Mystery meat navigation (also known as MMN) is a form of web navigation user interface whereby the target of each link is not visible until the user points their cursor at it. Such interfaces lack a user-centered design, emphasizing aesthetic appearance, white space, and the concealment of information over practicality and functionality.[1][2] The term was coined in 1998 by Vincent Flanders, author of the book and accompanying website Web Pages That Suck.[3]
Terminology
editThe epithet "mystery meat" refers to the meat products often served in American public school cafeterias whose forms have been so thoroughly reprocessed that their exact types can no longer be identified by their appearances;[4][5] similarly, the destinations of links using mystery meat navigation are unknown by appearance alone. Using such a navigation has been likened to processed meat products as "you're not sure what meat you've got until you bite into it".[6] Flanders originally and temporarily described the phenomenon as Saturnic navigation in reference to the Saturn Corporation, whose company website epitomized this phenomenon.[7]
Practice
editThe practice of mystery meat navigation may be defined as "frivolously concealing navigation options through rollovers and other tricks." It is considered problematic on information-rich websites because it makes it difficult for users to recognise the destinations of navigational hyperlinks, or to discern where they are, and this increases the time a user takes to learn to use the site.[8][9]
Iconographic navigation
edit
Website interface designers often decide to use iconographic navigation schemes as a way of reducing visual clutter and avoiding the need for language localisation.[10] The exclusive use of icons without explicit labels in a website navigation may not be considered intuitive because it relies on the designer's personal understanding of the meaning of each icon.[11] The provision of alt attributes or tooltips which are revealed on mouseover are not considered a satisfactory solution, as these techniques only introduce an element of exploration that has been likened to minesweeping ("let's roll over everything and see if any surprises pop up"). This practice has been identified as a common anti-pattern in interactive design.[6][12] Technology writer Shelley Powers also notes that MMN often relies on JavaScript, and that this can be detrimental to usability if a browser's scripting is disabled, and to search engine optimization.[13]
Flanders writes, "The typical form of MMN is represented by menus composed of unrevealing icons that are replaced with explicative text only when the mouse cursor hovers over them".[7]
"Click here"
editSome technology commentators consider that the use of the popular phrase "Click here" as link text is a type of mystery meat navigation. It is thought to be problematic because the phrase does not indicate the content of the link target, which confuses the user.[10]
The W3C's Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, as well as organisations such as WebAIM, recommend against the use of phrases such as "click here" as link text.[14][15] According to the W3C, "Good link text should not be overly general; don't use 'click here.' [...] link text should indicate the nature of the link target".[16] The text should also make sense when read out of context.
Furthermore, the phrase is inappropriate for users who are not using a mouse to navigate, e.g. using a keyboard or a touchscreen device. It also presents particular difficulties for blind and visually impaired users who make use of screen reader software that reviews a list of available links on a page. Pages would also suffer when printed. A further disadvantage given is that it hinders the search engine optimisation of a page.[10][16]
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ Ward, Mark (2002-11-04). "Why websites are getting easier to use". BBC News. Retrieved 2014-07-11.
- ^ Kingsley-Hughes, Adrian (2010-05-11). "iPad apps bring back mid-1990s "mystery meat" user interface problems". ZDNet. Archived from the original on May 13, 2010. Retrieved 2014-07-11.
- ^ Flanders, Vincent (1998). Web Pages That Suck: Learn Good Design by Looking at Bad Design. San Francisco: Sybex Inc. ISBN 978-0-7821-2187-2.
- ^ Beaumont, Andy; Gibbons, Dave; Kerr, Jody; Stephens, Jon (11 November 2013). Constructing Usable Web Menus. Apress. p. 16. ISBN 978-1-4302-5358-7.
- ^ Flanders, Vincent; Peters, Dean (2002). "8. Navigation and Mystery Meat: Mystery Meat Navigation is the Spawn of Satan". Son of Web Pages that Suck: Learn Good Design by Looking at Bad Design. San Francisco, CA : Sybex. pp. 163–165. ISBN 978-0-7821-4020-0. Retrieved 24 January 2023.
- ^ a b Brinck, Tom; Gergle, Darren; Wood, Scott D. (2002). Designing Web Sites that Work: Usability for the Web. Morgan Kaufmann. p. 125. ISBN 978-1-55860-658-6. Retrieved 23 January 2023.
- ^ a b Flanders, Vincent. "Web Pages That Suck learn good web design by looking at bad web design - Mystery Meat Navigation". Archived from the original on 1 July 2008. Retrieved 14 June 2009.
- ^ Psychology of Web Design. Smashing Magazine. 2012. p. 84. ISBN 978-3-943075-24-3.
- ^ Kalbach, James (28 August 2007). Designing Web Navigation: Optimizing the User Experience. O'Reilly Media. p. 149. ISBN 978-0-596-55378-4. Retrieved 23 January 2023.
- ^ a b c MacDonald, Diana (25 June 2019). Practical UI Patterns for Design Systems: Fast-Track Interaction Design for a Seamless User Experience. Apress. p. 194. ISBN 978-1-4842-4938-3. Retrieved 23 January 2023.
- ^ Potts, Kevin (25 November 2007). Web Design and Marketing Solutions for Business Websites. Apress. p. 78. ISBN 978-1-4302-0262-2. Retrieved 23 January 2023.
- ^ Scott, Bill; Neil, Theresa (15 January 2009). Designing Web Interfaces: Principles and Patterns for Rich Interactions. O'Reilly Media. p. 90. ISBN 978-0-596-55445-3.
- ^ Powers, Shelley (1 May 2008). Painting the Web: Catching the User's Eyes - and Keeping Them on Your Site. "O'Reilly Media, Inc.". p. 16. ISBN 978-0-596-55392-0. Retrieved 23 January 2023.
- ^ "Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 1.0". W3.org. Retrieved 2012-05-07.
- ^ "Introduction to Web Accessibility". WebAIM. Retrieved 2012-05-07.
- ^ a b "HTML Techniques for Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 1.0". W3.org. Retrieved 2014-07-11.