Talk:Thomas Rotherham College

Latest comment: 4 years ago by Acabashi in topic Founder

Founder

edit

College opened in 1967, so I question the listed founder. Might be better to list as dedicated to or named for. Newtoid (talk) 07:19, 17 January 2020 (UTC)Reply

I tend to agree with what you say, or the sentiment perhaps inferred. This article states that the college takes its name by leap-frogging the earlier grammar school to that school's the founder; this linking here may be strictly understandable. There is an impulse in UK school articles, particularly for state schools, for aggrandizement by timeline linking to earlier more notable independent and/or grammar schools, even when there have been major changes in ethos, educational emphasis, and often even location/site, which often show very little or no viable association with that earlier entity, other than by name seizing. This aggrandizement can be emphasized by current schools grabbing notable alumni from an earlier school, although not in this case. I think the 'took its name from' does kind of cover your query. However, the article could be copy edited to shift much info in the sub-secs 'Sixth form college' and 'The college building (1876)' to the 'Grammar school' (renamed 'Rotherham Grammar School'?) sub-sec, leaving only that which strictly relates to the Sixth form college in its own section. However, there would then be a case to move most of this stuff into the Rotherham Grammar School article, leaving a much trimmed history section precis relating to this 1967 entity. If there has been no consensus over the next month (17 Feb), to keep this overbalance in the article, I will copy edit to reflect the above. Acabashi (talk) 09:26, 17 January 2020 (UTC)Reply