Liberalism: A Counter-History (Italian: Controstoria del liberalismo) is a 2005 book by Italian philosopher Domenico Losurdo, first published in English in 2011. In the book, Losurdo examines the inner contradictions of the highly influential history of liberalism and its political tradition. Key liberal thinkers who are discussed include John Locke, Alexis de Tocqueville and Edmund Burke.
 First edition (Italian) | |
| Author | Domenico Losurdo |
|---|---|
| Original title | Controstoria del liberalismo |
| Subject | Political theory |
| Publisher | Editori Laterza |
Publication date | 2005 |
| Publication place | Italy |
Published in English | 2011 |
Losurdo argues that the liberal tradition has often excused and even celebrated racism, slavery, exploitation and genocide. Among the atrocities that Losurdo finds liberalism condoned include the Great Famine of Ireland, chattel slavery in the United States, the Indian genocide in North America, the Opium Wars, British crimes in India and the implementation of Jim Crow laws in the American South.
Summary
editIn the book, Losurdo characterises the dominant narrative regarding liberalism as hagiography, representing a gradual process of the expansion of liberty to all people. Rather, Losurdo investigates not only "the conceptual developments, but also and primarily the political and social relations it found expression in" which made itself known through various contradictions.[1] Not only is the process contradictory, but it is also marked by episodes where a group that is given rights can have those rights taken away. One such example is when Black Americans lost many of their newfound rights as the end of the Reconstruction Era gave way to the rise of Jim Crow laws.
According to Losurdo, liberalism lent itself to the foundation of Herrenvolk democracy, where one ethnic group had rights over other disenfranchised and exploited groups. Losurdo finds the early United States, a racial state with a clear difference in the rights afforded between whites and even free Blacks, to have been one such master-race democracy.[2] Additionally, influential liberal conservative Edmund Burke is credited with penning "the first organic theory of revolution as a Jewish conspiracy", an antisemitic conspiracy theory that was essential in fueling the genocidal aspects of Nazi ideology.[3]
According to Losurdo, the white supremacy that was typical of liberal thinkers of the time had a formative influence on fascism while also taking the dehumanization of those it considered inferior to extremes. For instance, Losurdo observes that the one-drop rule found in the American South was more stringent than the Nuremberg Laws (citizenship is not given if found 3⁄4 Jewish) implemented by Nazi Germany.[4]
Reception and influence
editLiberalism: A Counter-History has received a number of positive reviews from critics. Peter Clarke wrote in the Financial Times that Liberalism: A Counter-History is "a brilliant exercise in unmasking liberal pretensions, surveying over three centuries with magisterial command of the sources."[5] Essayist Pankaj Mishra wrote in The Guardian that Liberalism: A Counter-History "stimulatingly uncovers the contradictions of an ideology that is much too self-righteously invoked."[6]
Liberalism: A Counter-History was also well-received by Stefano G. Azzarà in Historical Materialism,[7] Geoff Mann in Antipode[8] and Iain McKay in Capital & Class.[9]
Notes and references
edit- ^ Liberalism: A Counter-History. Introduction. p. viii.
- ^ Liberalism: A Counter-History. p. 150.
- ^ Liberalism: A Counter-History. p. 276.
- ^ Liberalism: A Counter-History. p. 338.
- ^ Clarke, Peter (13 May 2011). "Locke, Stock, and Barrel". Financial Times. Retrieved 5 May 2017.
- ^ Mishra, Pankaj (2 November 2011). "Books of the Year 2011". The Guardian. Retrieved 5 May 2017.
- ^ Azzarà, Stefano G. (2011-01-01). "Settling Accounts with Liberalism: On the Work of Domenico Losurdo". Historical Materialism. 19 (2): 92–112. doi:10.1163/156920611X573815. ISSN 1465-4466.
- ^ Mann, Geoff (January 2012). "Liberalism: A Counter-History by Domenico Losurdo". Antipode. 44 (1): 265–269. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8330.2011.00949.x. ISSN 1467-8330.
- ^ McKay, Ian (2014). "Extended book review: Gramsci's Political Thought, by Carlos Nelson Coutinho and Gramsci: Du libéralisme au 'communisme critique' by Domenico Losurdo". Capital & Class. 38 (2): 455–462. doi:10.1177/0309816814534018. ISSN 0309-8168. S2CID 140786682.
External links
edit- Domenico Losurdo (2014). Liberalism: A Counter-History. Verso Books. 384 p. ISBN 9781781681664. ISBN 978-1781681664.