Talk:Westlife/GA3

Latest comment: 16 years ago by Realist2 in topic On review (Failed)

On review (Failed)

edit
  • They described each of them with different vocal range and styles, Byrne (husky voice), Egan (rock), Feehily (R&B), Filan (pop), McFadden (pop, R&B). - remove
  • This variations in voices are considered by the band as one of their edge among other musical groups around. - remove
  • "Double-figures in shortest time" - what does that even mean
  • "[4][5][6][7][8][9][10] - ugly, the lead shouldnt be sourced, instead it should be sourced in tontent of article.
  • Source 11 is no good, you need a much better source for such a claim.
  • Way to much wikilinking of the same words, some things dont need wikilinking at all.
  • Current sources 13,22,33,35 not formatted correctly.
  • Current sources 1,6,10,11,12,44,47,58,59,60,62,64 need replacing they are not reliable.
  • Over linking to GMTV - find some other sources

GA fails again, its been 6 days and not even these small requests have been completed, even with these done it would have still needed a lot of work. Realist2 ('Come Speak To Me') 15:07, 5 May 2008 (UTC)Reply