The Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO) is the non-profit organization responsible for operating Alberta, Canada's power grid.[2] AESO oversees the planning and operation of the Alberta Interconnected Electric System (AIES) in a "safe, reliable, and economical" manner.[3][4] It is mandated by provincial legislation to act in the public interest and cannot own any transmission, distribution or generation assets.
 | |
| Company type | Non-profit |
|---|---|
| Industry | Electricity |
| Headquarters | , Canada |
Key people | Michael Law – President and CEO[1] |
| Services | Planning and operation of the Alberta Interconnected Electric System (AIES) |
| Website | www.aeso.ca |
One of AESO's responsibilities is to manage system load in the case where shortfalls in supply or excessive demand for electricity threaten the integrity of the power grid. In this case AESO can direct power companies to shed load temporarily through measures such as rolling blackouts. In July 2012, six power generators were shut down during a major heat wave that resulted in high demand on the power grid, Edmonton, Calgary, Red Deer and Lethbridge were hit by rolling blackouts.[5] AESO directed utilities to reduce their customer load. AESO's Doug Simpson explained that this had not happened since 2006.[5]
According to their homepage, AESO operates "independently of any industry affiliations and owns no transmission or market assets."[3]
Duties and responsibilities
editThe key duties and responsibilities of the AESO are dictated by the Province of Alberta's Electric Utilities Act (EUA) and the Transmission Regulation (T-Reg) and include, without limitation, the following:
- Determine the future requirements of the AIES, develop transmission plans over near-term, medium-term and long-term planning horizons that identify transmission system enhancements needed to meet those requirements, and make arrangements to implement those enhancements as necessary.
- Prepare and maintain a transmission system that anticipates, for at least 20 years forward, system conditions and requirements. The system must be planned to accommodate future growth, which requires the AESO to take a long-term view while adjusting for short-term changes and focusing on system requirements that meet the long-term vision for electrical infrastructure.
- Ensure the safe, reliable and economic operation of the AIES.
- Operate the power pool and facilitate the electricity market in a manner that is fair, efficient and openly competitive.
- Provide transmission access service consistent with an approved transmission tariff.
- Manage and recover the costs associated with line losses and ancillary services.
- Conduct a fair and open competitive process to determine the successful proponent who will develop, design, build, finance, own, operate, and maintain identified major transmission infrastructure in Alberta.
The AESO operates a market for the exchange of electric energy in Alberta and attempts to uphold the principles of market fairness, openness, and efficiency. To this end the AESO "contracts with transmission facility owners to provide generators access to the electric grid."[3]
History
editAlberta electricity policy changed in 1996, with the province restructuring its electricity market away from traditional regulation to a market-based system. The market now includes a host of buyers and sellers, and an increasingly diverse infrastructure.
By 2020, Alberta had 900 wind turbines, which represented approximately 40% of Canada's total at that time.[6] In 2006, wind power provided less than 8% of Alberta's total power generation. AESO had said wind power was not reliable enough because wind doesn't blow consistently. When it drops off, coal and natural gas plants have to take up the slack to avoid power shortages." At that time, Alberta didn't have "enough transmission lines to connect new wind turbines to its power grid."[7]
By 2021, most of the power generators in Alberta used natural gas as the province transitioned away from coal.[8]
AESO announced an all-time record peak electricity demand of 12,187 megawatts was reached on 19 December 2022 during an extended spell of extreme cold. A grid alert was announced when Keephills 3 power plant west of Edmonton experienced an unplanned outage. In Calgary overnight wind chills of -10 combined with -25 C temperature.[9] On 3 January 2022, AESO reported a record high electricity demand of 11,939 megawatts during an extreme cold spell.[9]
In 2016, under then-Premier Notley, the provincial government had set a target of transitioning away from power generation dependent on fossil fuels by using renewables.[2] The goal was to replace 30% of all electricity generation in the province with renewables by 2030.[2]
By December 2022, Alberta had made progress towards reaching the 30% by 2030 target ahead of schedule.[2] According to AESO, in 2017, 59% of Alberta's electricity generators were still using coal; renewables only accounted for 10%. By late 2022, the 18% of the province's electricity came from renewables, many coal-powered plants had converted to natural gas, and it was anticipated that coal generation would be completely phased out by 2023.[2]
Leadership and governance
editAccording to their homepage, AESO operates "independently of any industry affiliations and owns no transmission or market assets."[3] As of November 2023, the AESO executive and board of directors was composed of:
| Name | Position | Background | Compensation
(2022, in CAD$) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michael Law | President/CEO | Project manager at VECO Corporation, associate at Enron, consultant at Duke Energy, VP at Direct Energy Marketing Ltd. | $1,149,555.01 (exceeding contractual compensation limit of $616,000, in Article 5.2)[1] |
| Bill Baker | VP Information Technology | Worked at Canadian Pacific Railway, Department of National Defence, Canadian Net Income Stabilization Account, We Care Health Services | $443,672.98 |
| Robert Davidson | VP Grid Reliability Projects/Planning | Engineer at Mid-continent Area Power Pool (MAPP), engineer at Dairyland Power Cooperative, manager at Enmax, and manager at Primary Engineering and Construction | $392,709.01 |
| Kevin Dawson | VP Strategic Integration | Director of Hedging and Market Analysis at TransAlta | $353,790.13 |
| Nicole Kinch | VP Finance | Business assurance manager of energy/utilities at Moss Adams, senior manager at Rothstein Kass, senior analyst at Suncor Energy, corporate controller at Mustus Energy, and CFO at Wagepoint | $419,673.58 |
| Nicole LeBlanc | VP Markets | Economist at Canadian Energy Research Institute (CERI) | $334,397.95 |
| Brian McGurk | VP People, Culture, Customer Experience | VP HR at Global Thermoelectric (bought by Quantum Fuel Systems in 2003), VP HR at CCS Income Trust, VP at Smart Technologies, EVP at Secure Energy Services, president of people culture & strategy, and board chair at Castle Mountain Resort | $333,023.62 |
| Marie-France Samaroden | VP Grid Reliability Operations | EIT of Leadership Development Program at TransAlta, Campaign Representative at United Way Calgary/Area, and Director of Corporate Operations at AltaLink | $371,477.26 |
| Cameron Bush | Chief Engineer | Worked with Ontario Hydro, City of Calgary Electric System, TransAlta, and AltaLink | $299,782.53 |
| Name | Position | Background | Compensation
(2022, in CAD$) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Karl Johannson | Chair | President/EVP of Canada and Mexico Gas Pipelines at TC Energy, director at Canadian Energy Pipeline Association (CEPA), director at Canadian Gas Association (CGA), director at Canadian Electric Association (CEA), board member at ClearStream Energy Services, board member at Columbia Pipeline Partners LP, and board chair at TC PipeLines | $91,235.20 |
| Stephen Clark | Member | Process Engineer at Novacor Chemicals, Project Engineer at Fluor Corporation, Business Development at Stone & Webster, SVP of Canadian and NE US Gas Pipelines at TC Energy, co-author of 2008 'Calgary 10-Year Plan to End Homelessness', and Board Chair of Canadian Mental Health Association | n/a |
| Aaron Engen | Member | Vice-Chair of Investment/Corporate Banking at BMO Capital Markets, Partner at McCarthy Tétrault, and Board of Governors Member at University of Lethbridge | $54,592.39 |
| Alex Federucci | Member | VP of corporate transformation at Talisman Energy, VP of people at TC PipeLines, VP of business process integration at TC Energy, and board member at Wellspring Alberta | n/a |
| Georgette Habib | Member | Manager at Alberta Energy and Utilities Board, board member at National Energy Board, board of governors member at University of Calgary, president at GE Energy Consulting Ltd., and board member at Alberta Energy Regulator | $45,408.64 |
| Patricia Kaiser | Member | Marketing Director at ARMATA Technologies, VP at MONTAGE IT Services, VP of Marketing at Allstream Inc., VP at Enabil Solutions, COO/SVP at Sierra Energy, Interim President/COO at MacKay CEO Forums, VP at BOWEN Group, and President of Light Industrial at Agilus Work Solutions | $46,429.05 |
| Mike Maxwell | Member | Systems/programmer analyst at Saint John Shipbuilding, manager at Bear Creek Corporation, manager at L.L.Bean, manager of IT at Amirix Systems, director of technical services at Maritime Broadcasting System, director of IT at Halifax International Airport Authority, CIO at Metropolitan Airports Commission, VP/CIO at Calgary Airport Authority, Technology and Innovation at Shannex Incorporated, and aviation leader at OARO Blockchain | $53,061.76 |
| Ann-Marie Osinski | Member | Partner at PwC Canada, senior financial consultant at Canadian Premium Sand Inc. (CPS), CFO at Questor Technology, and committee member at Alberta Securities Commission | $54,082.17 |
High cost of electricity in Alberta
editAccording to a 2013 Edmonton Journal article, Keith Provost, former senior vice-president of Alberta Power Ltd. (now ATCO Electric), with decades of experience in the electrical utilities business, said that instead of marketing electricity contracts for future deliveries in a regulated market, AESO has their own system that is open to manipulation and is not a free-market system. According to AESO, "The pool price is the arithmetic average of the 60 one-minute system marginal prices. Only those offers accepted generate power and receive the AESO pool price. All offers accepted receive the same price, the pool price, not the price offered."[10]
In April 2013, Calgary ranked third (with an average monthly payment of $216[11] based on a monthly consumption of 1,000 kWh) and Edmonton fourth ($202 a month) in Canada compared to other cities in terms of high electricity bills. Halifax placed first and worst in Canada at $225[11] a month. Compared to other cities in North America, Calgary and Edmonton placed seventh and eighth in terms of highest power costs.[12]
The unit price of electricity in Calgary in April 2013 was 14.81 cents per kWh, compared to 6.87 cents per kWh in Montreal, 15.45 in Halifax.[13]
On 1 November 2019, during the premiership of Jason Kenney, the United Conservative Party (UCP) removed the electricity price cap of the regulated rate option (RRO) at 6.8 cents/kW—which had been in place since then-Premier, Rachel Notley's New Democratic Party had set the price cap in 2016.[14]
In Alberta, the residential monthly utilities bill includes the cost of electricity, natural gas, water, delivery fees, and transmission fees, with energy costs representing approximately a third of the total.[8]
According to a 24 February 2022 Canadian Press article, the electricity portfolio of the Calgary-headquartered TransAlta—a utility company—generated a gross margin of $864 million in the three months that ended 31 December 2021, which was $405 million more than its earnings during the same time frame in the previous year.[15]
The price of electricity had increased in 2022, after spiking early in the year.[16] By November 2022, Direct Energy's residential monthly regulated rate option (RRO) increased to 17.597 cents/kWh from 10.483 cents in November 2021, while the Enmax RRO increased 10.66 to 18.245 cents from the same time period.[14] Prices reach record highs in December with predictions of even higher prices in early 2023.[16]
On 2 November, 2023, TransAlta purchased Heartland Generation - the third-largest electricity generation corporation in Alberta - for $658 million. Resultingly, TransAlta now controls 46% of electricity generation in the province, which critics have pointed out gives the company increased incentive and ability to use economic withholding and other monopoly powers to artificially increase electricity prices.[17][18]
See also
editCitations
edit- ^ AESO 2009.
- ^ a b c d e Anderson 2022.
- ^ a b c d Alberta Electric System Operator nd.
- ^ Liebrecht 2009.
- ^ a b CBC News 2012.
- ^ Meyer 2020.
- ^ CBC News 2006.
- ^ a b CBC News 2021.
- ^ a b Graveland 2022.
- ^ Provost 2013.
- ^ a b Hydro Quebec 2013, p. 9.
- ^ Hydro Quebec 2013.
- ^ Hydro Quebec 2013, p. 4.
- ^ a b Chorney 2022.
- ^ CBC News & CP 2022.
- ^ a b Gallant 2022.
- ^ Kinney, Duncan (November 27, 2023). "Proposed Transalta acquisition mean your electricity bills are somehow going to get even worse". Progress Report. Retrieved November 27, 2023.
- ^ Varcoe, Chris (November 2, 2023). "Alberta power market shakeup, as TransAlta buys Heartland Generation for $658M". Calgary Herald. Postmedia. Retrieved November 27, 2023.
References
editA
- "About AESO", Alberta Electric System Operator, nd, retrieved 22 December 2013
- "Profile David Erickson" (PDF), AESO, August 2009, archived from the original (PDF) on 2012-02-27, retrieved 22 December 2013
- Anderson, Drew (7 December 2022). "Guess what? Alberta is on track to meet its 2030 renewable energy goal ahead of schedule". The Narwhal. Retrieved 22 December 2022.
C
- "Alberta's power lines too full for expanding wind farms", CBC News, Calgary, Alberta, 20 October 2006, retrieved 22 December 2013
- "Alberta hit by rolling power blackouts: 'Great concern' grid would go down, Calgary mayor says", CBC News, Edmonton, Alberta, 9 July 2012, retrieved 22 December 2013
- "TransAlta reaps benefits of high Alberta power prices". CBC News and the Canadian press. 24 February 2022. Retrieved 29 March 2022.
- "Experts warn Albertans to lock in gas and electricity rates as prices set to soar". CBC News. Edmonton, Alberta. 13 November 2021. Retrieved 22 December 2022.
- Chorney, Allison (27 November 2022). "Airdrie House and Home: Put a freeze on rising utility costs this winter". Airdrie Today. Airdrie, Alberta. Retrieved 22 December 2022.
G
- Graveland, Bill (21 December 2022). "Frigid temperatures in Alberta prompt grid alert due to strain on electrical system". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 22 December 2022.
- Gallant, Collins (22 December 2022). "Local customers get unheard-of power deal, councillor says". Medicine Hat News. Retrieved 22 December 2022.
H
- "Comparison of Electricity Prices in major North American Cities: Rates in effect April 1, 2013" (PDF), Hydro Quebec, 2013, archived from the original (PDF) on 19 December 2013, retrieved 22 December 2013
L
- Liebrecht, Richard (22 September 2009), Residents want west-end transmission line buried, Sun Media, retrieved 22 December 2013
M
- Meyer, Carl (23 October 2020). "Here's where to find every wind turbine in Canada". Canada's National Observer. Retrieved 27 February 2022.
P
- Provost, Keith (21 December 2013), "Opinion: Unplugging myths about our electricity prices: Consumers bearing the high costs of a faulty, deregulated system", Edmonton Journal, Edmonton, Alberta, archived from the original on 1 February 2014