| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Austrians |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Austrians
|
| Afrikaners |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Afrikaners
|
| interbreeding |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#interbreeding
|
| Gotlanders |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Gotlanders
|
| Scots |
9 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Scots
|
| merge |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#merge
|
| Request |
16 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Request
|
| List of contemporary Germanic peoples |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#List of contemporary Germanic peoples
|
| Hi. We should be clear on this point. |
22 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Hi. We should be clear on this point.
|
| ToC |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#ToC
|
| Delete the list of contemporary Germanics!! |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Delete the list of contemporary Germanics!!
|
| *Þiuda- |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#*Þiuda-
|
| The Spanish a Germanic people? |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#The Spanish a Germanic people?
|
| External links |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#External links
|
| Decent |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Decent
|
| Improvement of "Culture" |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Improvement of "Culture"
|
| How big were Germanic tribes? |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#How big were Germanic tribes?
|
| Austrians |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Austrians 2
|
| Caption: Pagan? |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Caption: Pagan?
|
| Etymology of the Word German |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Etymology of the Word German
|
| Self name of tribes |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Self name of tribes
|
| British Isles |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#British Isles
|
| "Assimilated Germanic peoples" |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#"Assimilated Germanic peoples"
|
| UK |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#UK
|
| Templates? |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Templates?
|
| Swe-des |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Swe-des
|
| Polish Pan-Slavic POV |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Polish Pan-Slavic POV
|
| Anglo-Saxons? |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Anglo-Saxons?
|
| Genetics |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Genetics
|
| "Historically linked" |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#"Historically linked"
|
| Recent onomastic research |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Recent onomastic research
|
| Wrong etymology |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Wrong etymology
|
| People vs. Peoples |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#People vs. Peoples
|
| Bavarian / Alemannic |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Bavarian / Alemannic
|
| da |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#da
|
| Rokus01's changes and possible OR |
9 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Rokus01's changes and possible OR
|
| Removal of unsourced Out-of-Scandinavian bias |
15 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Removal of unsourced Out-of-Scandinavian bias
|
| Northern Bronze Age or Nordic Bronze Age? |
27 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Northern Bronze Age or Nordic Bronze Age?
|
| More "why" with the "what" |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#More "why" with the "what"
|
| "German" peoples in Spain and England |
9 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#"German" peoples in Spain and England
|
| Painting at top |
17 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Painting at top
|
| Changed misleading wording in the Assimilation section |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Changed misleading wording in the Assimilation section
|
| Snoballa68's edits |
11 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Snoballa68's edits
|
| What needs doing? |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#What needs doing?
|
| First image |
12 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#First image
|
| Stupid phrase |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 1#Stupid phrase
|
| Background for SenseOnes edits |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Background for SenseOnes edits
|
| Milkmen? |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Milkmen?
|
| Germanic peoples "where" a group of ethnic groups? |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Germanic peoples "where" a group of ethnic groups?
|
| The Germanic peoples today |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#The Germanic peoples today
|
| Germanic-Sarmatian connection |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#Germanic-Sarmatian connection
|
| At lesser extent |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 2#At lesser extent
|
| Genetics section |
37 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Genetics section
|
| Thing |
16 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Thing
|
| Germanic tribes |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Germanic tribes
|
| Intro |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Intro
|
| Italy Spain |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Italy Spain
|
| Move |
15 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Move
|
| Language or Ethnic Group? |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Language or Ethnic Group?
|
| era style |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#era style
|
| Do Afrikaners Count As Germanic People? |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Do Afrikaners Count As Germanic People?
|
| Contemporary Germanic Europe |
21 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Contemporary Germanic Europe
|
| Saxon Danes? |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Saxon Danes?
|
| confusion |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#confusion
|
| Germanic wannabeism |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Germanic wannabeism
|
| Germanic peoples |
9 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Germanic peoples
|
| "West Germanic Kingdoms 460" map |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#"West Germanic Kingdoms 460" map
|
| DNA material (Y haplogroup I1) |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#DNA material (Y haplogroup I1)
|
| Ethymology |
12 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 3#Ethymology
|
| expansion of the lead |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#expansion of the lead
|
| Better Maps |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Better Maps
|
| Persistent BC/AC vandalism |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Persistent BC/AC vandalism
|
| Anachronism - describing older Germanic peoples as 'Germans' |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Anachronism - describing older Germanic peoples as 'Germans'
|
| Overreliance on Jordanes |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Overreliance on Jordanes
|
| Barbarization Thesis |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Barbarization Thesis
|
| Germans |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Germans
|
| Nikolai Kopernik |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Nikolai Kopernik
|
| Revert of infobox |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Revert of infobox
|
| collage picitures in infobox |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#collage picitures in infobox
|
| recent deletion |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#recent deletion
|
| The Braun & Schneider picture now being used as an illustration |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#The Braun & Schneider picture now being used as an illustration
|
| Political correctness has scared everyone. |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Political correctness has scared everyone.
|
| Infobox ethnic group |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Infobox ethnic group
|
| Image File:Ancient German Family.jpg |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Image File:Ancient German Family.jpg
|
| Article is preachy on Nordicist conception of Germanic peoples of today |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Article is preachy on Nordicist conception of Germanic peoples of today
|
| Article scope |
9 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Article scope
|
| call for opinions about the source in the controversial part of the lead in this article |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#call for opinions about the source in the controversial part of the lead in this article
|
| modern day Germanic peoples |
31 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#modern day Germanic peoples
|
| edit request from other people |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#edit request from other people
|
| Germanic DNA does not exist. |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Germanic DNA does not exist.
|
| Needs a fix |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Needs a fix
|
| In Herodotus's History |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#In Herodotus's History
|
| Ptolemys map from 2nd century only show Germaina and Germania Magna |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Ptolemys map from 2nd century only show Germaina and Germania Magna
|
| Charlemain note was the first German king in 8th century. The language did not exist until the 8th century but explain Slavic sorbs tribes living there in 6th century!: http://www.sachsen.de/en/276.htm |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Charlemain note was the first German king in 8th century. The language did not exist until the 8th century but explain Slavic sorbs tribes living there in 6th century!: http://www.sachsen.de/en/276.htm
|
| Scots |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Scots
|
| Objective sources lacking |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Objective sources lacking
|
| Germanic tribes in central Europe |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Germanic tribes in central Europe
|
| Special role of England |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Special role of England
|
| "Varieties of German" |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#"Varieties of German"
|
| Chicken or the Egg |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Chicken or the Egg
|
| Origins and Early Iron Age overlap |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Origins and Early Iron Age overlap
|
| Damitian |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 4#Damitian
|
| Etymology |
9 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Etymology
|
| List of Germanic peoples |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#List of Germanic peoples
|
| Germanic identity |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Germanic identity
|
| RfC: Should sections on genetics be removed from pages on ethnic groups? |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#RfC: Should sections on genetics be removed from pages on ethnic groups?
|
| Germanic antiquity in later historiography |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Germanic antiquity in later historiography
|
| Germans |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Germans
|
| CE/AD |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#CE/AD
|
| "North Sea Germanic", "Rhine-Weser Germanic", "Elbe Germanic" |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#"North Sea Germanic", "Rhine-Weser Germanic", "Elbe Germanic"
|
| Germanic peoples |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Germanic peoples
|
| Modern Germanic People |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Modern Germanic People
|
| Distribution of Y-chromosomal haplogroup I1a in Europe |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Distribution of Y-chromosomal haplogroup I1a in Europe
|
| No written records |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#No written records
|
| BC/AD vs. BCE/CE |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#BC/AD vs. BCE/CE
|
| Please tell me this is not true |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Please tell me this is not true
|
| Lowland Scots |
37 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Lowland Scots
|
| Modern history and culture: rise and fall of Germanics? |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Modern history and culture: rise and fall of Germanics?
|
| modern germanic peoples |
40 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 6#modern germanic peoples
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 8 April 2018 |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#Semi-protected edit request on 8 April 2018
|
| "Modern ethnic groups" arbitrary selection of Irish, Scots and Manx? |
20 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 5#"Modern ethnic groups" arbitrary selection of Irish, Scots and Manx?
|
| lets remove the line about "Modern ethnic groups descended from the ancient Germanic peoples" |
21 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 6#lets remove the line about "Modern ethnic groups descended from the ancient Germanic peoples"
|
| Problems with summary |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 6#Problems with summary
|
| Pytheas |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 6#Pytheas
|
| Term for the mainstream Rome-centred religion Clovis joined etc |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 6#Term for the mainstream Rome-centred religion Clovis joined etc
|
| Do modern "germanic people" exist? |
65 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 7#Do modern "germanic people" exist?
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 27 May 2019 |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 6#Semi-protected edit request on 27 May 2019
|
| Scope of the article |
64 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 8#Scope of the article
|
| New York |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 7#New York
|
| Map |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 7#Map
|
| Sub-plot: accusations of major recent changes to article topic |
18 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 10#Sub-plot: accusations of major recent changes to article topic
|
| Not an ethnolinguistic group |
13 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 8#Not an ethnolinguistic group
|
| Past tense? |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 8#Past tense?
|
| Article length |
22 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#Article length
|
| Genetics, continuity of old ethnic groups, etc |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 8#Genetics, continuity of old ethnic groups, etc
|
| Does modern "Germanic" heathenism need to be mentioned in the lead |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 8#Does modern "Germanic" heathenism need to be mentioned in the lead
|
| A first batch of new proposals for consideration |
25 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#A first batch of new proposals for consideration
|
| Genetic definition? |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#Genetic definition?
|
| The Early Germans by Malcolm Todd |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#The Early Germans by Malcolm Todd
|
| Expansion and restructuring |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#Expansion and restructuring
|
| the double footnote system is not well done |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#the double footnote system is not well done
|
| restructuring: further ideas |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#restructuring: further ideas
|
| Why do we need a section about the term barbarian? |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#Why do we need a section about the term barbarian?
|
| Revisiting the article topic controversy |
12 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#Revisiting the article topic controversy
|
| Proposed deletion of "Origins" and "Early Iron Age" sections in their current form |
13 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#Proposed deletion of "Origins" and "Early Iron Age" sections in their current form
|
| Merge proposal. Germani to be merged back to here (new split off article by Krakkos) |
43 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 8#Merge proposal. Germani to be merged back to here (new split off article by Krakkos)
|
| Another split off article created by Krakkos: Early Germanic culture |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#Another split off article created by Krakkos: Early Germanic culture
|
| conflation of franks with visigoths? |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 7#conflation of franks with visigoths?
|
| Serious misrepresentation of reliable sources by Andrew Lancaster |
34 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 9#Serious misrepresentation of reliable sources by Andrew Lancaster
|
| Two simple and fundamental questions for Andrew Lancaster |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 10#Two simple and fundamental questions for Andrew Lancaster
|
| Proposal |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 10#Proposal
|
| If racial "Germanics" are the problem, then let's also put this on the table... |
27 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 10#If racial "Germanics" are the problem, then let's also put this on the table...
|
| Drafting: easier to show |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#Drafting: easier to show
|
| Etymology of Germani |
28 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#Etymology of Germani
|
| RfC: Is this article primarily about people called Germani in Latin-language ancient Roman sources, or is it primarily about people called Germanic in English-language modern sources? |
51 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#RfC: Is this article primarily about people called Germani in Latin-language ancient Roman sources, or is it primarily about people called Germanic in English-language modern sources?
|
| Roman definition of Germani was not all "inhabitants of Germania" |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#Roman definition of Germani was not all "inhabitants of Germania"
|
| Genetics synth |
13 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#Genetics synth
|
| This article being discussed elsewhere by Krakkos and Andrew Lancaster |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#This article being discussed elsewhere by Krakkos and Andrew Lancaster
|
| Verification check: Liebeschuetz re. Gillett etc |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#Verification check: Liebeschuetz re. Gillett etc
|
| Future of the article |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#Future of the article
|
| Protected edit request on 1 February 2020 |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#Protected edit request on 1 February 2020
|
| Drastic and highly problematic edit to the lead |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 11#Drastic and highly problematic edit to the lead
|
| New lead source verification discussion |
15 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 12#New lead source verification discussion
|
| Section on linguistics |
55 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 12#Section on linguistics
|
| New second section: "Definitions of Germanic" (instead of "Ethnomyns", which are now part of it) |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 12#New second section: "Definitions of Germanic" (instead of "Ethnomyns", which are now part of it)
|
| Proposed sections to be merged-out/deleted or moved |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 10#Proposed sections to be merged-out/deleted or moved
|
| The elephant in the room: section 4 "History" should be pruned |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 12#The elephant in the room: section 4 "History" should be pruned
|
| Do we need two discussions of Pytheas (internal POV forking?) |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 10#Do we need two discussions of Pytheas (internal POV forking?)
|
| Open question about Clovis/Visigoths should be handled |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 10#Open question about Clovis/Visigoths should be handled
|
| "Physical characteristics" |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 12#"Physical characteristics"
|
| Gaulish versus Gallic |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 12#Gaulish versus Gallic
|
| Bibliography check: many Britannica articles |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 12#Bibliography check: many Britannica articles
|
| the article length topic revisited |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 12#the article length topic revisited
|
| Several edits |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 13#Several edits
|
| Unusued references in bibliography |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 13#Unusued references in bibliography
|
| Edit summaries |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 13#Edit summaries
|
| Back to the etymology question |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 13#Back to the etymology question
|
| Discussion relevant to this article, on less watched article. Topics include Walter Goffart as source. |
19 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 13#Discussion relevant to this article, on less watched article. Topics include Walter Goffart as source.
|
| Agenda Anyone |
9 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 13#Agenda Anyone
|
| Feedback requested on 8 (hopefully) minor points |
32 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 14#Feedback requested on 8 (hopefully) minor points
|
| Early Middle Ages |
27 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 14#Early Middle Ages
|
| An article to define the scope of another article? |
36 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 15#An article to define the scope of another article?
|
| archaeology section(s) and pre-Caesar (pre) history sections |
28 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 14#archaeology section(s) and pre-Caesar (pre) history sections
|
| Genetic Legacy of Germanic Expansions Map |
21 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 15#Genetic Legacy of Germanic Expansions Map
|
| Caesar's speculations |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 15#Caesar's speculations
|
| "Tribes" |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 15#"Tribes"
|
| A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 15#A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion
|
| Proto-Germanic |
12 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 15#Proto-Germanic
|
| Rewrite and NPOV |
27 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 15#Rewrite and NPOV
|
| Endonym |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 15#Endonym
|
| Bold idea: should we remove the languages section (3.3)? |
13 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 16#Bold idea: should we remove the languages section (3.3)?
|
| Include central Europe |
18 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 16#Include central Europe
|
| removed definition? |
11 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 16#removed definition?
|
| Ethnic groups? |
13 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 17#Ethnic groups?
|
| Arminius vs. Hermann |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 16#Arminius vs. Hermann
|
| Germanic peoples revisited |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 16#Germanic peoples revisited
|
| Article POV |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 16#Article POV
|
| Structure |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 16#Structure
|
| The Germanic peoples are an ethnic group |
28 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 17#The Germanic peoples are an ethnic group
|
| do we need a roll-back? |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 16#do we need a roll-back?
|
| Proto-Germanic folklore |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 17#Proto-Germanic folklore
|
| Goffart |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 17#Goffart
|
| Structure ideas again |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 17#Structure ideas again
|
| Straw poll: Split article into two: (a) Ancient Germanic peoples (linguistic and ethnic group) and (b) Germani (Roman exonym) |
67 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 18#Straw poll: Split article into two: (a) Ancient Germanic peoples (linguistic and ethnic group) and (b) Germani (Roman exonym)
|
| A request |
6 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 17#A request
|
| Late 20th c. Academia, Migrationism and Immobilism (diffusionism) |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 17#Late 20th c. Academia, Migrationism and Immobilism (diffusionism)
|
| "Attempt" to define |
23 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 18#"Attempt" to define
|
| Germanic studies |
16 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 19#Germanic studies
|
| Getting more eyes |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 18#Getting more eyes
|
| Germanii and Germani |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 19#Germanii and Germani
|
| Let my people go |
20 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 19#Let my people go
|
| - Cont. - |
15 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 19#- Cont. -
|
| A way forward? |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 19#A way forward?
|
| My thoughts.... |
30 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#My thoughts....
|
| New book on Archaeology and Germani |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#New book on Archaeology and Germani
|
| TNTing the lead |
25 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#TNTing the lead
|
| Mystery source... |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#Mystery source...
|
| Started working on Modern definition |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#Started working on Modern definition
|
| questioned edit |
33 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#questioned edit
|
| the question of what this article is about |
16 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#the question of what this article is about
|
| Language section and Roman classification section |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#Language section and Roman classification section
|
| Germanic-speaking peoples |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#Germanic-speaking peoples
|
| Germanic paganism |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#Germanic paganism
|
| Scirii = σκιροι? |
9 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 20#Scirii = σκιροι?
|
| The Nordic Bronze Age |
13 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#The Nordic Bronze Age
|
| Future-proofing |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Future-proofing
|
| Was Teutoberg a turning point in world history? |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Was Teutoberg a turning point in world history?
|
| Roman Germania |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Roman Germania
|
| Length of sections on Classical Definitions and "Gaulish" Germani |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Length of sections on Classical Definitions and "Gaulish" Germani
|
| Germani and ancient Germans |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Germani and ancient Germans
|
| Good guys vs. bad guys |
13 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Good guys vs. bad guys
|
| Language templates |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Language templates
|
| What's left to do |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#What's left to do
|
| Language |
60 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Language
|
| "The Pre-Christian Religions of the North" (Brepols, 2020) |
43 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#"The Pre-Christian Religions of the North" (Brepols, 2020)
|
| The food is good in Sicilia |
12 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#The food is good in Sicilia
|
| Germans are considered part of the broad Germanic category |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Germans are considered part of the broad Germanic category
|
| That's SOME edit war |
44 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#That's SOME edit war
|
| Length of history section |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Length of history section
|
| Removal of discussion of Shaw's challenge to Odin/Woden cognate assumption |
17 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Removal of discussion of Shaw's challenge to Odin/Woden cognate assumption
|
| deletion of sourced material about the so-called Germanic guard |
21 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#deletion of sourced material about the so-called Germanic guard
|
| Scope of end of history section |
41 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Scope of end of history section
|
| Time for a reminder.... |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Time for a reminder....
|
| Anything still missing? |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Anything still missing?
|
| Religious continuity |
27 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Religious continuity
|
| Parallels |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Parallels
|
| Nordic Bronze Age |
16 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Nordic Bronze Age
|
| Categories for discussion |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Categories for discussion
|
| Edit war |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Edit war
|
| WP:ERA |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#WP:ERA
|
| Pictures |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Pictures
|
| Our opening sentence, defining the article |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Our opening sentence, defining the article
|
| New name for this article. |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#New name for this article.
|
| Wonder |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Wonder
|
| Most scholars |
26 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Most scholars
|
| March 2023 |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#March 2023
|
| Categories for discussion |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Categories for discussion 2
|
| Should we at least mention the Teutonic terminology |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Should we at least mention the Teutonic terminology
|
| Recent edits about purported lack of use of "Germanic peoples" among historians and archaeologists |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Recent edits about purported lack of use of "Germanic peoples" among historians and archaeologists
|
| Question |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Question
|
| Question |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Question 2
|
| once occupied? |
3 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#once occupied?
|
| Two pre-print articles to watch |
23 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Two pre-print articles to watch
|
| A plea for short sentences |
14 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#A plea for short sentences
|
| Bernard Mees's "The English Language before England" (Routledge, 2023) |
4 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Bernard Mees's "The English Language before England" (Routledge, 2023)
|
| Addition to metalworking section |
2 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Addition to metalworking section
|
| Article opening |
12 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Article opening
|
| Suggestion: New map under Subdivisions |
8 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Suggestion: New map under Subdivisions
|
| Suggestion: Replace Southern Scandinavia with Jutland |
10 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Suggestion: Replace Southern Scandinavia with Jutland
|
| map that might help |
1 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#map that might help
|
| map review |
28 |
Talk:Germanic peoples#map review
|
| Beating the very loosely interpreted Steuer (p.3) Quote to Death |
5 |
Talk:Germanic peoples/Archive 21#Beating the very loosely interpreted Steuer (p.3) Quote to Death
|
| Source check: why southern Jutland? |
17 |
Talk:Germanic peoples#Source check: why southern Jutland?
|
| Osterby Man |
12 |
Talk:Germanic peoples#Osterby Man
|
| What is 'Northern Europe'? |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples#What is 'Northern Europe'?
|
| Doubtful category |
7 |
Talk:Germanic peoples#Doubtful category
|
