemes.
  1. ^ "laugh" in conventional spelling
  2. ^ "friend" in conventional spelling
  3. ^ "business" in conventional spelling
  4. ^ "pretty" in conventional spelling
  5. ^ "system" in conventional spelling
  6. ^ "wash" in conventional spelling
  7. ^ "come" in conventional spelling
  8. ^ "break" in conventional spelling
  9. ^ "gauge" in conventional spelling
  10. ^ "bass" in conventional spelling
  11. ^ "ideal" in conventional spelling
  12. ^ "beautiful" in conventional spelling
  13. ^ "stood" in conventional spelling
  14. ^ "pudding" in conventional spelling
  15. ^ "through" in conventional spelling
  16. ^ "bear" in conventional spelling
  17. ^ "father" in conventional spelling
  18. ^ "tomato" in conventional spelling
  19. ^ "vase" in conventional spelling
  20. ^ "drama" in conventional spelling
  21. ^ "board" in conventional spelling
  22. ^ "wanton" in conventional spelling

Consonants

edit

The following table lists the consonants that don't always represent the same phoneme, so /b/, /d/, /h/, /l/, /m/, /n/, /p/, /r/, /t/ and /v/ are ommitted.

Phoneme Grapheme Examples Notes
/dʒ/ j jam
g gin Before /ɛ/, /ɪ/, /iː/, /aɪ/
dg marrige[a] Doubled before /ɛ/, /ɪ/, /iː/, /aɪ/
/f/ f frog
ph phone In words of Greek origin only
/g/ g gun Except before /e/, /ɪ/, /iː/, /aɪ/ with no u (c.f. guide)
/j/ y yet
i bastion
/k/ k kid
c cream Except before /e/, /ɪ/, /iː/, /aɪ/
ck flick, socker[b] Word-finally or doubled
ch chemistry In words of Greek origin only
/ks/ x exterminate Treated as doubled (e.g. boxing)
/kw/ qu queen
/s/ s sun Word-initially, before or after /k/, /f/, /p/, /t/, as part of or after the prefixes ⟨dis-⟩, ⟨mis-⟩, ⟨con-⟩ and ⟨per-⟩ or beginning one part of a compound word (homesick)
ss hiss
c city Before /ɛ/, /ɪ/, /iː/, /aɪ/
/ʃ/ sh shed
c socially Before ⟨ia⟩ in some dialects
/tʃ/ ch church
-tch switch
/θ/ th thing
(o)th(er) bother Exception to ⟨-other⟩ subgroup
/ð/ th bathe In single syllable words before /ɛ/
(o)th(er) other In ⟨-other⟩ subgroup
/ʒ/ sure plesure[c] As part of a common suffix
si lesion
  1. ^ "marriage" in conventional spelling
  2. ^ "soccer" in conventional spelling
  3. ^ "pleasure" in conventional spelling

Inconsistencies

edit

"Ch" with /k/ sound

edit

Words of Greek origin are supposed to retain "ch" for /k/,[7] though these words are respelled in the word list:[8]

  • architect → arcitect
  • technique → tecnique
  • technological → tecnolodgical

Example text

edit

Gettysburg Address[7]

Fourscor and seven years ago our faathers brought forth, on this continent, a new nation, conceeved in libberty and deddicated to the proposition that all men are creäted equal. Now we are engaged in a grait civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so conceeved, and so deddicated, can long endure. We are met on a grait battle-feeld in that war. We have cum to deddicate a portion of that feeld, as a final resting place for those who here gave their lives, that that nation might liv. It is altogether fitting and propper that we should do this, but in a larger senss we cannot deddicate, we cannot consecrate, we cannot hallo this ground. The brave men, livving and ded, who struggled here, have consecrated it far abuv our poor power to add or detract. The world will little note, nor long remember, what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here. It is for us the livving, rather, to be deddicated to the grait task remaining befor us that from these onored ded we take increassed devotion to that cause for which they gave the last fuul mesure of devotion - that we here highly resolv that these ded shall not have died in vain, that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom, and that guvvernment of the peeple, by the peeple, for the peeple, shall not perrish from the erth.

Notes and references

edit
  1. ^ Stephen Linstead (2021-01-31). IESC_Second_Session_Final_Meeting. Retrieved 2024-09-28 – via YouTube.
  2. ^ "Press Release: Revised Spelling System Approved". The English Spelling Society. 2021-04-12.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  3. ^ "Report of Voting" (PDF). The English Spelling Society.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  4. ^ "International English Spelling Congress | the English Spelling Society".
  5. ^ "Should English spelling be reformed to make it easier to learn?". The Times. Times Newspapers. Retrieved 18 April 2021.
  6. ^ "Heard, word, bird: should the spelling of some words change?". RTÉ. RTÉ. Retrieved 27 October 2023.
  7. ^ a b c d e Linstead, Stephen. "TSR Complete Guidance" (PDF). The English Spelling Society. Retrieved 2023-10-27.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  8. ^ a b Linstead, Stephen. "3-4000 most common words transcribed into TSR (by frequency)" (PDF). Retrieved 2023-10-27.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)

See also

edit
edit