Talk:Shape dynamics

Latest comment: 6 years ago by MaxEnt in topic Our own consistency

The unref tag should be removed, since the article contains a number of sources.

Our own consistency

edit

My last edit comment: Wikipedia does not render the page title for general relativity as a proper noun; hence the proper GR parallel convention for SD (applied inconsistently) is awkward and ugly here

I think it's enough to acknowledge the alternate style in the lead sentence, then conform to how Wikipedia render neither GR nor the second law of thermodynamics (also a specific, definite theory) as proper names.

In this context, the proper form strikes me as an affectation, and as Wikipedia has no claim to establish common usage (indeed, the arrow of causation flows exactly the other direction), I think our own internal consistency should hold sway :-)

That's my one-time only vote. Your dog. — MaxEnt 23:52, 13 April 2018 (UTC)Reply