Super-imperialism is a Marxist term with two possible meanings. It can refer:
- to the hegemony of an imperialist great power over its weaker rivals, which in this context become sub-imperialisms[1]
- to a comprehensive supra-structure above a set of theoretically equal-righted imperialist states
The latter meaning is the older one and had become rare by the middle of the 20th century.
Etymology
editThe expression super-imperialism first appeared in November 1914 as an inaccurate translation of the newly coined German term Ultra-Imperialismus. William E. Bohn, the translator of Karl Kautsky’s article "Der Imperialismus" ("The Imperialism"),[2] seemed to believe that the terms Kartell and Ultra-Imperialismus were not reasonable for the audience of the International Socialist Review, an American Marxist journal.[3] Bohn faced a double problem as cartels were much less familiar in the United States than the concern-like, tauter organized trust entities and the word ultra, which in English means "exaggerated" or "extreme". Thus, he paraphrased Kautsky's ideas in terms more familiar to American readers, somewhat distorting Kautsky's statement.
Recent meanings
editTogether with the revival of the imperialism debates in the 1970s, the term super-imperialism recovered, but was modified in its content. It served now to describe the domination by the super-power United States within a system of imperialism in which the other imperialist powers were set back in their abilities and thus were second-class.[4] Since the same time, the German term Ultraimperialismus was translated into English literally with ultra-imperialism and was now used to describe a rather equal-righted inter-imperialist cooperation.
References
edit- ^
Compare:
Noonan, Murray (28 February 2017). "The Big Three: Globalisation, Empire, State and the Third Phase of Marxist Imperialism Theory". Written at Bloomsbury Publishing. Marxist Theories of Imperialism: A History. London. p. 247. ISBN 9781786720948. Retrieved 8 June 2024.
By sub-imperialism, [ten Brink] mean[s] countries that strive for political dominance on a regional scale in ways similar to the most developed capitalist states at a macro-regional or even global scale.
{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link) - ^ Karl Kautsky: Der Imperialismus. In: Die Neue Zeit. 32 (1914), vol. 2, p. 908–922.
- ^ Vgl.: Karl Kautsky, Imperialism and the War, in: International socialist review, 15 (1914), 286.
- ^ Bob Rowthorn, Imperialism in the Seventies: Unity or Rivalry?, in: New Left Review, 59 (1971), 31; Michael Hudson: Super imperialism : the economic strategy of American empire, New York, 1972.
Literature
edit- Michael Hudson: Super Imperialism. The Economic Strategy of American Empire (Third Edition), Islet, 2021. ISBN 978-3981826098
- Karl Kautsky: Imperialism and the War, in: International socialist review, 15 (1914).
- Karl Kautsky: Der Imperialismus, in: Die Neue Zeit. 32 (1914), vol. 2, p. 908–922.
- Holm A. Leonhardt: Bibliographie zur Ultraimperialismus-Theorie [Bibliography on Ultraimperialism Theory], in: Homepage of the Institute of History of Hildesheim University, http://www.uni-hildesheim.de/media/geschichte/Geschichte Ultraimperialismustheorie.pdf (available since 1–20–2008).
- Holm A. Leonhardt: Zur Geschichte der Ultraimperialismus-Theorie 1902–1930. Die Ideengeschichte einer frühen Theorie der politischen Globalisierung [On the History of Ultra-Imperialism Theory], in: Homepage of the Institute of History, Hildesheim Universität (Germany) http://www.uni-hildesheim.de/de/30219.htm (available since 1–20–2008).
- Bob Rowthorn: Imperialism in the Seventies: Unity or Rivalry? , in: New Left Review, 59 (1971).
- Martin Thomas: Introduction to Kautsky's "Ultra-imperialism". Workers Liberty.
- Dan Jakopovich, In the Belly of the Beast: Challenging US Imperialism and the Politics of the Offensive'