1894 Ontario prohibition plebiscite

1894 Ontario prohibition plebiscite
Are you in favour of the immediate prohibition by law, of the importation, manufacture and sale of intoxicating liquors as a beverage.
Results

A plebiscite on the legality of alcoholic beverages was held in Ontario, Canada on January 1, 1894. Per the terms of the Prohibition Plebiscite Act passed in 1893, a plebiscite was held on the issue of prohibition in conjunction with the 1894 municipal elections. Though a majority of voters indicated support for prohibition, the results were non-binding and prohibition would not occur in Ontario until 1916.

Plebiscite question

An Act of the Legislature specified the form of the question posed:^[1]

Are you in favour of the immediate prohibition by law, of the importation, manufacture and sale of intoxicating liquors as a beverage.^[2]

Voting only occurred within the various constituted municipalities.^[3] Anyone who lived in unorganized areas of the Province was unable to participate.^[4]

Results

Response	# of votes polled	% of votes polled^[5]
Yes	192,489	63.5
No	110,720	36.5
Total	303,209	100.0

Unmarried women and widows were permitted to vote in the plebiscite, though they voted in a ballot of a different colour (blue for women, yellow for men). Though the plebiscite passed, the results were non-binding and prohibition would not occur in Ontario until 1916.^[2] Provincial prohibition, though having majority support, would face another roadblock in 1896 when the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council determined that provinces do not have the authority to prohibit the importation of alcohol.^[6]

Analysis

1894 Ontario plebiscite - analysis of results by municipality^[7]
Type	Choice	All municipalities				Yes					No
Type	Choice	Male	Female	Total	%	Municipalities	Male	Female	Total	%	Municipalities	Male	Female	Total	%
Counties	Yes	145,504	8,736	154,240	64.75	35	137,838	8,182	146,020	66.60	3	7,666	554	8,220	43.39
	No	82,578	1,382	83,960	35.25		72,049	1,187	73,236	33.40		10,529	195	10,724	56.61
	Total	228,082	10,118	238,200	100.00		209,887	9,369	219,256	100.00		18,195	749	18,944	100.00
	Majority	62,926	7,354	70,280	29.50		65,789	6,995	72,784	33.20		2,863	(359)	2,504	13.22
	Turnout	59.55%					59.62%					58.76%
Districts	Yes	5,136	209	5,345	64.10	7	5,136	209	5,345	64.10	Nil
	No	2,951	42	2,993	35.90		2,951	42	2,993	35.90
	Total	8,087	251	8,338	100.00		8,087	251	8,338	100.00
	Majority	2,185	167	2,352	28.20		2,185	167	2,352	28.20
	Turnout	45.49%					45.49%
Cities	Yes	27,045	3,091	30,136	57.87	11	26,447	3,015	29,462	58.19	1	598	76	674	46.42
	No	21,219	724	21,943	42.13		20,495	670	21,165	41.81		724	54	778	53.58
	Total	48,264	3,815	52,079	100.00		46,942	3,685	50,627	100.00		1,322	130	1,452	100.00
	Majority	5,826	2,367	8,193	15.74		5,952	2,345	8,297	16.38		126	(22)	104	7.16
	Turnout	50.96%					51.15%					45.39%
Separated towns	Yes	2,402	366	2,768	60.28	6	2,201	340	2,541	62.71	2	201	26	227	42.04
	No	1,746	78	1,824	39.72		1,437	74	1,511	37.29		309	4	313	57.96
	Total	4,148	444	4,592	100.00		3,638	414	4,052	100.00		510	30	540	100.00
	Majority	656	288	944	20.56		764	266	1,030	25.42		108	(22)	86	15.92
	Turnout	51.84%					51.56%					54.04%

Only three counties, one city and two separated towns voted No:

Counties

City

Windsor

Separated towns

1894 Ontario plebiscite - analysis of total results^[7]
Choice	Group of municipalities	Male	Female	Total	%
Yes	Counties	145,504	8,736	154,240
	Districts	5,136	209	5,345
	Cities	27,045	3,091	30,136
	Separated towns	2,402	366	2,768
	Total	180,087	12,402	192,489	63.48
No	Counties	82,578	1,382	83,960
	Districts	2,951	42	2,993
	Cities	21,219	724	21,943
	Separated towns	1,746	78	1,824
	Total	108,494	2,226	110,720	36.52
Total votes		288,581	14,628	303,209	100.00
Majority		71,593	10,176	81,769	26.96
Turnout		57.26%

References

^ The Prohibition Plebiscite Act, S.O. 1893, c. 41, Sch. A
^ ^a ^b Johnston & Sage 2007, p. 2.
^ 1891 Act, s. 4
^ 1891 Act, s. 27
^ Johnston & Sage 2007, p. 3.
^ Johnston & Sage 2007, p. 4.
^ ^a ^b "To an Order of the Legislative Assembly, dated the 27th February, 1894, for a Return from the Records of the Votes cast 'Yes' and 'No' on the question of Prohibition on the 1st January last..." Legislative Assembly of Ontario. 1894.

Bibliography

Johnston, Larry; Sage, Rick (2007). "Referendums in Ontario: An Historical Summary" (PDF). Legislative Assembly of Ontario. Archived from the original (PDF) on September 20, 2007. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)

[1] The Prohibition Plebiscite Act, S.O. 1893, c. 41, Sch. A

[FOOTNOTEJohnstonSage20072-2] Johnston & Sage 2007, p. 2.

[3] 1891 Act, s. 4

[4] 1891 Act, s. 27

[FOOTNOTEJohnstonSage20073-5] Johnston & Sage 2007, p. 3.

[FOOTNOTEJohnstonSage20074-6] Johnston & Sage 2007, p. 4.

[1894pleb-7] "To an Order of the Legislative Assembly, dated the 27th February, 1894, for a Return from the Records of the Votes cast 'Yes' and 'No' on the question of Prohibition on the 1st January last..." Legislative Assembly of Ontario. 1894.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]