Talk:Carl Rohl-Smith

Latest comment: 11 years ago by Tim1965 in topic Iowa Soldiers and Sailors Monument

Iowa Soldiers and Sailors Monument

edit

The source cited says Rohl-Smith had little to do with the Iowa Soldiers and Sailors Monument. He merely implemented the design by Harriet A. Ketcham. Adding images of the monument is a testament to Ketcham, and does not reflect Rohl-Smith's artistic talent. If there is evidence that Rohl-Smith designed all, some, or part of the Iowa Soldiers and Sailors Monument, it should be added. But the sources should be very specific about exactly what is Rohl-Smith's work, and what is Ketcham's. If it's unclear, no attribution should be made. - Tim1965 (talk) 01:20, 26 December 2012 (UTC)Reply