The Carthage nursing home shooting was a mass shooting that occurred on March 29, 2009, when a gunman opened fire at Pinelake Health and Rehabilitation, a 120-bed nursing home in Carthage, North Carolina, United States.[1] The shooter, 45-year-old Robert Kenneth Stewart, killed eight people, including a nurse at the home, and wounded a ninth. He was shot and apprehended by the responding police officer, who was also wounded by gunfire.[2] It was the worst mass shooting in North Carolina's history.[3]
| Carthage nursing home shooting | |
|---|---|
  Carthage Carthage (North Carolina) | |
| Location | Carthage, North Carolina, United States |
| Coordinates | 35°20′00″N 79°24′53″W / 35.3332°N 79.4147°W |
| Date | March 29, 2009 (10:00 AM - 10:05 AM.) |
Attack type | Mass shooting, mass murder |
| Weapons | |
| Deaths | 8 |
| Injured | 3 (including the perpetrator) |
| Perpetrator | Robert Kenneth Stewart |
Stewart was said to have intended to kill his estranged wife, a nurse at the nursing home, who had hidden and survived the shooting unharmed. Initially charged with first-degree murder, Stewart was tried in 2011 and convicted on eight counts of second-degree murder. He was sentenced to 179 years, four months, and 20 days.[4]
Shooting
editRobert Stewart, 45, dressed in a bib overall, arrived at the parking lot of the nursing home just before 10:00 a.m., where he fired several shots at the empty car of his estranged wife, shattering its windows.[citation needed] Stewart then fired at the car of visitor Michael Lee Cotten as he was driving into the parking lot, hitting him in the left shoulder. Cotten, who later stated that Stewart was "very calm...very deliberate" during the shooting,[5] managed to run into the building and warn the people inside of the gunman.[citation needed] Police received the first emergency calls at approximately 10:00 a.m. and the only police officer on duty in Carthage, 25-year-old Cpl. Justin Garner, was dispatched to the scene.[6]
Leaving a camouflaged Remington 597 .22 caliber rifle atop a Jeep Cherokee, Stewart entered the nursing home armed with a .357-caliber handgun, a .22 Magnum semi-automatic pistol, and a 12-gauge Winchester 1300 shotgun and went down the hall, apparently searching for his estranged wife, Wanda Neal. She had left him three weeks earlier because of his abusive behavior, drinking, violent temper, and possessiveness. She had been reassigned to the Alzheimer's unit that morning. When she heard the shooting, she hid in a locked and passcode-protected bathroom.[7]
Upon realizing that his wife wasn't where she usually worked, Stewart headed to the area for Alzheimer's patients, which was secured by passcode-protected doors. As he walked through the hallways of the nursing home, Stewart killed seven residents—two of them in their wheelchairs—while the staff tried to move other patients to safety. He shot and killed nurse Jerry Avant, who tried to stop the gunman.[8][9] Avant was the only employee killed.
Police Cpl. Garner confronted Stewart in the hallway at about 10:05 a.m. After refusing several orders to drop his weapon, Stewart lowered his shotgun and fired a shot at Garner, hitting him in the leg.[10] Garner returned fire and hit Stewart in the chest, incapacitating him.[10] Years later, Garner recalled that the wounded Stewart had said only: "Kill me, kill me."[10]
At the end of the shooting, six people were dead at the scene; five others, including Stewart, were taken to a nearby hospital, where two of the wounded died the same day.[1]
Victims
edit
|
|
Aftermath
editStewart was charged with eight counts of first-degree murder.[11][12] On September 3, 2011, a jury convicted Stewart of eight counts of second-degree murder (and several other lesser charges). "The judge imposed the maximum sentence – 15 years, nine months to 19 years, eight months – for each count of murder, with the terms to run consecutively."[13] He was sentenced to a total incarceration term of 179 years, four months, and 20 days.[4][14]
Stewart's defense attorneys, Jonathan Megerian and Franklin Wells of Asheboro, North Carolina, had argued that Stewart was under the influence of Ambien during the shooting, and therefore not capable of premeditation and deliberation, two elements of first degree murder under North Carolina law. He had been taking it for two years prior to the shooting, and defense experts said he was unable to control his actions. The prosecution made the case that he had carried out elaborate planning prior to the attack and on that morning, so he was in control of his actions.[13]
Perpetrator
editRobert Kenneth Wayne Stewart (born September 12, 1963) was born in Robeson County.[15] When he was a young boy, his family moved to Eastwood in Moore County. His father was a house painter, and his mother worked at an office of a paving company in Pinebluff. After finishing middle school in Aberdeen, Stewart attended Pinecrest High School, but dropped out before graduating. Among his peers Stewart was known as a quiet loner, who showed a volatile bad temper at times.[citation needed]
At the age of 18, Stewart married for the first time in 1981; his marriage lasted only for a few months. In 1983 he married then 17-year-old Wanda Gay Neal, but this marriage failed within three years, reportedly due to Stewart's extreme possessiveness, his excess drinking, and his violent temper. Wanda Neal's mother Margaret Neal later stated: "He had a rage, it would just explode over everything. He would be good and then something would just set him off."[16] Both Margaret Neal and Wanda Neal's 14-year-old daughter Jamie said that, as far as they knew, Stewart had never hit his wife.
In 1986 Stewart married again, though he still harbored feelings for his former wife. According to his third wife, Sue Griffin, Stewart would often compare her to Wanda Neal and complain that "Wanda doesn't do it like that."[17]
Stewart worked as a house painter and had his own painting business, but had filed twice for bankruptcy.[citation needed] He had been out of work for over a year before the shooting, after injuring his back and leg.[citation needed] He served six years in the National Guard and never rose above the rank of private before receiving an honorable discharge.[citation needed] In 1995 he joined the Clay Road Farm Hunt Club in Moore County, where he soon alienated the other members because of his drinking problem and his temper. He was eventually thrown out of the hunting club, after threatening Larry Allred, one of its founders.
In 2001, after 15 years of marriage to Sue Griffin, Stewart divorced again and returned to Wanda Neal. After he promised her he would change, stop drinking, and treat her well, they married a second time in June 2002. But as time passed, Stewart again showed extreme possessiveness and would not let his wife go anywhere alone. After he put a gun to her head and threatened to kill her, Wanda Neal left her husband and returned to her parents' home, three weeks prior to the shooting. After his wife had left him, Stewart began calling her family, sometimes at 2:00 or 3:00 a.m., claiming there was an emergency and he needed to see Wanda and her parents. He also tried to contact his former wife, Sue Griffin, through her family, telling them that he was suffering from prostate cancer, that he was preparing to "go away", and that he "was planning on leaving town to visit places he hadn’t seen."[1] According to Mack Hancock, who had seen him in the last week before the shooting, Stewart seemed very depressed, saying that "everything had gone to hell."[6]
As of November 2024, Stewart is housed at the Neuse Correctional Institution in Goldsboro, North Carolina.[4]
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ a b c "Gunman Kills 8 at a N. Carolina Nursing Home", The New York Times (March 29, 2009)
- ^ "Man kills eight at US care home", BBC (March 29, 2009)
- ^ "Dispatches From the Deadliest Mass Shooting in N.C. History". The Pilot. March 29, 2018. Retrieved May 5, 2020.
- ^ a b c "NC DPS Offender Public Information". webapps6.doc.state.nc.us. Retrieved November 16, 2016.
- ^ ABC News (March 31, 2009). "Nursing Home Shooting 'Not a Random Act'". ABC News. Retrieved November 16, 2016.
- ^ a b Dewan, Shaila (March 30, 2009). "Alleged Gunman's Wife Worked at Nursing Home". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved November 16, 2016.
- ^ "North Carolina Nursing Home Gunman's Wife Hid in Bathroom During Rampage", Fox News (March 31, 2009)
- ^ Suspect took 'nerve pills' Archived April 11, 2009, at the Wayback Machine, The News & Observer (April 8, 2009)
- ^ "I never knew he'd take it that far", The Fayetteville Observer (April 1, 2009)
- ^ a b c "Hero in nursing home rampage recalls facing mass murderer". WRAL.com. July 21, 2012. Retrieved November 16, 2016.
- ^ "Town's lone officer subdued N.C. nursing home shooter" Archived April 1, 2009, at the Wayback Machine, The State (March 31, 2009)
- ^ "Warrants: NC man said he doesn’t remember rampage", The News Courier (April 7, 2009)
- ^ a b "Robert Stewart guilty of 2nd-degree murder, sentenced to life in prison", The Fayetteville Observer (September 4, 2011)
- ^ "Man guilty in 8 N.C. nursing home killings". UPI. September 4, 2011. Retrieved May 12, 2024.
- ^ Robert Stewart arrest warrants
- ^ "North Carolina Nursing Home Gunman Had Explosive Temper, Was Prone to Violence", Fox News (April 1, 2009)
- ^ "Officials probe role of relationship in NC rampage", The Guardian (March 31, 2009)