Talk:Telekom Romania Mobile
Latest comment: 4 years ago by Smjg in topic Proposed for deletion
This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
400.000 clients = 1% market share ??
edit400.000 users * 100 would yield a market of 40 millions mobile phone users, in a country with less than 22 million people. This is obviously wrong. Someone should update this with real data related to Cosmote's market share.
- The information about the number of subscribers can be found in one of the latest press releases: [1]
Proposed for deletion
editThis article refers to a service provided by Telekom Romania, and it contains same info as included in the company's main article. I therefore propose the article for deletion.Eduardm (talk) 23:51, 30 April 2020 (UTC)
- This is not a ground for deletion. Furthermore, why do you keep tagging it with {{db-move}}? This is for deleting a page in order to move another article to this title. I can't see that it makes any sense to move the page Telekom Romania to Telekom Romania Mobile. This would only make sense if the whole company is now called Telekom Romania Mobile. — Smjg (talk) 11:41, 1 May 2020 (UTC)
- Hi Smjg. Small correction, I requested for this article to be moved to Telekom Romania, not vice versa. Another user requested for what you're stating, and I tried to reverse that for the same reasons stated by you. Just a clarification, what would constitute grounds for deletion? This article simply repeated information in the Telekom Romania article, as it is simply referring to the mobile services of the aforementioned company. Therefore, it adds no extra information or value than the Telekom Romania article. Hence, the request to move this article to the Telekom Romania article. However, I realise now I misunderstood the {{db-move}} tag. Could you please let me know what tag should have been used? Such as {{Db-g6|rationale=reason}}? Would appreciate the guidance for future reference in possible similar cases. Eduardm (talk) 14:47, 1 May 2020 (UTC)
- @Eduardm: See WP:Criteria for speedy deletion for the grounds for speedy deletion, and WP:Deletion policy for more general information about what might constitute a reason to delete a page.
- What tag should have been used to do what?
- Request that the article content be moved to Telekom Romania? You say the article simply repeated information there; if this is so then there was nothing to move across. The best thing to do is simply redirect this there, which you did. But to answer your question more generally, it depends on the circumstances. See Wikipedia:Moving a page for if there isn't already an article (or is merely a redirect) at the target title, and Wikipedia:Merging for if there's an article already there and you're wanting to add the information to that already there.
- Request deletion of Telekom Romania Mobile? For stuff that doesn't meet the criteria for speedy deletion, look at WP:PROD and Wikipedia:Deletion process#Deletion venues. I'm not convinced that a deletion request on this would be successful, but you can try if you think it meets one of the reasons for deletion. — Smjg (talk) 18:39, 2 May 2020 (UTC)