Wikipedia

Mary Roberts Rinehart

(Redirected from The butler did it (catchphrase))

Mary Roberts Rinehart (August 12, 1876 – September 22, 1958) was an American writer, often called the American Agatha Christie.[1] Rinehart published her first mystery novel, The Circular Staircase, in 1908, which introduced the "had I but known" narrative style. Rinehart is also considered the earliest known source of the phrase "the butler did it", in her novel The Door (1930), although the exact phrase does not appear in her work and the plot device had been used prior to that time.[2][3] She also worked to tell the stories and experiences of front line soldiers during World War I, one of the first women to travel to the Belgian front lines.[4]

Mary Roberts Rinehart
Mary Roberts Rinehart (1914)
Mary Roberts Rinehart (1914)
BornMary Ella Roberts
(1876-08-12)August 12, 1876
Allegheny City, Pennsylvania (now Pittsburgh), U.S.
DiedSeptember 22, 1958(1958-09-22) (aged 82)
New York City, U.S.
OccupationWriter
GenreMystery fiction
RelativesOlive Louise (Roberts) Barton

Biography

edit
 
Rinehart lunching after a morning's trouting on Flathead River, Glacier National Park (c. 1921)

Rinehart was born Mary Ella Roberts in Allegheny City, Pennsylvania, now a part of Pittsburgh. A sister, Olive Louise, four years Mary's junior, would later gain recognition as an author of children's books and as a nationally syndicated newspaper columnist.[5] Her father was a frustrated inventor, and throughout her childhood, the family often had financial problems. Her father committed suicide when Mary was 19 years old. Tending to be left-handed at a time when that was considered disadvantageous, she was trained to use her right hand instead.

She attended public schools and graduated at age 16, then enrolled at the Pittsburgh Training School for Nurses at Pittsburgh Homeopathic Hospital, where she graduated in 1896. She described the experience as "all the tragedy of the world under one roof." After graduation, she married Stanley Marshall Rinehart (1867–1932), a physician she had met there. They had three sons: Stanley Jr., Alan, and Frederick.

During the stock market crash of 1903, the couple lost their savings, spurring Rinehart's efforts at writing as a way to earn income. She was 27 that year, and produced 45 short stories. In 1907, she wrote The Circular Staircase, the novel that propelled her to national fame. According to her obituary in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in 1958, the book sold 1.25 million copies. Her regular contributions to The Saturday Evening Post were immensely popular and helped the magazine mold American middle-class taste and manners.

In 1911, after the publication of five successful books and two plays, the Rineharts moved to the Pittsburgh suburb of Glen Osborne, where they purchased a large home at the corner of Orchard and Linden Streets called "Cassella." Before they could move into the house, however, Mrs. Rinehart had to have it completely rebuilt because it had fallen into disrepair. "The venture was mine, and I had put every dollar I possessed into the purchase. All week long I wrote wildly to meet the payroll and contractor costs,” she wrote in her autobiography. In 1925, the Rineharts sold the house to the Marks family; the house was demolished in 1969.[6] Today, a Mary Roberts Rinehart Nature Park sits in the borough of Glen Osborne at 1414 Beaver Street, Sewickley, Pennsylvania.[7]

Rinehart's commercial success sometimes conflicted with her expected domestic roles of wife and mother, yet she often pursued adventure, including a job as a war correspondent for The Saturday Evening Post at the Belgian front during World War I.[8] During her time in Belgium, she interviewed Albert I of Belgium, Winston Churchill and Mary of Teck, writing of the latter "This afternoon I am to be presented to the queen of England. I am to curtsey and to say 'Your majesty,' the first time!"[9] Rinehart was working in Europe in 1918 to report on developments to the War Department and was in Paris when the armistice was signed.[10]

 
Rinehart home in Washington, D.C. (1927)

In 1922, the family moved to Washington, DC, when Dr. Rinehart was appointed to a post in the Veterans Administration. She was a member of the Literary Society of Washington from 1932 to 1936.[11] Her husband died in 1932, but she continued to live in Washington until 1935, when she moved to New York City. There she helped her sons found the publishing house Farrar & Rinehart, serving as its director.

She also maintained a vacation home in Bar Harbor, Maine. In 1947, a Filipino chef who had worked for her for 25 years fired a gun at her and then attempted to slash her with knives until other servants rescued her. The chef committed suicide in his cell the next day.[12]

Rinehart suffered from breast cancer, which led to a radical mastectomy. She eventually went public with her story, at a time when such matters were not openly discussed. The interview "I Had Cancer" was published in a 1947 issue of the Ladies' Home Journal; in it, Rinehart encouraged women to have breast examinations.

Rinehart received a Mystery Writers of America special award a year after she published her last novel, and an honorary doctorate in literature from George Washington University.[1]

On November 9, 1956, Rinehart appeared on the interview program Person to Person.[13] She died at age 82 at her apartment at 630 Park Avenue in New York City.[14]

Writing

edit
 
House where Mary Roberts Rinehart lived, and wrote The Circular Staircase at 954 Beech Avenue in the Allegheny West neighborhood of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Rinehart wrote hundreds of short stories, poems, travelogues and articles. Many of her short stories, books, and plays were adapted for movies, such as Bab: A Sub-Deb (1917), The Bat (1926), The Bat Whispers (1930), Miss Pinkerton (1932), and The Bat (1959 remake). The novel The Circular Staircase was first adapted to the screen as a silent film in 1915, and later as an episode in the TV show Climax! in 1956. In 1933 RCA Victor released The Bat as one of the early talking book recordings. She co-wrote the 1920 play The Bat which was later adapted into the 1930 film The Bat Whispers. The latter influenced Bob Kane in the creation of Batman's iconography.

Carole Lombard and Gary Cooper starred in I Take This Woman (1931), an early sound film based on Rinehart's novel Lost Ecstasy (1927).

While many of her books were best sellers, critics were most appreciative of her murder mysteries. Rinehart, in The Circular Staircase (1908), is credited with inventing the "Had-I-but-Known" school of mystery writing. The Had-I-But-Known mystery novel is one where the principal character (frequently female) does things in connection with a crime that have the effect of prolonging the action of the novel. In The Circular Staircase "a middle-aged spinster is persuaded by her niece and nephew to rent a country house for the summer. The gentle, peace-loving trio is plunged into a series of crimes solved with the help of the aunt."[15] Ogden Nash parodied the school in his poem Don't Guess Let Me Tell You: "Sometimes the Had I But Known then what I know now I could have saved at least three lives by revealing to the Inspector the conversation I heard through that fortuitous hole in the floor."

The phrase "The butler did it" is often attributed to Rinehart's novel The Door, in which the butler actually did murder someone, although that exact phrase does not appear in the work.[16][17] The device had been used earlier (for example Herbert Jenkins' 1921 story "The Strange Case of Mr. Challoner"[3]) to the point that in 1928 S.S. Van Dine wrote a critique of mystery novels called "Twenty Rules for Writing Detective Stories" in which he argued that it was a poor choice to have a domestic servant be the murderer.[2][3] Tim Kelly adapted Rinehart's play into a musical, The Butler Did It, Singing. This play includes five lead female roles and five lead male roles.

She followed her initial success with The Man in Lower Ten, another novel that continued to reinforce her fame. After these two, Rinehart published about a book a year. She also wrote a long series of comic stories about Letitia (Tish) Carberry, that was frequented in the Saturday Evening Post over a number of years. This was later made into a series of novels by Rinehart that started with The Amazing Adventures of Letitia Carberry in 1911.

After her fiction writing era, Rinehart worked as a correspondent during World War I. She became "obsessed by the injustice, the wanton waste and cost" of the war, and wrote extensively of the things she had seen in 10 articles for the Saturday Evening Post, which were later republished in the London Times. During this time she interviewed many famous historical figures, including Albert I of Belgium, Winston Churchill, French General Ferdinand Foch, and Mary of Teck. The notes from her interview with Albert the I she sent to President Wilson in the hopes of swaying him from neutrality to fight alongside the Belgians, though it didn't immediately work. Her articles were later published as a collection titled "Kings, Queens and Pawns" in 1915. She never stopped working to serve her country and tell the stories of the men fighting in World War I.[4]

Afterwards, she continued to write many novels and even began writing plays. Although she was greatly remembered for her plays Seven Days in 1909 and The Bat in 1920, Rinehart will always be most remembered for her mystery novels, which paved the way for the current generation of mystery writers.

She had written an autobiography, My Story, in 1931, which later was revised in 1948. During her prime, Rinehart was said to be even more famous than her rival, the great Agatha Christie. At the time of Rinehart's death, her books had sold over 10 million copies.

Works

edit
 
Program for the 1920 play The Bat

Novels

edit
  • The Circular Staircase (1908) Adapted (with Avery Hopwood) for the stage as The Bat
  • The Man in Lower Ten (1909)
  • The Window at the White Cat (1910) Revision of The Mystery of 1122
  • When A Man Marries, or Seven Days (1910) Expansion of Rinehart's 1908 novella Seven Days
  • Where There's a Will (1912)
  • The Case of Jennie Brice (1913)
  • The Street of Seven Stars (1914)
  • The After House: A Story of Love, Mystery and a Private Yacht (1914)
  • K. (1915)
  • Bab, a Sub-Deb (1916)
  • Long Live the King! (1917)
  • The Amazing Interlude (1918)
  • Twenty-Three and a Half Hours' Leave (1918)
  • Dangerous Days (1919)
  • A Poor Wise Man (1920)
  • The Truce of God (1920)
  • Sight Unseen (1921)
  • The Confession (1921)
  • The Breaking Point (1922)
  • The Red Lamp (1925) Alternate title The Mystery Lamp
  • The Bat (1926) Novelization of play, credited to Rinehart and Hopwood, but ghostwritten by Stephen Vincent Benét
  • Lost Ecstasy (1927) Alternate title I Take This Woman
  • This Strange Adventure (1928)
  • Two Flights Up (1928)
  • The Door (1930)
  • The Double Alibi (1932)
  • The Album (1933)
  • The State vs. Elinor Norton (1933)
  • The Doctor (1936)
  • The Wall (1938)
  • The Great Mistake (1940)
  • The Haunted Lady (1942)
  • The Yellow Room (1945)
  • A Light in the Window (1948)
  • The Swimming Pool (1952)

Series

edit

Letitia (Tish) Carberry

edit
  • The Amazing Adventures of Letitia Carberry (1911)
  • Tish: The Chronicle of Her Escapades and Excursions (1916)
  • More Tish (1921)
  • Tish Plays the Game (1926)
  • Tish Marches On (1937)

Hilda Adams

edit
  • The Buckled Bag (1914)
  • Miss Pinkerton (1932) Alternate title The Double Alibi
  • The Haunted Lady (1942) Sequel to Miss Pinkerton
  • Episode of the Wandering Knife (1950)

Short story collections

edit
  • Love Stories (1919)
  • Affinities and Other Stories (1920)
  • Temperamental People (1924)
  • The Romantics (1929)
  • Married People (1937)
  • Familiar Faces: Stories of People You Know (1941)
  • Alibi for Isabel and Other Stories (1944)
  • The Frightened Wife and Other Murder Stories (1953) Special Edgar Award, 1954

Plays

edit

Nonfiction

edit
  • "Faces and Brains," Photoplay, February 1922, p. 47.
  • Kings, Queens, and Pawns: An American Woman at the Front (1915) A collection of Rinehart's reports as a correspondent during World War I
  • Through Glacier Park: Seeing America First with Howard Eaton (1916)
  • The Altar of Freedom: An Appeal to the Mothers of America (1917) An appeal to prepare for the coming war
  • Tenting Tonight: A Chronicle of Sport and Adventure in Glacier Park and the Cascade Mountains (1918) First published in Cosmopolitan (1917)[18]
  • The Out Trail (1923)[19][unreliable source]
  • Nomad's Land (1926)[20]
  • My Story (1931; revised 1948) Rinehart's autobiography

Essays

edit
  • "Isn't That Just Like a Man!" (1920) Available in one volume with "Oh, Well, You Know How Women Are!" by Irvin S. Cobb
  • "Why I Believe in Scouting for Girls"

Film and TV adaptations

edit

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ a b Keating, H.R.F., The Bedside Companion to Crime. New York: Mysterious Press, 1989, p. 170. ISBN 0-89296-416-2
  2. ^ a b TV Tropes - The Butler Did It
  3. ^ a b c Where Did The Phrase The Butler Did It Come From?
  4. ^ a b Atwood, Katherine (2014). Women Heroes of World War I. Chicago Review Press. pp. 186–195. ISBN 978-1-61374-686-8.
  5. ^ "Cloud boat stories by Barton, Olive Roberts, 1880-1957; Winter, Milo, 1888-1956, illustrator". Internet Archives. Retrieved January 23, 2021.
  6. ^ "Mary Roberts Rinehart Nature Park". mrrnaturepark.org. Archived from the original on November 3, 2013.
  7. ^ "Home: Mary Roberts Rinehart Nature Park". mrrnaturepark.org. Archived from the original on April 15, 2013.
  8. ^ MacLeod, Charlotte (1994). "Chapter 20: On Active Duty". Had She But Known: A Biography of Mary Roberts Rinehart. New York: Mysterious Press. ISBN 0-89296-444-8.
  9. ^ Rinehart, Mary. "World War I Notebook – Note Pad with Cover Missing" (PDF). Special Collections Department, University of Pittsburgh. Retrieved October 22, 2013.
  10. ^ Doolittle, Alice. "Mary Roberts Rinehart Papers Finding Aid". Special Collections, University of Pittsburgh. Retrieved April 1, 2013.
  11. ^ Spauling, Thomas M. (1947). The Literary Society in Peace and War. Washington, D.C.: George Banta Publishing Company.
  12. ^ Dubose, Martha Hailey (December 11, 2000). Women of Mystery: The Lives and Works of Notable Women Crime Novelists. St. Martin's Publishing. ISBN 9780312276553.
  13. ^ "Person to Person Episode #4.9 (TV Episode 1956)". IMDb.
  14. ^ "Mary Roberts Rinehart Is Dead; Author of Mysteries and Plays New York Times, September 23, 1958.
  15. ^ Roseman, Mill et al. Detectionary. New York: Overlook Press, 1971. ISBN 0-87951-041-2
  16. ^ "The Straight Dope: In whodunits, "the butler did it." Who did it first?". straightdope.com. September 26, 2003.
  17. ^ Nate Pedersen, "Why do we think the butler did it?", The Guardian, 9 Dec 2010
  18. ^ Roberts Rinehart, Mary (1918). Tenting Tonight: A Chronicle of Sport and Adventure in Glacier Park and Cascade Mountains, with Illustrations.
  19. ^ Roberts Rinehart, Mary (1923). The Out Trail.
  20. ^ Rinehart, Mary Roberts (1926). Nomad's Land. New York: George H. Doran Company.

Further reading

edit
edit
 
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Mary Roberts Rinehart.
 
Wikisource has original works by or about:
Mary Roberts Rinehart

Electronic editions

edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=Mary_Roberts_Rinehart&oldid=1261561774"