Wikipedia

Same-sex marriage in Mississippi

(Redirected from Czekala-Chatham v. Melancon)

Same-sex marriage has been legal in Mississippi since June 26, 2015. On November 25, 2014, U.S. District Court Judge Carlton W. Reeves of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi ruled that Mississippi's ban on same-sex marriage was unconstitutional. Enforcement of his ruling was stayed pending appeal to the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. On June 26, 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Obergefell v. Hodges that the denial of marriage rights to same-sex couples violates the U.S. Constitution. On June 29, Attorney General Jim Hood ordered clerks to comply with the court ruling and issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The Fifth Circuit lifted its stay on July 1, and Judge Reeves ordered an end to Mississippi's enforcement of its same-sex marriage ban. However, until July 2, 2015, several counties in Mississippi continued to refuse to issue marriage licenses, including DeSoto, Jasper, Jones, Newton, Pontotoc, Simpson and Yalobusha.[1][2]

edit

In 1978, a same-sex couple was refused a marriage license. In 1994, another same-sex couple, Todd Emerson and Luis Cintron, applied for a license in Ocean Springs but were rejected.[3]

Restrictions

edit

On August 24, 1996, Governor Kirk Fordice issued an executive order banning same-sex marriage in the state.[4] On January 10, 1997, the Mississippi State Senate passed a bill banning same-sex marriage in the state. On February 5, 1997, the House of Representatives passed the bill, and Governor Kirk Fordice signed it into law on February 12. It went into effect on the same day.[5]

On March 1, 2004, the Mississippi House of Representatives, by a 97 to 17 vote, approved Amendment 1, a constitutional amendment defining marriage as "only between a man and a woman" and denying recognition to same-sex marriages from other jurisdictions. The Mississippi Senate passed it on April 7 by a 51 to 0 vote, and voters approved it on November 4 with 86% of the vote.[6][7][8]

Lawsuits

edit

Campaign for Southern Equality v. Bryant

edit

The Campaign for Southern Equality and two lesbian couples filed suit in federal district court on October 20, 2014, challenging Mississippi's statutory and constitutional denial of marriage rights to same-sex couples. Each of the couples was raising two children and one couple had previously married in Maine. Their principal attorney was Roberta Kaplan, who had argued United States v. Windsor before the U.S. Supreme Court. They named as defendants Governor Phil Bryant and Attorney General Jim Hood, and the Hinds County circuit clerk who denied a marriage license to one of the plaintiff couples.[9][10] U.S. District Court Judge Carlton W. Reeves held a hearing on motions for summary judgment on November 12.[11] He ruled for the plaintiffs on November 25, finding that the state's ban did not survive rational basis review. Although Fifth Circuit precedent prevented him from using a stricter standard when considering discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, he argued at length that the proper standard to use would be "heightened scrutiny" and he suggested the Fifth Circuit consider revisiting the question. He stayed his ruling for 14 days to allow the defendants to request a longer stay from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals or the U.S. Supreme Court.[12][13]

The state defendants asked the Fifth Circuit for a stay pending appeal the next day.[14] This stay was immediately opposed by the plaintiffs,[15] who also filed a motion to expedite the appeal to coincide with hearings for a Texas case, De Leon v. Perry, and a Louisiana case, Robicheaux v. George.[16] On December 4, the Fifth Circuit agreed to expedite the case, but not to consolidate oral arguments with its other same-sex marriage cases.[17] It issued a stay pending appeal the same day.[18] The Fifth Circuit heard oral arguments on January 9, 2015, before Judges Patrick Higginbotham, Jerry Edwin Smith, and James E. Graves Jr.[19]

Czekala-Chatham v. Melancon

edit

A lesbian couple, residents of Mississippi who had married in California in 2008, asked the state to recognize their marriage in order to allow them to divorce. The lawsuit was filed in DeSoto County, in Mississippi's Third District Chancery Court, in September 2013. The Mississippi Attorney General's office intervened in their divorce suit, Czekala-Chatham v. Melancon. The plaintiffs contended that "there can be no legitimate state purpose in allowing bigamous or incestuous couples to divorce and not allowing the same remedy to same-sex couples".[20] The Third District Chancery Court dismissed their case for lack of jurisdiction.[21] On appeal, the Mississippi Supreme Court took jurisdiction and allowed Governor Bryant, represented by the Alliance Defending Freedom, to intervene to support the state's position.[22] That court heard oral arguments on January 21, 2015.[23] On February 24, the court, after noting that all parties agreed proceedings should be stayed pending action by the U.S. Supreme Court in related cases, asked for additional briefs. Six justices supported that request, one objected that nothing would be gained, and two objected that it was only "a delay tactic" and the court should find the state's ban on same-sex marriage unconstitutional.[24]

On July 2, 2015, Attorney General Hood, citing the previous week's decision by the U.S. Supreme Court in Obergefell, asked the court to grant the divorce he had previously opposed.[25] On November 5, 2015, in a 5–4 ruling, the Mississippi Supreme Court remanded the case to the Third District Chancery Court in light of Obergefell. The court ruled that the plaintiffs' requested relief, which the Attorney General had already agreed, was consistent with Obergefell and thus ruled in favor of Czekala-Chatham. Forming the five-justice majority were Justices Bill Waller Jr., Michael K. Randolph, Ann Hannaford Lamar, David A. Chandler, and Randy G. Pierce. Justices Josiah D. Coleman and Jess H. Dickinson each joined each other's dissents, disagreeing with Obergefell and questioning the decision's constitutional authority. Justice Pierce, joined by Chandler, wrote a separate concurrence accusing Justices Coleman and Dickinson of violating their oath of office by refusing to follow a ruling of the U.S. Supreme Court. Justice Leslie D. King, joined by James W. Kitchens, dissented, though they agreed Czekala-Chatham received the proper relief. Justice King wrote that, "While I am satisfied that the right result for Czekala-Chatham has been reached, I believe this Court does a great disservice to the jurisprudence of this State by reaching such result in an order, rather than issuing a precedential opinion. Consequently, I object to issuing this decision via order."[26]

On December 1, 2015, Chancellor Mitchell Lundy, Jr. granted the divorce. He apologized to Czekala-Chatham for denying the original divorce in December 2013, but explained that he felt he had no other choice due to Mississippi's refusal to recognize their marriage at the time.

Obergefell v. Hodges

edit

On June 26, 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Obergefell v. Hodges that the denial of marriage rights to same-sex couples violates the Due Process and Equal Protection clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment. Following the decision, Attorney General Jim Hood said: "The Supreme Court's decision is not immediately effective in Mississippi. It will become effective in Mississippi, and circuit clerks will be required to issue same-sex marriage licenses, when the 5th Circuit lifts the stay" and allows Judge Reeves' order to take effect.[27] Governor Bryant and Lieutenant Governor Tate Reeves condemned the ruling. State Representative Andy Gipson, chair of the Mississippi House Judiciary Committee, suggested the state should consider having "no marriage certificate sponsored by the state".[28]

The plaintiffs filed a motion the same day asking the Fifth Circuit to lift its stay of that order. Attorney General Hood did not oppose that motion, but Governor Bryant did.[29] On June 29, Hood issued an email to county clerks to clarify his earlier statement which, he wrote, "seems to have been misinterpreted as prohibiting Circuit Clerks from issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples. The statement was merely meant to explain that an order of the Fifth Circuit would be necessary to lift the stay." He wrote: "Obergefell is the law of the land. If a clerk has issued or decides to issue a marriage license to a same-sex couple, there will be no adverse action taken by the Attorney General against that circuit clerk on behalf of the State.... On the other hand, a clerk who refuses to issue a marriage license to a same-sex couple could be sued by the denied couple and may face liability."[30] On July 1, the Fifth Circuit lifted its stay and returned the Campaign for Southern Equality case to the district court,[31] where Judge Reeves ordered Mississippi and its agents to cease enforcing the state's constitutional and statutory restrictions on same-sex marriage.[32] The last counties in Mississippi to refuse to issue marriage licenses, DeSoto, Jasper, Jones, Newton, Pontotoc, Simpson and Yalobusha counties, began issuing licenses on July 2, 2015.[1][2]

The first same-sex couple to marry in Mississippi were Amber Hamilton and Annice Smith in Hattiesburg on June 26, just hours before Attorney General Hood instructed county clerks to wait for the Fifth Circuit to lift its stay.[33]

Developments after legalization

edit

On June 27, 2016, a federal judge ruled that county clerks in Mississippi may not recuse themselves from issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples based on their religious beliefs. U.S. District Judge Carlton W. Reeves ruled that the recusals on religious grounds granted by the Religious Liberty Accommodations Act violated Obergefell v. Hodges.[34][35] The decision was overturned on appeal by the Fifth Circuit on June 23, 2017, in Barber v. Bryant, on the grounds that the plaintiffs in this case lacked standing.[36]

The Mississippi Supreme Court ruled in Strickland v. Day in April 2018 that married same-sex couples should have the same parental rights as married opposite-sex couples. The court overturned the decision of a trial court that Strickland, a non-biological lesbian mother who was denied legal parentage for a boy she and her ex-wife had raised together, was not a parent. The court named Strickland on her son's birth certificate as a parent, and remanded the case to trial court for matters considering child support and custody.[37]

Native American nations

edit

The Domestic Relations Code of the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians recognizes all marriages which have been validly performed in another jurisdiction. The code defines marriage as "a personal consensual relationship arising out of a civil contract", and does not expressly forbid same-sex marriages.[38] On May 4, 2016, the Assistant Attorney General, Cheryl Hamby, stated in an official opinion that due to its recognition of Mississippi state law as a "valid means for marriage, same sex marriage is valid in tribal court. Additionally, the tribe will recognize a Mississippi same-sex marriage licence."[39]

While there are no records of same-sex marriages as understood from a Western perspective being performed in Native American cultures, there is evidence for identities and behaviours that may be placed on the LGBT spectrum. It is likely that Choctaw society had a designation like two-spirit for individuals who were born male but wore women's clothing and performed everyday household work and artistic handiwork which were regarded as belonging to the feminine sphere, but a lot of traditional knowledge was lost in the aftermath of colonization and the Trail of Tears for those Choctaw forcibly removed to the Indian Territory.[40] In the Choctaw language, two-spirit people are known as ohoyo holba (pronounced [ohoːjó hólba]),[41] though the term is relatively modern. Choctaw author LeAnne Howe stated in a 2022 book, "Often they weren't just involved with other men but had many levels of relationships. They were also involved with our community in very special ways. They could be healers. They're people that protected our children because they embodied more than one thing. And what is part of Choctawan aesthetics is that we revere things that are unusual. Different. When you look at the spirit that's connected in [ohoyo holba], and when they put on that dress in olden times, they are saying 'the embodiment of many'." Some female-bodied two-spirit individuals use the term hattak holba (pronounced [hat.ták hólba]).[42] It is unknown if Choctaw two-spirit individuals were historically allowed to marry.

Demographics and marriage statistics

edit

Data from the 2000 U.S. census showed that 4,774 same-sex couples were living in Mississippi. Same-sex couples lived in all counties of the state, and constituted 0.8% of coupled households and 0.5% of all households in the state. Most couples lived in Hinds, Harrison and Rankin counties, but the counties with the highest percentage of same-sex couples were Tallahatchie (0.82% of all county households) and Marshall (0.74%). Same-sex partners in Mississippi were on average younger than opposite-sex partners, and more likely to be employed. However, the average and median household incomes of same-sex couples were lower than different-sex couples, and same-sex couples were also far less likely to own a home than opposite-sex partners. Individuals in same-sex relationships were also significantly more likely to be African American; 46% of people in same-sex unions were African American compared to 20.5% of people in married opposite-sex unions. 35% of same-sex couples in Mississippi were raising children under the age of 18, with an estimated 2,839 children living in households headed by same-sex couples in 2005.[43]

The 2020 U.S. census showed that there were 3,100 married same-sex couple households (1,173 male couples and 1,927 female couples) and 2,837 unmarried same-sex couple households in Mississippi.[44]

Domestic partnerships

edit

On September 5, 2014, the City Council of Starkville voted 7–0 in favor of an ordinance establishing domestic partner benefits for city employees in same-sex relationships.[45] On January 6, 2015, the Council voted 5–2 to repeal the ordinance passed in September.[46][47] On January 8, Mayor Parker Wiseman vetoed the repeal,[48] but on January 21, the Council voted 5–2 to override Wiseman's veto and repeal the domestic partnership ordinance.[49]

Public opinion

edit

In a 2016 Public Religion Research Institute (PRRI) poll, Mississippi was one of the only three U.S. states where a majority of residents opposed same-sex marriage, alongside Arkansas and West Virginia. In 2021, Mississippi was the state with the highest opposition to same-sex marriage in the country according to the PRRI.

Public opinion for same-sex marriage in Mississippi
Poll source Dates administered Sample size Margin of error Support Opposition Do not know / refused
Public Religion Research Institute March 9 – December 7, 2023 167 adults ± 0.82%1 50% 46% 4%
Public Religion Research Institute March 11 – December 14, 2022 ? ? 49% 48% 3%
Public Religion Research Institute March 8 – November 9, 2021 ? ? 44% 55% 1%
Public Religion Research Institute January 7 – December 20, 2020 286 adults ? 47% 33% 20%
Public Religion Research Institute April 5 – December 23, 2017 586 adults ? 42% 48% 10%
Public Religion Research Institute May 18, 2016 – January 10, 2017 833 adults ? 37% 56% 7%
Public Religion Research Institute April 29, 2015 – January 7, 2016 753 adults ? 25% 65% 10%
Public Religion Research Institute April 2, 2014 – January 4, 2015 536 adults ? 32% 61% 7%
New York Times/CBS News/YouGov September 20 – October 1, 2014 826 likely voters ± 4.5% 29% 56% 15%
Public Policy Polling November 15–17, 2013 502 voters ± 4.4% 22% 69% 9%
Greenberg Quinlan Rosner Research/Target Point Consulting June 26 – July 9, 2013 640 adults ± 3.9% 36% 55% 9%
Public Policy Polling November 4–6, 2011 796 likely voters ± 3.5% 13% 78% 9%

Notes:

  • 1 The margin of error for the national survey was ± 0.82 percentage points at the 95% level of confidence, including the design effect for the survey of 1.56.

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ a b Desoto county won't issue same-sex marriage licenses
  2. ^ a b Circuit court clerks refusing to issue same-sex marriage licenses
  3. ^ "Legal Marriage Court Cases". Buddybuddy.com. Retrieved June 29, 2014.
  4. ^ "Mississippi Governor Bans Same-Sex Marriage". New York Times. August 24, 1996. Retrieved November 26, 2014.
  5. ^ Senate Bill 2053
  6. ^ "PROTECTING LIFE: ADHERENCE TO THE RULE OF LAW AND JUDICIAL RESTRAINT IN MISSISSIPPI" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on September 23, 2015. Retrieved November 26, 2014.
  7. ^ House Concurrent Resolution 56
  8. ^ Roberts, Joel (November 2, 2004). "11 States Ban Same-Sex Marriage". CBS News. Associated Press. Retrieved November 26, 2014.
  9. ^ "Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief". U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Mississippi. October 20, 2014. Retrieved October 20, 2014.
  10. ^ Lavers, Michael K. (October 20, 2014). "Roberta Kaplan representing plaintiffs in Miss. marriage lawsuit". Washington Blade. Retrieved October 20, 2014.
  11. ^ Foxx, Keegan (November 12, 2014). "Hearing held in lawsuit challenging Mississippi's ban on gay marriage". WAPT. Retrieved November 12, 2014.
  12. ^ Snow, Justin (November 25, 2014). "Federal judge rules Mississippi same-sex marriage ban unconstitutional". Metro Weekly. Retrieved November 25, 2014.
  13. ^ Geidner, Chris (November 25, 2014). "Mississippi's Same-Sex Marriage Ban Is Unconstitutional, Federal Judge Rules". BuzzFeed News. Retrieved November 25, 2014.
  14. ^ "State's Motion for Stay Pending Appeal". Scribd.com. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Retrieved November 26, 2014.
  15. ^ "Plaintiffs Opposition to Stay". Scribd.com. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Retrieved November 29, 2014.
  16. ^ "Plaintiffs' Motion to Expedite Appeal". Scribd.com. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Retrieved November 29, 2014.
  17. ^ "Order on motion to expedite". Scribd.com. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Retrieved December 4, 2014.
  18. ^ "Order and Opinion: Stay pending appeal granted". Scribd.com. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals. Retrieved December 4, 2014.
  19. ^ Geidner, Chris (January 9, 2015). "Federal Appeals Court Appears Poised To Strike Down Three Southern States' Same-Sex Marriage Bans". BuzzFeed News. Retrieved January 9, 2015.
  20. ^ "Some states see fight for right to same-sex divorce". Fox News. December 1, 2013. Retrieved January 18, 2014.
  21. ^ Maxey, Ron (December 2, 2013). "Judge rejects Mississippi woman's divorce request in same-sex marriage". The Commercial Appeal (Memphis). Retrieved January 18, 2014.
  22. ^ Baume, Matt (September 19, 2014). "Southern Governor Fights Same-Sex Marriage — And Lesbian Divorce". The Advocate. Retrieved September 23, 2014.
  23. ^ Amy, Jeff (January 22, 2015). "Mississippi court hears arguments over same-sex divorce". Clarion-Ledger. Retrieved February 4, 2015.
  24. ^ "En Banc Order". Scribd.com. Supreme Court of Mississippi. Retrieved February 26, 2015.
  25. ^ Elliott Jr., Jack (July 3, 2015). "Mississippi AG: Let same-sex couple divorce". Associated Press. Retrieved July 6, 2015.
  26. ^ "LAUREN BETH CZEKALA-CHATHAM" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on November 23, 2015. Retrieved November 6, 2015.
  27. ^ "Mississippi in limbo over high-court's same-sex marriage ruling". Los Angeles Times. June 27, 2015.
  28. ^ Pender, Geoff (June 26, 2015). "Lawmaker: State could stop marriage licenses altogether". The Clarion-Ledger. Retrieved June 29, 2015.
  29. ^ "Appellees' Motion for Immediate Lifting of Stay and Issuance of Mandate". June 26, 2015.
  30. ^ Royals, Kate (June 29, 2015). "AG gives clerks OK for same-sex marriage licenses". The Clarion-Ledger. Retrieved June 29, 2015.
  31. ^ "Mississippi 5th Circuit Opinion". Equality Case Files. Retrieved July 1, 2015.
  32. ^ "Permanent Injunction" (PDF). Retrieved July 1, 2015.
  33. ^ "Weddings, then a halt in Mississippi". Greenfield Recorder. Tupelo, Mississippi. July 5, 2015.
  34. ^ Whitcomb, Dan (June 27, 2016). "Mississippi clerks cannot claim religious exception to gay marriage: judge". Reuters.
  35. ^ Judge: Mississippi law creates inequality for gay marriage
  36. ^ Dreher, Arielle. "House Bill 1523 Becomes Law after 5th Circuit Overturns Injunction". Retrieved September 25, 2018.
  37. ^ "Victory! Mississippi Supreme Court Rules That Lesbian Spouses Are Both Legal Parents to Their Marital Children". Lambda Legal. April 5, 2018.
  38. ^ "Choctaw Domestic Relations Code" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on December 5, 2014. Retrieved November 29, 2014.
  39. ^ "Attorney General Opinion Regarding Same Sex Marriage in MBCI Tribal Court" (PDF). Office of the Attorney General of the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians. May 4, 2016. Archived from the original (PDF) on November 20, 2021.
  40. ^ Sabine Lang (1998). Men as women, women as men: changing gender in Native American cultures. University of Texas Press. ISBN 0-292-74701-2.
  41. ^ "Choctaw Dictionary". dictionary.choctawnation.com. Archived from the original on February 3, 2023. Retrieved April 27, 2024.
  42. ^ Pratt, Minnie Bruce (January 11, 2020). "The Queer South: Where the past is not past, and the future is now". Scalawag magazine.
  43. ^ "Census Snapshot" (PDF). Williams Institute. Retrieved August 30, 2022.
  44. ^ "PCT1405 Couple Households, By Type". United States Census Bureau. Retrieved December 11, 2023.
  45. ^ Starkville becomes first Miss. city to extend domestic partner benefits to LGBT city workers
  46. ^ Starkville passes equality resolution supporting LGBT residents, others
  47. ^ Mississippi town rescinds health coverage for unmarried domestic partners
  48. ^ "Starkville mayor vetoes board's repeal of equality resolution". Archived from the original on January 16, 2015. Retrieved January 21, 2015.
  49. ^ Starkville, Mississippi Officials Override Mayor's Veto, Repeal Historic Gay-Rights Initiatives
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wiki.x.io/w/index.php?title=Same-sex_marriage_in_Mississippi&oldid=1256482986#Czekala-Chatham_v._Melancon"