On 19 June 2021, Stanislav Tomáš, a Romani man in Teplice, Czech Republic, died after several police officers pinned him to the ground and knelt on his neck for several minutes.[1][2] The death was filmed and the video went viral, leading to comparisons with the murder of George Floyd in the United States and led to protests against antiziganism.[3]
Background
editRomani people (Czech: Romové) are an ethnic minority in the Czech Republic, currently making up 2–3% of the population. Since the creation of Czechoslovakia in 1918, the Romani population have experienced considerable hardship, having been a main target of Nazi extermination programs during World War II, and the subject of forced relocation, the building of Roma walls to enforce segregation, and other discriminatory social policies during the Communist era.[4] Romani people continue to be targeted by far-right groups in the Czech Republic, which spread anti-Romanyism.[5] Among highly publicized cases was the Vítkov arson attack of 2009. A 2010 survey found that 83% of Czechs consider Roma asocial and 45% of Czechs would like to expel them from the Czech Republic, and a 2019 Pew Research poll found that 66% of Czechs held unfavorable views of Roma.[6][7]
Death
editOn 19 June 2021, Tomáš, a 46-year-old Romani man, was arrested by Czech police in Teplice. Multiple eyewitnesses stated that he was arrested while attempting to prevent the vandalism of a car. Video footage of the arrest that was captured by witnesses showed several police officers pinning him to the ground and kneeling on his neck and back. During the arrest, Tomáš cried out repeatedly in distress and several onlookers attempted to warn the police that he could not breathe. Tomáš died shortly afterwards in an ambulance.[8]
Police denied any involvement in the death.[9] An official police statement claimed that a court-ordered autopsy had found no connection between Tomáš' death and the actions of the police and that he had instead died of an amphetamine overdose.[10] The Czech police later posted a video on Twitter titled "No Czech Floyd" showing an unidentified half-naked man fighting with another next to a car.[11]
On 30 June 2021, Tomáš' family announced that they would be filing a criminal complaint against Czech police with the European Roma Rights Centre (ERRC). ERRC president Đorđe Jovanović stated that "police harassment, ethnic profiling, brutality, torture, and sometimes even death is the experience for many Roma in Europe when they interact with law enforcement."[12]
After the forensic autopsy and expert opinion, it was announced that the man died of heart failure, which was allegedly not related to the police officer kneeling on his neck in an identical maneuvre to that which killed George Floyd, but rather it was related to his usage of illegal substances that affected not only his heart but also his blood vessels.[13]
On 13 December 2021, the Deputy Ombudsperson (Public Defender of Rights), Monika Šimůnková, published a report which found that the police officers had made at least three significant errors in the arrest of Stanislav Tomáš.[14] For example, the police account stated that Tomáš "rose from the ground on his own, although he was sluggish." However, Šimůnková's report quotes a paramedic's testimony:
(The patient's) hands were cuffed behind his back. The officers were pinning him to the ground just by one arm so that he wouldn't run away. When I approached the patient, I ascertained that he was lying on his abdomen, making no noise, and I checked his carotid artery, but no pulse could be felt. At that moment the patient's circulatory system had stopped, i.e., he was not breathing. Subsequently I insisted he immediately be placed on a stretcher and put into the ambulance.[15]
Reactions
editJan Hamáček, the Czech Minister of the Interior, stated that the police had his full support and that "anybody under the influence of addictive substances who breaks the law has to count on the police intervening."[11] His statement was made in the immediate aftermath of the death and long before the results of the autopsy had been released.
The Council of Europe called for "an urgent, thorough, and independent investigation" into the death.[16] Amnesty International also called for an investigation into the death, stating that kneeling on the neck as a form of restraint was "reckless, unnecessary and disproportionate, and therefore unlawful" and that the Czech government's statements defending the police "can only be understood as giving carte blanche for law enforcement officials to resort to unnecessary or excessive use of force when handling with any person under the influence of drugs, providing a dangerous sense of impunity and being above the law."[17] The Czech Government Council for Romani Minority Affairs stated that "the obvious similarity between this case and the death of the African-American George Floyd after a police intervention in the USA in June 2020 using very similar techniques raises a subject of basic interest to all of society about whether police are using force proportionately during their interventions."[18]
Sebijan Fejzula of the University of Coimbra stated that "the death of Stanislav Tomáš is not an isolated case" and that "Roma are victims of permanent state terror, yet, there is little discussion around the issue of police brutality as a result of structural racism."[19]
Protests
editAfter growing criticism on Police brutality against Romani people, on June 26 people in Teplice commemorated his death, with some coming from as far away as Hungary and Slovakia.[20]
Commemorations organised by Romani NGOs were held in several European cities: On June 25 in Berlin, organised by RomaTrial e.V.[21] On June 27 in Vienna, organised by the Hochschüler*innenschaft Österreichischer Roma und Romnja (HÖR).[22]
On 6 July Kosovo Romani people demonstrated in Pristina and in front of the Czech embassy to Kosovo.[23][24]
Aftermath
editIn March 2022, the General Inspection of Security Forces (GIBS) published the results of their internal investigation into the case. They stated that the police intervention was done in a standard manner, and it was not connected with the subsequent death of the suspect in any way whatsoever.[25] The European Roma Rights Centre called the statement "a denial of justice," while Amnesty International stated that there was "major doubts" about the independence and comprehensiveness of the investigation.[26]
The Czech Constitutional Court dismissed a constitutional appeal in April 2023 brought by the European Roma Rights Centre and the Forum for Human Rights. In August 2023, the organisations filed a case before the European Court of Human Rights on behalf of Tomáš' sister.[27]
References
edit- ^ "Roma see little hope as they mourn 'Czech George Floyd'".
- ^ "Stanislav Tomáš, who died in police custody, laid to rest in Teplice, Czech Republic. Civil society and his family call for his death to be properly investigated". 24 July 2021.
- ^ ""Tschechischer George Floyd": Video zeigt Polizeieinsatz, der später tödlich endete". www.vice.com (in German). Retrieved 25 June 2021.
- ^ Furlong, Ray (November 24, 1999). "Czechs pull down Gypsy wall". BBC. Retrieved 7 July 2013.
- ^ "Europe's Romani Population Can't Breathe".
- ^ "European Public Opinion Three Decades After the Fall of Communism — 6. Minority groups". Pew Research Center. 14 October 2019.
- ^ Jeiří Šťastný (8 February 2012). "Češi propadají anticikánismu, každý druhý tu Romy nechce, zjistil průzkum". Zpravy.idnes.cz. Retrieved 17 May 2012.
- ^ "Death of Romany man knelt on by Czech police must be 'investigated urgently'". the Guardian. 2021-06-23. Retrieved 25 June 2021.
- ^ Welle (www.dw.com), Deutsche. "Czech police deny 'George Floyd' knee-on-neck arrest led to Roma man's death | DW | 22.06.2021". DW.COM. Retrieved 25 June 2021.
- ^ "Activists see George Floyd parallels in video of Czech police officer kneeling on Roma man who later died". Washington Post. Retrieved 25 June 2021.
- ^ a b "'Czech Floyd' Illustrates Struggles of Roma Lives Matter". Balkan Insight. 2021-06-23. Retrieved 25 June 2021.
- ^ "Family of Stanislav Tomáš File Criminal Complaint against Czech Police with ERRC Support".
- ^ "Case closed. Policeman from Teplice are not responsible for Romani's death".
- ^ ČTK (2021-12-13). "Czech Deputy Public Defender of Rights finds police officers made significant errors in the controversial arrest of Stanislav Tomáš". Romea.cz - Everything about Roma in one place (in Czech). Retrieved 2023-06-22.
- ^ "Public Defender finds Czech police at fault in the death of Romani man Stanislav Tomáš". European Roma Rights Centre (in Hungarian). Retrieved 2023-06-22.
- ^ "Czech Republic: Council of Europe calls for urgent independent investigation into Romani man's death".
- ^ "Czech Republic: Concerns over possible unlawful killing by the police". Amnesty International. 2021-06-23. Archived from the original on 2022-10-26.
- ^ "Civil society members of the Czech Govt Roma Council ask Interior Minister to prioritize the thorough investigation of the death of a Romani man after a police intervention". 21 June 2021.
- ^ "The Roma struggle from protests to political liberation".
- ^ "'Roma Lives Matter': Protests Erupt in Teplice". Balkan Insight. 2021-06-28. Retrieved 28 June 2021.
- ^ "GEDENKEN AN STANISLAV TOMÁŠ IN BERLIN THEMATISIERT ANTIZIGANISMUS IN EUROPA" (in German). Retrieved 7 July 2021.
- ^ "Mahnwache in Wien für Stanislav Tomáš" (in German). Retrieved 7 July 2021.
- ^ "Kosovar Protesters Honor Czech Romany Man Who Died In Police Custody". Retrieved 6 July 2021.
- ^ "Roma in Kosovo Protest for Investigation of 'Czech Floyd' Death". Balkan Insight. 6 July 2021. Retrieved 6 July 2021.
- ^ Policisté smrt zatýkaného muže v Teplicích nezavinili, řekla inspekce by Zuzana Mendlová at iDNES.cz, 16 March 2022.
- ^ "Czech and international organizations support bereaved family with Constitutional Court complaint over death of Stanislav Tomáš in police custody". 22 March 2022.
- ^ "Roma Rights Activists Take Police Killing of Stanislav Tomáš to European Court". European Roma Rights Centre. Retrieved 2024-02-05.