Kobe Incident

The Kobe incident (神戸事件, kōbe jiken), also known in Japanese as the Bizen incident (備前事件, bizen jiken) and in English as the Bizen affray or Bizen affair, was a diplomatic incident between Imperial Japan and several Western powers, caused by a skirmish on February 4, 1868 between Bizen soldiers and foreign sailors. It developed into a crisis in Franco–Japanese relations, becoming the first major international affairs challenge for the fledgling Meiji government.

Kobe incident

Date	February 4, 1868 (1868-02-04)
Location	Between Tamondori and the Ikuta Shrine in Kobe
Also known as	Bizen incident
Cause	Tension between marching Japanese Imperial-allied forces of Bizen province and foreign soldiers along the route.
Participants	Two men of French origin Armed men from the Kobe foreign settlement of several nationalities 50 American Marines, landed from US Navy ships off Kobe A "Coolie" of either Chinese or Indian origin Bizen men 500 (alternately 800) soldiers of Bizen Domain
Outcome	Temporary occupation of central Kobe by foreign forces, lifted after execution by seppuku of Japanese squad leader; official transition of international relations from Shogunal to Imperial hands.
Convicted	Taki Zenzaburo (jp)

The incident occurred during a period of time that Hyōgo Port was open to foreign trade, with a community of foreign merchants and soldiers living and working in the Kobe foreign settlement. In response, the foreign militaries seized nearby Japanese warships and occupied the center of the city under the pretense of protecting their settlement. The Imperial court sent a representative to negotiate and inform the Westerners that power had shifted from the Tokugawa Shogunate to the newly-formed Meiji government. The Western representatives demanded Taki Zenzaburo, who was involved, be executed; Taki committed ceremonial seppuku on March 3.

Initial incident

On January 27, 1868, with the outbreak of the Boshin War, the new Meiji government ordered that Nishinomiya in Settsu be guarded in order to check the pro-Shogunate forces of Amagasaki Domain. By the 29th, 2,000 troops had been raised in Bizen Domain to the west, and among these were 500 (alternately 800) troops under the command of the domain's karō Heki Tatewaki (日置帯刀), accompanied by cannons, who marched over land for their destination. Because the port of Hyōgo had been opened on January 1, the troops advanced on the Saikoku Kaidō (西国街道) road rather than that built by the Tokugawa shogunate, in an effort to avoid encounters with enemy forces or foreigners.

Sometime after 1 o'clock on February 4, as the line of Bizen troops marched along in the vicinity of Sannomiya Shrine, two French sailors emerged from a nearby building and attempted to cross the line. The Japanese troops saw this as constituting tomowari (供割), an act of extreme disrespect under the Laws for the Military Houses, and Taki Zenzaburo, in charge of the third cannon group, took a spear and attempted to stop them. However, neither side could understand the other, and when the sailors attempted to force their way through, Taki stabbed at them with his spear, inflicting light wounds.

The sailors briefly retreated indoors but reemerged with handguns. Taki, seeing this, shouted out "Guns, guns!", which his troops took as an order to shoot, beginning a firefight. The roadside skirmish soon also targeted the European and American dignitaries who were inspecting the adjacent planned site of a foreign settlement, and several full volleys were fired. Most of the bullets missed and flew over the heads of their intended targets, but did pierce the various foreign flags flying over the old Shogunate customs house on the other side of the planned site. Whether this was warning fire or simply badly aimed shots intended to kill was unclear even in the testimony of Western witnesses.

Foreign response

The British envoy Harry Smith Parkes, who happened to be present at the skirmish, was enraged, and notified the vessels of various nations present to celebrate the opening of the port of Hyōgo of a state of emergency. U.S. Marines, British guardsmen, and French sailors pursued the Bizen troops outside of the foreign settlement and exchanged fire at Ikuta River. On the Bizen side, Heki ordered his troops to cease fire and withdraw. There was one "coolie" killed, and a few wounded on either side.

On that same day, the Great Powers that possessed consulates in Kobe militarily occupied central Kobe under the pretext of protecting the foreign settlement, and seized the Tokugawa warships anchored off the Hyōgo port. At this point in time, the Japanese imperial court had not yet informed foreign countries of the transition of power from the Shogunate to the Meiji government, and Itō Hirobumi attempted negotiations that quickly broke down.

On February 8, the imperial court hurriedly announced the transfer of power to the Meiji government and declared the opening of Japan. Higashikuze Michitomi was assigned as a representative and reopened negotiations.

The foreign countries demanded safety for their people and harsh punishment for the Japanese person responsible for the incident—in short, Taki's execution. There was some complaint that this was too harsh for an incident in which no one had actually died, and to the Japanese Taki's response to the foreign troops' tomowari seemed altogether natural, but in the face of a demand from the Great Powers there was nothing to be done. Date Munenari sent an appeal for clemency via Itō Hirobumi and Godai Tomoatsu, which arrived just in time, but was rejected by a vote of the foreign ministers, beginning with the French Consul General Léon Roches.

Finally, on February 24, Bizen Domain acceded to the foreign countries' demands. Taki committed seppuku before the assembled foreign officials at Eifuku-ji Temple in Osaka on March 3. Heki, who had been in command of the troops, was simultaneously placed under house arrest, and the incident was tentatively resolved.

Significance

The Kobe Incident represented the first international diplomatic incident faced by the new government after the restoration of Imperial rule. Though this incident was ultimately resolved when the foreign powers forced the execution of Taki Zenzaburo (jp), it did demonstrate to them that the new Meiji government was now the ruling administration to deal with in terms of Japan's foreign policy. Furthermore, this incident showed the court's foreign-relations philosophy turning quickly from that of "expel the barbarians" (攘夷, jōi) to "opening the country in peace and amity" (開国和親, kaikoku washin). However, as the jōi faction did retain support in the new administration, the new foreign policy was not made clear internally. An official declaration of the change was finally made the next year, on July 7, 1869, based on a decision by the jōkyoku kaigi (上局会議) national council.

See also

• Diplomatic (contractual or in treatise) faux-pas
• The Robinson Affair (Namamugi Incident)

References

Japanese sources

• "Request for relief of damage with Soshu-maru, Chikuzen domain, and Shimpu-maru, Kurume domain, detained by foreigners during riot and firing of former Bizen domain members at Kobe port" (神戸港二於テ備前藩士暴動発砲ノ際外国人二抑留セラレシ筑前藩蒼隼丸船及久留米藩晨風艦損失救助願一件, kōbe-kō ni oite bizen-han shi bōdō happō no sai gaikokujin ni yokuryō serareshi chikuzen-han sōshunmaru-sen oyobi kurume-han shinpū-kan sonshitsu kyūjogan ikken), held by the Diplomatic Archives of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, available online via the Japan Center for Asian Historical Records with reference number B08090131500.
• Tokutomi, Sohō (1963). 近世日本国民史 67 官軍・東軍交戦篇 (in Japanese). Jiji Press.
• Oka, Yoshitake (1964). 黎明期の明治日本 [The Dawn of Meiji Japan] (in Japanese). Miraisha.
• Ishii, Takashi (1966). 増訂 明治維新の国際的環境 [The International Environment of the Meiji Restoration, New and Revised Edition] (in Japanese). Yoshikawa Kōbunkan.
• Taki, Yoshinari (March 1980). 『神戸事件 瀧善三郎』に関する諸資料 [Documents on Taki Zenzaburo of the Kōbe Incident]. 日本古書通信 (in Japanese) (431).
• Uchiyama, Masakuma (1983). 神戸事件--明治外交の出発点 [The Kobe Incident: The Starting Point of Meiji Diplomacy] (in Japanese). Chūkō Shinsho.
• Hinata, Yasushi (1985). 非命の譜. Mainichi Shinbunsha.
• ＮＨＫ歴史への招待 第20巻 黒船来襲 [NHK Invitation to History, Volume 20: Invasion of the Black Ships] (in Japanese). NHK Publishing. 1989.
• Nemoto, Katsuo (1990). 検証 神戸事件 [An Investigation of the Kobe Incident] (in Japanese). Sougei Press.
• Yano, Tsuneo (2008). 維新外交秘録 神戸事件 [Secret Records of Restoration Diplomacy: The Kobe Incident] (in Japanese). Forum-A.
• Suzuki, Yuko (June 2009). "慶応四年神戸事件の意味--備前藩と新政府" [The Meaning of the Kobe Incident of Keiō 4: Bizen and the New Government]. Japanese History (日本歴史) (in Japanese) (733).

Western sources

• "JAPAN.; The Invasion of the Sacred Soil by Foreign Powers. Full Particulars of the Brief but Decisive Campaign. The War Between Satsuma and the Tycoon Stotsbashi". New York Times. April 22, 1868.
• "JAPAN.; Particulars of the Insurrection Outrage to Foreigners—Reported Termination of the Insurrectionary Movement". New York Times. April 23, 1868.
• Adams, Francis Ottiwell (1875). The History of Japan, Volume 2 1865 - 1871. Edition.
• Black, John Reddie (1881). Young Japan: Yokohama and Edo, Volume 2. pp. 145–159.
• von Brandt, Max (1901). 39 Jahre in Ostasien - Erinnerungen eines deutschen Diplomaten (in German). Vol. 2.
• Longford, Joseph H. (1910). The Story of Old Japan. Chapman and Hall, Ltd.
• Freeman-Mitford, Algernon (1871). "An Account of the Hara-Kiri". Tales of Old Japan.
• Satow, Ernest (1921). A Diplomat in Japan. Seeley, Service & Co.