A balancing authority (BA) is an entity in the US electric system (as well as in parts of Canada and Mexico) that is responsible for grid balancing: resource planning and unit commitment ahead of time, maintenance of the load-interchange-generation balance within a balancing authority area (also known as a control area) and support for real-time load-frequency control.[1] The balancing authorities are connected by metered high-voltage tie lines[2][3] and grouped into interconnections:[4][5]
- Eastern Interconnection consists of 31 balancing authorities in the US and 5 in Canada;
- Western Interconnection consists of 34 balancing authorities in the US, 2 in Canada, and 1 in Mexico;
- Electric Reliability Council of Texas includes a single balancing authority;
- Quebec Interconnection also with a single authority.
Implementation
editA typical balancing authority is an electric utility with an added responsibility to maintain a fine balance between the production and consumption of electricity, including ensuring availability of sufficient on-line generation resources and managing the electricity transfers from (and to) other balancing authorities.[4]
Balancing authorities operation is guided by mandatory reliability standards created by the North American Electric Reliability Corporation and approved by the US (Federal Energy Regulatory Commission) and Canadian regulators.[4] The enforcement authority is delegated to regional entities (8 in the US).[6] To coordinate activities across multiple BAs, a reliability coordinator entity (RC) is used that has the power to reduce or cancel the interchange transactions and adjust the dispatch plans.[7] Frequently the same utility plays multiple roles, for example, CAISO, in addition to being an independent system operator, is also operating under the name RC West as a reliability coordinator for 42 balancing authorities and transmission operators in the Western interconnection.[8] The interactions between the BAs and RCs can be compared to the ones between pilots and air traffic controllers.[3]
A meter on a tie-line is shared between the two BAs interconnected by this line.[9]
Operation
editA balancing authority has the following responsibilities:[6]
- maintaining the balance between load, generation, and external transfers;
- short-term (load-frequency regulation);
- longer-term (load following);
- controlling the frequency and time error;
- implementing the interchange transactions.
The coordination tasks are performed by the balancing authority staff and the automatic generation control (AGC) systems.[6] The quantitative estimate of the balancing is provided through area control error (ACE, measured in MW[10]),[7] that as an indicator is conceptually similar to the role the frequency deviation plays at the interconnection level: positive ACE is pushing interconnection frequency higher.[11]
The operation of a BA is guided by two primary external inputs[9] (that together form the ACE[10]):
- interchange error, a difference between the planned and measured electricity flows through the tie lines;
- frequency bias is a coefficient[12] representing an obligation of the BA to provide or absorb energy in order to maintain the system-wide frequency or to assist in time control, it is a negative number expressed in MW/0.1Hz.[13] As a simple example, if frequency is lower than the 60 Hz target, the BA is typically expected to provide a (usually small) amount of additional power. More precisely, BA might be required to provide more energy if its import exceeds its bias obligation (defined as a product of the frequency bias coefficient and a difference between the actual and target frequency).[14]
To maintain the balance, a BA will dispatch the generators and, in some cases, will control the load[3] with the goal to keep the ACE within predefined limits that are usually set to be proportional to the total load services by the BA. The control is maintained by multiple means: direct control of the generators by the computer systems, dispatch orders to power plants communicated by phone, load shedding in emergencies, and exchanging the electricity with other BAs.[15]
References
edit- ^ Glossary of Terms Used in Reliability Standards. North American Electric Reliability Corporation, p. 2. February 8, 2005.
- ^ PJM. "Tie Lines". PJM Interconnection. Retrieved 22 August 2022.
- ^ a b c NERC 2011, p. 6.
- ^ a b c U.S. electric system is made up of interconnections and balancing authorities. Energy Information Administration (EIA.gov), July 20.2016.
- ^ NERC 2021, pp. 1–2.
- ^ a b c WECC.
- ^ a b NERC 2018, p. 8.
- ^ CAISO. "RC West Entities" (PDF). California Independent System Operator.
- ^ a b NERC 2011, p. 9.
- ^ a b NERC 2011, p. 10.
- ^ NERC 2011, p. 11.
- ^ NERC 2021, p. 11.
- ^ NERC 2021, p. 20.
- ^ NERC 2021, pp. 11–12.
- ^ NERC 2011, pp. 9–10.
Sources
edit- WECC. "Balancing Authority and Regulation Overview" (PDF). wecc.org. Western Electricity Coordinating Council.
- NERC (July 2018). Reliability Functional Model Technical Document Version 5.1 (PDF). North American Electric Reliability Corporation.
- NERC (January 26, 2011). Balancing and Frequency Control (PDF). North American Electric Reliability Corporation.
- NERC (May 11, 2021). Balancing and Frequency Control (PDF). North American Electric Reliability Corporation.
- US Department of Energy. "How it Works: The Role of a Balancing Authority" (PDF). Retrieved 2024-10-04.