The Subversion of Christianity is an essay written in 1984 by Jacques Ellul and published by Éditions du Seuil. Released four years before Anarchy and Christianity, it offers a anarchist and Christian reflection on Christianity.
| Author | Jacques Ellul |
|---|---|
| Original title | La subversion du christianisme |
| Language | French |
| Subject | Christian anarchism Feminism |
| Genre | Non fiction |
Publication date | 1984 |
| Publication place | France |
The author argues that the message and actions of Jesus were fundamentally radical and anti-political. These, however, would have been corrupted through various dynamics, including Christians’ participation in the State and their increasing collusion with money. Ellul also presents feminist ideas, notably suggesting that the centrality of Mary in Christianity contributed to the establishment of patriarchy by creating a distinction between "ordinary" women and the mother of Jesus.
Contents
editThe work begins with a conclusion drawn by the author: Christianity would have distorted the message of the Gospels.[1] Christians, he argues, failed to resist "political contaminations" during the conversion of the Roman Empire.[1] The same occurred with economic issues, particularly with the rise of capitalism, as well as with religious matters, as other religions influenced Christianity.[1] The institutional Church, according to Ellul, embodies this subversion,[2] making this one of his most controversial texts regarding the Church.[3]
Ellul contrasts this negative subversion—dominated by the State or money—with a positive subversion, which he claims was preached by Jesus.[1] Christians, he argues, are called to subvert society by engaging in critical reflection and action "against the powers of money, political authority, and even the religious domain itself". The thinker also critiques the concept of a purely transcendent God, claiming that this transcendence gave rise to modern nihilism.[4] He does not spare Christian anarchism either, criticizing it for absolutizing politics.[4]
The work is heavily influenced by the philosophy of Kierkegaard,[5][6] whom Ellul quotes directly in a passage questioning the "massification" of Christian conversion in the 4th century.[6] Ellul also advances feminist ideas, notably by asserting that the centrality of Mary in Christianity facilitated the establishment of patriarchy by creating a distinction between "ordinary" women and the mother of Jesus.[7]
Moreover, Ellul insists that Jesus was fundamentally nonviolent.[8]
References
edit- ^ a b c d Bourgine, Benoît (2012). "L'avenir d'une subversion:L'humanisme évangélique à l'heure de la modernité liquide". Études théologiques et religieuses (in French). 87 (3): 315–330. doi:10.3917/etr.0873.0315. ISSN 0014-2239.
- ^ Ivan, Andrei (2013), Jerónimo, Helena M.; Garcia, José Luís; Mitcham, Carl (eds.), "Social Intolerability of the Christian Revelation: A Comparative Perspective on the Works of Jacques Ellul and Peter L. Berger", Jacques Ellul and the Technological Society in the 21st Century, Philosophy of Engineering and Technology, vol. 13, Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands, pp. 219–228, doi:10.1007/978-94-007-6658-7_16, ISBN 978-94-007-6658-7, retrieved 2024-12-08
- ^ Davis, Richard A. (2018), Rodkey, Christopher D.; Miller, Jordan E. (eds.), "Jacques Ellul", The Palgrave Handbook of Radical Theology, Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp. 187–202, doi:10.1007/978-3-319-96595-6_12, ISBN 978-3-319-96595-6, retrieved 2024-12-08
- ^ a b Cassan, Margaux (2022-05-31). "L'anarchisme chrétien". Études (in French) (6): 79–90. doi:10.3917/etu.4294.0079. ISSN 0014-1941.
- ^ Nerhot, Patrick (1986). "Une sociologie de la Technique". ARSP: Archiv für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie / Archives for Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy. 72 (1): 75–93. ISSN 0001-2343. JSTOR 23680597.
- ^ a b Stewart, Jon, ed. (2016). Kierkegaard's influence on philosophy: Volume 11, Tome 2: Francophone philosophy. Kierkegaard research. London New York: Routledge. ISBN 978-1-315-23486-1.
- ^ GENEVIÈVE MORIN-L’HEUREUX (2021). "Le monstre en moi ne lâche pas l'affaire" : récupération féministe de la Vierge Marie dans Rosemary's Baby et Alien (mémoire) (PDF) (in French). UQAM: UQAM.
- ^ Gill, David W. (2018). Political Illusion and Reality: Engaging the Prophetic Insights of Jacques Ellul. David Lovekin. La Vergne: Wipf and Stock Publishers. ISBN 978-1-5326-4908-0.